Links Of Interest
Journal Authors
Subscribe Reviewers
Shopping Cart Continuing Education
 
 

Chronological List of Articles


Volume 26, 2001
ISSN 0361-7734

Number 1
Number 2
Number 3
Number 4
Number 5
Number 6
Supplement 6


JANUARY-FEBRUARY, Volume 26, Number 1

Editorial

Regarding Dinosaurs

Dr Michael A Cochran


Clinical Research

Comparative In Vivo and In Vitro Investigation of Interfacial Bond Variability.

M Hannig • C Friedrichs.

Clinical Relevance:
SEM-analysis of the interfacial adaptation between composite resins and cavity walls located in dentin indicates that the internal seal of totally bonded adhesive resin restorations varies considerably in vivo and in vitro.

SUMMARY:
This comparative in vivo/in vitro study investigated the interfacial adaptation between dentin and composite resins in totally bonded adhesive restorations placed under clinical and laboratory conditions in the same tooth. Cavities were prepared in buccal or lingual surfaces of 47 third-molar teeth scheduled for extraction and randomly assigned for treatment with the following bonding systems/restorative materials: Clearfil Liner Bond 2/Clearfil AP-X (Group I, n=10), Resulcin AquaPrime+Monobond/MFR Merz (Group II, n=9), Prime&Bond 2.1/Dyract AP (Group III, n=9), Scotchbond Multi-Purpose/Z-100 (Group IV, n=10), and Ecusit Primer AB-Mono/Ecusit (Group V, n=9). In Group V, a thin layer of a low-viscous compomer (Primaflow) was interposed between the dentin and the composite resin during restoration placement (according to the manufacturer’s directions). After extraction a second filling was placed in each tooth with identical materials in the same manner as in vivo. The restoration-dentin interface was evaluated in longitudinally cut sections of the specimens by SEM-analysis, and the frequency of gap formation between restoration and dentin was calculated. Median percentages for the in vivo/in vitro frequency of interfacial gap formation were 29.2%/13.9% in Group I, 33.3%/20.0% in Group II, 40%/5.3% in Group III, 53.9%/30.4% in Group IV and 13.8%/0% in Group V. Comparison of gap formation frequency between fillings placed in vivo and in vitro revealed significant differences (p<0.05) in Groups II, III and IV. However, in Groups I and V the internal adaptation was not significantly different between in vivo and in vitro applied restorations. A significant (p<0.01) correlation (Spearman-Rho rank correlation coefficient) was found for the corresponding in vivo and in vitro fillings placed in the individual teeth with regard to interfacial gap formation. It was concluded that achievement of a completely gap-free internal adaptation between restorative material and dentin in totally bonded composite-resin restorations is difficult to predict under in vivo as well as in vitro conditions.

Two-Year Clinical Performance of a Polyacid-Modified Resin Composite and a Resin-Modified Glass-Ionomer Restorative Material.

WW Brackett • WD Browning • JA Ross • MG Brackett.

Clinical Relevance:
The resin-modified glass ionomer material appears to be superior to the polyacid-modified resin composite material in restoration of cervical erosion/abfraction lesions.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the clinical performance of a polyacid-modified resin composite and a resin-modified glass-ionomer restorative material over two years. Thirty-four pairs of restorations of Compoglass and Fuji II LC were placed in caries-free cervical erosion/abfraction lesions without tooth preparation. Restorations were clinically evaluated at baseline, 6, 12, 18 and 24 months using modified Ryge/USPHS criteria. A significantly higher incidence of failed restorations was found with the polyacid-modified resin composite (p<0.05).

Clinical Evaluation of a Resin-Modified Glass Ionomer Adhesive System -- Results after Three Years.

MJ Tyas • MF Burrow.

Clinical Relevance:
Fuji Bond LC was highly successful in the bonding of a microfill and a hybrid resin composite in non-carious cervical lesions.

SUMMARY:
One hundred non-carious cervical lesions were restored with either Silux Plus or Estio LC resin composite using Fuji Bond LC as the bonding agent. Thirteen patients of mean age 60.5 years participated in the study. The retention rate at three years was: Silux Plus, 94%; Estio LC, 100%; total, 97%. Marginal discoloration of aesthetic significance was present around three restorations, two of which were in one patient.


Laboratory Research

Selected Mechanical Propertied of Fluoride-Releasing Restorative Materials.

G Iazzetti • JO Burgess • D Gardiner.

Clinical Relevance:
There are significant differences in the mechanical properties of the various types of fluoride-releasing, tooth-colored restorative materials. These differences should be taken into consideration when selecting a fluoride-releasing material for a particular clinical application.

SUMMARY:
One hundred non-carious cervical lesions were restored with either Silux Plus or Estio LC resin composite using Fuji Bond LC as the bonding agent. Thirteen patients of mean age 60.5 years participated in the study. The retention rate at three years was: Silux Plus, 94%; Estio LC, 100%; total, 97%. Marginal discoloration of aesthetic significance was present around three restorations, two of which were in one patient.

Influence of the Direction of the Tubules on Bond Strength to Dentin.

M Ogata • M Okuda • M Nakajima • PNR Pereira • H Sano • J Tagami.

Clinical Relevance:
The direction of the dentinal tubules appears to be an important variable determining bond strength to dentin. This may be one of the reasons that the bond strengths of the resin are not uniform inside a cavity.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of the direction of dentinal tubules on resin-dentin tensile bond strength (µTBS) using four commercially available bonding systems and observed the resin-dentin interfaces with an SEM. The dentin bonding systems used in this study were Clearfil Liner Bond II (LB, Kuraray), Imperva Fluoro Bond (FB, Shofu), Single Bond (SB, 3M) and One-Step (OS, BISCO). Thirty-six extracted caries-free human molars were used for micro tensile bond testing and eight additional teeth were used for scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The teeth were divided into two groups according to the direction of the dentinal tubules at the resin-dentin interface: a perpendicular group, in which the occlusal enamel was removed perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth, and a parallel group, in which the mesial half of the tooth was removed parallel to the long axis of the tooth, and the coronal dentin surface was used for bonding. After the flat dentin surfaces were polished with #600 silicon carbide paper, each surface was treated with one of the four adhesive systems according to the manufacturer’s recommendation, then covered with resin composite (Clearfil AP-X, Kuraray) to provide sufficient bulk for micro-tensile bond testing. After 24 hours in 37°C water, the resin-bonded teeth were serially sliced perpendicular to the adhesive surface, the adhesive interface trimmed to a cross sectional area of 1 mm2 an subjected to tensile forces at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min. Statistical analysis of the tensile bond strengths were performed using two-way ANOVA and Fisher’s PLSD test at 95% level of confidence. The tensile bond strength of the group with tubules parallel to the bonded interface was higher than that of tubules cut perpendicularly. This tendency reached statistical significance using SB and OS.

Inhibition of Artificial Secondary Caries in Root by Fluoride-Releasing Restorative Materials.

Y Torii • T Itota • M Okamoto • S Nakabo • M Nagamine • K Inoue.

Clinical Relevance:
Resin-modified glass-ionomer cements inhibit secondary caries more effectively with larger amounts of fluoride release than compomers and resin composites.

SUMMARY:
This investigation evaluated the fluoride-releasing properties of various fluoride-releasing restorative materials, including resin-modified glass-ionomer cements (Fuji ionomer TypeII LC, Photac-Fil Aplicap, Vitremer), compomers (Ionosit FIL, Compoglass, Dyract) and fluoride-releasing resin composites (Heliomolar radiopaque, Degufill mineral). The study also estimated the effects of those materials on the inhibition of artificial secondary caries around restorations using a bacterial caries-inducing system. The amount of fluoride released from the materials in deionized water was measured every one week for 10 weeks. Class V cavities with the gingival margin located in the root were prepared in extracted human premolars and restored with each of the materials. The restored teeth were incubated in the bacterial artificial caries chamber, and the artificial lesion created around the restoration was observed microradiographically. The resin-modified glass-ionomer cements released the largest amount of fluoride and created a thick radio-opaque zone in the artificial lesion along the restoration-dentin interface. These results indicated that the fluoride-releasing restorative materials have the potential to inhibit secondary caries formation around restorations. Resin-modified glass-ionomer cements presented a particularly strong effect, compared with compomers and fluoride-releasing resin composites.

Shear Bond Strength of Four Filled Dentin Bonding Systems.

JR Gallo • R Comeaux • B Haines • X Xu • JO Burgess.

Clinical Relevance:
The addition of filler to a dentin adhesive system does not determine bond strength. Agitation of the bonding system may improve bond strength of dentin bonding systems.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the shear bond strength of four filled dentin bonding agents (Prime & Bond NT, One Coat Bond, OptiBond Solo, PermaQuik1) to a conventional unfilled Dentin Bonding agent (3M Scotchbond Multipurpose Plus). A column of composite resin (Herculite XRV Restorative Resin) was bonded to human dentin using the five dentin-bonding systems following the manufacturers’ directions. The specimens were thermocycled 1000 cycles from 6 to 60°C. Each specimen was tested on an MTS machine in shear-to-failure. The data were subjected to One-Factor ANOVA and Newman-Kuels post-hoc tests. Statistical analysis revealed that One Coat Bond had significantly greater shear bond strength than all other materials tested.

Effect of Delayed Application on Shear Bond Strength of Four Fifth-Generation Bonding Systems.

JR Gallo • JO Burgess • X Xu.

Clinical Relevance:
Although significant differences existed between materials, 10 minute delayed application of dispensed fifth-generation bonding systems had no significant difference on shear bond strength.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the shear bond strength of four filled dentin bonding agents (Prime & Bond NT, One Coat Bond, OptiBond Solo, PermaQuik1) to a conventional unfilled Dentin Bonding agent (3M Scotchbond Multipurpose Plus). A column of composite resin (Herculite XRV Restorative Resin) was bonded to human dentin using the five dentin-bonding systems following the manufacturers’ directions. The specimens were thermocycled 1000 cycles from 6 to 60°C. Each specimen was tested on an MTS machine in shear-to-failure. The data were subjected to One-Factor ANOVA and Newman-Kuels post-hoc tests. Statistical analysis revealed that One Coat Bond had significantly greater shear bond strength than all other materials tested.

In Vitro Evaluation of Secondary Caries Development in Enamel and Root Dentin Around Luted Metallic Restoration.

RS Shinkai • AADB Cury • JA Cury.

Clinical Relevance:
Despite its believed cariostatic potential, the resin-modified glass-ionomer luting agent tested was not able to inhibit demineralization on enamel and root dentin margins of luted metallic restorations.

SUMMARY:
Materials that release fluoride have been recommended for patients with high caries risk, but there is no conclusive evidence of their effect on fixed prostheses abutments. This study evaluated the influence of a resin-modified glass-ionomer cement on in vitro caries development in enamel and root dentin around metallic restoration. The cervical portion of 12 human third molars were sectioned in four blocks that were randomly divided into four Groups (n=12; 1 block from each tooth/group): ZP (restoration + zinc phosphate cement), GI (restoration + resin-modified glass-ionomer cement), C1 (no restoration and no pH cycling), and C2 (no restoration and pH cycling). In ZP and GI, metallic restorations were luted at the crown-root junction. ZP, GI and C2 were submitted to a pH-cycling model. All blocks were sectioned, embedded and polished. Enamel and root dentin demineralization were evaluated through cross-sectional microhardness Knoop measures at 20 to 80 µm of depth (from the outer surface) and at 20 to 220 µm of distance from the cavity margins. Mineral loss values were calculated from Knoop hardness numbers. Data were analyzed by ANOVA, Tukey’s test and regression analysis. Groups ZP, GI and C2 showed demineralization in relation to C1, which was more superficial in enamel than in root dentin. In root dentin, mineral loss in ZP and GI was smaller than in C2. Distance from the cavity margins was not significant. There was no difference between resin-modified glass-ionomer cement and zinc phosphate cement regarding artificial secondary caries development in both dental substrates.

Microleakage at the Cervical Margin of Composite Class II Cavities with Different Restorative Techniques.

C Beznos.

Clinical Relevance:
In the restoration of a Class II with posterior composite, when the cervical margin is located on enamel, all tested techniques demonstrated a good seal. However, when located in dentin, they all failed to do so.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the microleakage at the cervical margins of Class II composite resin restorations restored with different techniques. Slot cavities were prepared on both proximals of 40 unerupted third molars with one cervical margin located above and the other below the cementoenamel junction. The prepared teeth were randomly assigned to four groups and restored using the following techniques: (I) 3-Sited, (II) Directed-Shrinkage, (III) Resin-Modified Glass-Ionomer Cement or a (IV) Flowable Composite as the gingival increment. All restorations were placed with the same bonding agent and composite resin. The difference among the groups was on the first increment and on its insertion and polymerization techniques. After restoration, the teeth were thermocycled and exposed to a dye. Results showed that all the techniques worked well for enamel, with almost no leakage. However, on cementum, all techniques demonstrated moderate to severe leakage.

The Effect of Additional Enamel Etching and a Flowable Composite to the Interfacial Integrity of Class II Adhesive Composite Restorations.

S Belli • S Inokoshi • F Özer • PNR Pereira • M Ogata • J Tagami.

Clinical Relevance:
Flowable composite resins can produce gap-free resin-dentin interfaces. However, both flowable composite and enamel etching could not prevent gap formation at enamel-resin interfaces and crack formation on enamel walls.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the microleakage at the cervical margins of Class II composite resin restorations restored with different techniques. Slot cavities were prepared on both proximals of 40 unerupted third molars with one cervical margin located above and the other below the cementoenamel junction. The prepared teeth were randomly assigned to four groups and restored using the following techniques: (I) 3-Sited, (II) Directed-Shrinkage, (III) Resin-Modified Glass-Ionomer Cement or a (IV) Flowable Composite as the gingival increment. All restorations were placed with the same bonding agent and composite resin. The difference among the groups was on the first increment and on its insertion and polymerization techniques. After restoration, the teeth were thermocycled and exposed to a dye. Results showed that all the techniques worked well for enamel, with almost no leakage. However, on cementum, all techniques demonstrated moderate to severe leakage.

Newly-Developed Diamond Points for Conservative Operative Procedures.

Y Katoh • M Sunico • V Medina III • K Shinkai.

Clinical Relevance:
The experimental diamond points have cutting surface characteristics similar to the smallest commercial diamond points and create significantly smaller cavities, and thus, are preferable instruments for preparing conservative cavity preparations.

SUMMARY:
The rapid decrease in the size of dental restorations has increased the demand for the smallest rotary cutting instrument possible. The width of cavities prepared with two experimental diamond points and the smallest commercial diamond point were compared and significant differences found. SEM observation of the head surfaces of the three diamond points revealed that the experimental points had comparable cutting characteristics with the commercial diamond point.

Amalgam Bonding: Visualization and Clinical Implications of Adhesive Displacement During Amalgam Condensation.

DW Tyler • J Thurmeier.

Clinical Relevance:
During Amalgam condensation resin is displaced onto adjacent tooth surfaces and produces radiological artifacts at the gingival floor of the proximal box, which could cause diagnostic errors.

SUMMARY:
Resin adhesive was visualized in this in vitro study of amalgam bonding using methylene blue dye incorporated into the resin or by scanning electron microscopy. Class II amalgam cavities were prepared in extracted teeth previously stored in buffered formalin. The preparations were then restored following manufacturers’ instructions, but included methylene blue dissolved in ethanol into the adhesive resin mixture. This procedure had little effect on the setting time of the resin. Following condensation and carving, excess resin was incorporated into the body of the restorations as well as onto all adjacent coronal surfaces with significant occlusal and proximal accumulations. Resin also accumulated in significant amounts on the gingival floor of the proximal box and at line angles and retentive grooves within the preparation. In conclusion, radiological studies demonstrated that arifacts produced by resin accumulation at the gingival floor of the box could be mistaken for an open margin or recurrent caries. Other potential clinical consequences of resin residue on tooth surfaces are discussed, including the problem of interproximal ledges and occlusal discrepancies. The incorporation of a radiopaque material in the resin systems should be a universal requirement.

Fracture Resistance of Anterior, Posterior and Universal Light Activated Composite Restoratives.

AC Shortall • S Uctasli • PM Marquis.

Clinical Relevance:
The findings of this investigation provide the clinician with comparative data on the wide range of fracture resistance values exhibited by 36 light-activated resin composite restoratives.

SUMMARY:
This investigation measured the fracture resistance of a wide range of currently available light-activated-composite restoratives. Products intended solely for anterior use were tested together with universal materials and products intended for posterior application. All materials were handled according to manufacturers’ instructions. For products evaluated in this investigation, universal and posterior materials yielded higher mean torque to fracture (T) values overall in comparison to the anterior products. One Microfilled and two Polyglas filled products designated for posterior application yielded relatively modest mean fracture resistance values.

Relationship Between Adhesive Thickness and Microtensile Bond Strength.

L Zheng • PNR Pereira • M Nakajima • H Sano • J Tagami.

Clinical Relevance:
The effect of the thickness of the adhesive layer on bond strength is material-dependent. Care should be taken to avoid excess adhesive resin at line angles in cavities bonded with single bottle systems that contain water and ethanol.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of the thickness of the adhesive resin layer of two commercially available resin bonding systems on bond strengths (Single Bond and Liner Bond 2V). The adhesive of Single Bond contains ethanol and water as solvents and is applied using the moist-bonding technique. The adhesive of Liner Bond 2V contains no solvents and is applied after a self-etching primer treatment. Forty-six caries-free molars were ground flat to expose the dentin surface and polished with #800-grit silicon carbide paper under running water. A vinyl tape punched with a 6 mm diameter hole was then placed on the dentin surface to demarcate the area for bonding. The thickness of the adhesive resin layer was varied by stacking an increasing numbers of vinyl tapes together. The teeth were randomly divided into two groups and treated with either Clearfil Liner Bond 2V or Single Bond. They were further divided into subgroups according to the number of tapes placed on the dentin surface. After the bonding procedures the teeth were incrementally restored with Clearfil AP-X resin composite, building a 5 mm high crown to produce sufficient bulk for the microtensile bond test and stored in tap water at 37°C for 24 hours. The teeth were then sectioned along their long axis into 0.7 mm thick slabs and trimmed for the microtensile bond test using a super-fine diamond bur. The thickness of the adhesive resin layer was then measured with a light microscope and the slabs tested in tension at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute. The results were subjected to statistical analysis by a one-way analysis of variance and linear regressions with 95% confidence intervals.

The thickness of the Clearfil Liner Bond 2V adhesive layer ranged from 5 mm–1500 mm, and for Single Bond, it varied from <7.5 mm–430 mm. For Clearfil Liner Bond 2V, bond strengths increased significantly as the thickness of bonding layer increased (p<0.05). However, the bond strengths of the Single Bond decreased significantly with increased thickness of the bonding layer (p<0.05).



MARCH-APRIL, Volume 26, Number 2

Editorial

Operative Dentistry—The Past, Present and Future

Henry A St Germain, Jr


Clinical Research

Clinical Evaluation of a Polyacid-Modified Resin Composite in Class III Cavities: One Year Results

M Demirci • M Üçok

Clinical Relevance:
Dyract’s clinical performance in Class III cavities at one year recall is promising.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluates the one-year clinical performance of a polyacid-modified resin composite material, Dyract (DeTrey Dentsply, Konstanz, Germany), in Class III cavities.

Sixty-two Class III cavities in 30 patients were restored with Dyract. Restorations were evaluated at baseline and one-year recall according to modified Ryge criteria by two experienced, calibrated examiners.

At one-year recall the rate of retention was 98.4%. None of the restorations were clinically unacceptable in regard to color match, wear or loss of anatomical form, marginal discoloration, caries, marginal adaptation and surface texture. After one year, color change and marginal discoloration in restorations were statistically significant (p=0.031) but did not require the replacement of any of the restorations. At baseline, only one patient reported postoperative sensitivity and two months later, endodontic treatment was performed.

Dyract’s clinical performance in Class III cavities at one year recall is promising but further long-term clinical research on color change and marginal discoloration is needed.


Laboratory Research

Microleakage of Packable Composite Resins

JC Meiers • R Kazemi •CD Meier

Clinical Relevance:
Packable composite resins, when placed in bulk, demonstrated significantly more enamel crazing in butt joint cavity preparations when compared to a conventional anterior/posterior hybrid composite resin.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the microleakage performance of a new generation of composites known as “packable” composites within a high C-factor preparation. Class V cavity preparations with occlusal margins in enamel and gingival margins in dentin were prepared on extracted human molar teeth. Prepared teeth were randomly distributed into four treatment groups (n=18) consisting of three “packable” composites—Alert, Solitaire, and SureFil—and a traditional anterior/ posterior small particle hybrid composite Z-100. Prime & Bond NT bonding agent was used with each composite. Samples were stored in tap water for 24 hours, thermocycled, stained with dye, sectioned into halves and scored for microleakage. All test groups showed a significant increase in both linear and penetrating dentinal microleakage when compared to enamel microleakage. Z-100 had significantly less dentinal marginal microleakage than SureFil. There was no significant difference in the enamel microleakage values between groups. However, the “packable” composites exhibited significantly higher percentages of enamel crazing adjacent to the cavity walls when compared to Z-100. The enamel crazing within the “packable” composite groups warrants further investigation to determine if this is a characteristic related to the composition of this class of composites, the mode of light curing used in this study or the result of the cavity/marginal design.

Bond Strength of Polyacid-Modified Resins Using a New One-Step Adhesive System

H Oberländer • K-H Friedl • G Schmalz

Clinical Relevance:
The tested “universal” adhesive system provides equal or higher bond strengths of the tested polyacid-modified resins to enamel and dentin compared to the adhesive systems provided by the manufacturers.

SUMMARY:
During the last few years a number of one-bottle adhesive systems have been developed. However, no “universal” adhesive system recommended for use with different polyacid-modified resins (PMR) is currently available. This study compared the shear bond strengths of four PMR Dyract AP (D), Compoglass F (C), F 2000 (F) and Hytac (H)) to enamel and dentin using (1) the adhesive system provided by the manufacturer and (2) a new one-step “universal” adhesive system (Prompt L-Pop).

Seventy enamel and 70 dentin-surfaces were prepared for 10 replications of each bonding combination (C1, C2, D1, D2, F1, F2, H1/2). After the bonding procedure and subsequent storage of the specimens in distilled water at 37°C for 24 hours, shear bond strengths were determined using a Universal Testing Machine at a cross-head speed of 0.75 mm min-1 until failure occurred. Fracture modes were examined at 25x magnification under a light microscope.

The median shear bond strength values (MPa) to enamel were 13.2 (C1), 16.5 (C2), 17.7 (D1), 41.2 (D2), 12.7 (F1), 41.2 (F2), 33.9 (H1/2); to dentin, values of 3.3 (C1), 3.7 (C2), 7.4 (D1), 12.2 (D2), 11.4 (F1), 8.6 (F2) and 4.6 (H1/2) were measured. In both enamel and dentin, bond strengths of the tested PMR were either not significantly different or significantly higher using the universal adhesive system compared to the adhesive systems provided by the manufacturers. Bond strengths to enamel and dentin were not significantly different from each other in D and F with their corresponding adhesive system. In all other groups, bond strengths to enamel were significantly higher compared to dentin. Failure modes were mostly adhesive in dentin and mixed adhesive/ cohesive in enamel. SEM observations revealed similar hybrid layer and tag formation in dentin for the four adhesive systems. On enamel, a clearly visible etch pattern was detected only for the universal adhesive system.

In conclusion, the universal adhesive system achieved equal or higher bond strengths of the tested PMR to enamel and dentin compared to the adhesive systems provided by the manufacturers.

Influence of Contact Stress on OCA Wear of Composite Restoratives

AUJ Yap • CL Chew • SH Teoh • LFKL Ong

Clinical Relevance:
Increase in contact stress significantly enhances the wear of composites. Contact stress on occlusal contact areas should be quantified on restorations analyzed for clinical trials in order to make clinical wear assessment more discriminating and to avoid misinterpretations. Composite usage in patients with large biting forces and parafunctional behavior should be avoided in large restorations.

SUMMARY:
Occlusal contact area (OCA) wear has been shown to exceed contact-free area wear by three-to-five times in clinical studies. A reciprocal compression sliding wear device was used to investigate the influence of contact stress on OCA wear of four resin composite restoratives (Silux, Z100, Ariston and Surefil). A dental amalgam (Dispersalloy) was used for comparison. The pattern and mechanisms of wear, and the relationship between wear and composite surface hardness were also studied. Thirty wear specimens and six hardness specimens were made for each material. Wear specimens were tested at 20 to 60 MPa contact stresses against SS304 counter-bodies with artificial saliva as lubricant up to 20,000 cycles. Wear depth (µm; n=6) was measured using profilometry. Hardness testing (KHN) was done with a digital microhardness tester (load=500 gf, dwell time=15 seconds). Results were analyzed using ANOVA/Scheffe’s test (p<0.05). At all contact stresses Dispersalloy had significantly better OCA wear resistance than the composites. The wear of Z100 was significantly greater than Silux, Ariston and Surefil. The influence of stress on wear and counter-body loss was material dependent. Correlation between contact stress and wear was significant for all materials with correlation coefficient (r) ranging from 0.96 for Z100 to 0.88 for Ariston. The wear mechanisms for the different composites varied depending on their microstructure and the contact stress. There was no significant correlation between material hardness and wear/counter-body loss.

Three-Body Abrasive Wear of Composite Restoratives

AUJ Yap • SH Teoh • KB Tan

Clinical Relevance:
The use of composites as an amalgam substitute in low stress, contact-free areas exposed to three-body abrasive wear is feasible. Choice of composite material is, however, an important consideration.

SUMMARY:
This investigation studied the three-body abrasive wear resistance and wear patterns of five composite restoratives. The possible relation between three-body wear and surface hardness was also investigated. A three-body wear instrumentation was used to investigate the wear resistance of five composite restoratives [Silux Plus (SX), Z100 (ZO), Ariston pHc (AR), Surefil (SF) and Tetric Ceram (TC)]. An amalgam alloy [Dispersalloy (DA)] was used as control. The amalgam alloy (DA) had the lowest three-body wear (0.3±0.27 µm) and the highest surface hardness (KHN 131.5±27.87). TC had the most wear (2.14±0.58 µm) and SX was the softest restorative (KHN 34.04±2.73). Ranking was as follows: Wear resistance—DA>ZO>SF>AR>SX>TC; Hardness—DA>SF>ZO>TC>AR>SX. With the exception of ZO, DA was significantly more wear resistant than all the composites evaluated. ZO was significantly more wear resistant than SX and TC. DA was significantly harder than all the composites evaluated. SF was significantly harder than AR and SX. For the composite restoratives, correlation between hardness and wear was significant, with a correlation coefficient of r=-0.45. A significant negative but weak correlation exists between hardness and three-body wear of composite restoratives.

Wear Assessment of High Viscosity and Conventional Composite Restorative Materials

WW Barkmeier • MA Latta • TM Wilwerding • SM Blake

Clinical Relevance:
Relative wear rates of composite restoratives are important in the selection of materials for the placement of posterior resin restorations. The results of this study indicate that there is a significant difference in in-vitro wear rates of resin restorative materials.

SUMMARY:
Newer composite restoratives used in the posterior dentition are marketed as high viscosity, condensable or packable materials. The in-vitro wear characteristics of three newer generation materials were compared to three conventional hybrid composites. Specimens were subjected to wear in a Leinfelder wear simulator equipped with a conical stylus tip to simulate localized wear. Using surface profilometry, computer generated surface maps were analyzed to determine both volumetric loss and maximum depth of wear facets for the materials tested. Volume loss (mm3) was as follows: Z100 – 0.010 ± 0.003; SureFil – 0.014 ± 0.004; Alert 0.016 ± 0.005; Spectrum TPH – 0.042 ± 0.003; Prodigy – 0.055 ± 0.005; Solitaire – 0.062 ± 0.008. Maximum depth of the wear facets (mm) was as follows: Z100 – 69.2 ± 8.8; Alert 80.9 ± 15.4; SureFil – 82.6 ± 11.4; Spectrum TPH – 125.2 ± 15.4; Solitaire – 159.2 ± 14.9; Prodigy – 162.9 ± 22.2. The results of this study indicate that there are significant differences in the wear rates of composite materials. However, there was no clear trend that the newer high viscosity composites exhibited superior wear characteristics when compared to conventional composites.

Composite-to-Dentin Bond Strength, Micromorphology of the Bonded Dentin Interface and Marginal Adaptation of Class II Composite Resin Restorations Using Self-Etching Primers

M Hannig • K-J Reinhardt • B Bott

Clinical Relevance:
Measurement of shear bond strength and analysis of marginal adaptation in Class II composite resin restorations indicate that self-etching priming agents, based on phosphate derivatives of hydrophilic monomers, are effective adhesives for composite-to-dentin bonding restorative requirements.

SUMMARY:
This in vitro study 1) investigated the composite-to-dentin bond strength, 2) analyzed the micromorphology of the resin-dentin interface and 3) evaluated the marginal adaptation of resin composite restorations in Class II cavities using three self-etching priming agents. In the first part of the study 30 extracted human third molars were embedded in acrylic resin and ground flat with 800-grit paper. The following three self-etching priming agents/composite resins were applied to the dentinal surfaces of 10 teeth each: Clearfil Liner Bond 2/Clearfil AP-X (Group I), Etch & Prime 3.0/Degufill mineral (Group II), Resulcin AquaPrime + Mono Bond/Arabesk (Group III). Shear bond strength values measured on a T 22 K testing machine (Lloyds Instr) at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/min were: 21.7 ± 2.6 MPa (Group I), 22.4 ± 1.4 MPa (II) and 29.5 ± 2.5 MPa (III). ANOVA revealed significant (p<0.001) differences in shear bond strength between groups, except comparison of Group I and II. In the second part of the study specimens were prepared by application of the above mentioned bonding materials to wet-ground dentinal surfaces of 24 freshly extracted caries-free human premolars. Morphology of the resin- dentin interface was studied by scanning and transmission electron microscopic analyses. Tag formation could be detected with all bonding agents. Thickness of the demineralized zone/resin infiltrated layer at the dentinal surface varied from 0.8 to 2.3 µm (Group I), 2.5 to 4.0 µm (Group II), 3.5 to 6.5 µm (Group III). In the third part of the study 18 standardized Class II cavities with the proximal box extending 0.5 mm beyond the CEJ were prepared in extracted human molars. Enamel margins were beveled, dentinal cavosurface margins were prepared as butt joint and the teeth were divided into three groups (n=6, each). Cavities were restored with composite resin using the self-etching priming agents Clearfil Liner Bond 2 (Group I), Etch & Prime 3.0 (Group II) and Resulcin AquaPrime + MonoBond (Group III). Marginal adaptation of the restorations was analyzed by SEM after thermocycling (5-55°C, 2,500 cycles) and mechanical loading (100 N, 500,000 cycles). Mean/median percentages of excellent, gap-free marginal adaptation observed at the restorations proximal dentinal margins after loading were 97.5%/99% in Group I, 90.7%/98.5% in Group II and 76.3%/98% in Group III. There were no statistically significant differences between the three groups (p<0.01). It was concluded that the three self-etching priming agents evaluated in this in vitro study have the potential to provide an effective bonding between composite and dentin.

Color Stability of Ionomer and Resin Composite Restoratives

MA Vargas • HL Kirchner • AM Diaz-Arnold• VL Beck

Clinical Relevance:
Perceptible changes in color were recorded for the conventional glass ionomer, resin- modified glass ionomer and compomer materials tested in this study. Therefore, those materials should not be considered color stable.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the color stability of a conventional glass ionomer (Ketac-Fil), a light polymerized resin-modified glass ionomer (Photac-Fil), a polyacid-modified resin composite or compomer (Dyract) and a microfilled resin composite (Silux Plus). Thirty-two specimens (n=8/material) were fabricated and stored in artificial saliva at 37°C for seven weeks. A colorimetric evaluation, according to the CIE L*a*b* system, was performed at 24 hours (baseline) and at the end of each week. Color difference values (DE*ab) were calculated. The conventional glass ionomer, resin-modified ionomer and compomer materials underwent significant color changes over time (p<0.01). Those materials darkened and showed color shifts in both the red-green and yellow-blue axes.

Microleakage of “One Bottle” Dentin Adhesives

AA Al-Ehaideb •H Mohammed

Clinical Relevance:
There was no significant difference in microleakage scores between the fifth generation (One Bottle) and fourth generation dentin adhesive resins.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the marginal sealing ability of five “One Bottle” fifth generation dentin adhesive resins. Bond 1, Single Bond, Tenure Quick with fluoride, One-Step and Prime & Bond 2.1 were evaluated. Tenure All-Surface Bonding System, a fourth generation dentin adhesive resin, was used as the control group.

A Class V preparation (3 mm diameter, 1.5 mm deep) was placed at the cemento-enamel junction of 60 extracted human premolar teeth. A 1 mm 45° bevel was placed at the enamel margin. Each group of cavities were restored using one of the dentin adhesives and the same restorative resin. Following five days storage in 37°C water, the restored teeth were thermocycled for 500 cycles between 5°C and 55°C for one minute in each cycle. Microleakage was assessed by dye penetration using 0.2% Basic Fuchsin dye. After 24 hours the teeth were sectioned longitudinally and evaluated for microleakage. The results were analyzed using the non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis Test.

Microleakage at the enamel margins was not evident in any group. However, leakage was present at the gingival margin (cementum) in all of the treated groups. There were no significant differences between gingival margins (0.75>p>0.5). When comparing the gingival margin microleakage scores between two groups or within the same group, statistical analysis showed no significant difference. The new “One Bottle” dentin adhesives have similar marginal sealing ability to that of the control group.

Determination of the Minimum Irradiance Required for Adequate Polymerization of a Hybrid and a Microfill Composite

DL Leonard • DG Charlton • HR Roberts• TJ Hilton • A Zionic

Clinical Relevance:
The generally accepted minimum irradiance value of 300 mW/cm2 may be insufficient for adequate polymerization of some microfilled resin composites.

SUMMARY:
This in vitro study determines the minimum irradiance values required for adequate polymerization of a microfill and a hybrid resin composite when cured for 40 and 60 seconds.

A curing light (Optilux 401) with an 8-mm-diameter tip (SaniCure) was used as the light source. The irradiance output of the light unit, measured with a laser power meter, was varied by altering the input voltage using a variable power supply. Two-mm-thick hardness test specimens were made with a microfill composite (Silux Plus) and a hybrid composite (Z-100) for each combination of exposure time (40, 60 seconds) and irradiance value (100 mW/cm2 to 700 mW/cm2 in 25-mW/cm2 increments). After 24 hours, Knoop hardness (KH) measurements were made for each side of each specimen, means were calculated and a top/bottom KH percentage was determined. A value of at least 80% was used to indicate satisfactory polymerization. A linear regression of irradiance versus KH percentage was performed and the resulting equation used to predict the irradiance value required to produce a KH value of 80% for the test conditions.

Results showed that the hybrid composite, Z-100, required 260.1 mW/cm2 @ 40 seconds or 185.0 mW/cm2@ 60 seconds for satisfactory polymerization. The microfill, Silux Plus, required 542.9 mW/cm2 @ 40 seconds or 449.0 mW/cm2 @ 60 seconds. These findings indicate that previously stated minimum irradiance values may be insufficient for adequate polymerization of microfill resin composites.

Pulpal Temperature Change with Visible Light-Curing

C Porko • E-L Hietala

Clinical Relevance:
The warming effect of the light curing lamp on pulp should be taken into account when curing large restorations or inlays/onlays that need several consecutive light curing exposures.

SUMMARY:
In vitro measurements were made to reveal the heat transference to the pulp chamber during light curing. Ten extracted human teeth were kept in physiologic saline at body temperature. In the first part of the study, five light curing exposures of 40 seconds were given to the occlusal surface of each tooth with a light curing unit.The temperature of the pulp was measured by a thermocouple probe that was inserted into the pulp through the apex. The maximal temperature rise was 2.2°C. Thereafter, standard occlusal cavities were prepared in all 10 teeth and filled with composite resin filling material in three parts. The dental adhesive was light cured for 20 seconds and each composite increment for 40 seconds. An extra cycle of 40 seconds was given when the cavity was filled as a post cure. The maximal temperature difference during the total procedure was 7.2°C. The heating effect of light curing should thus be taken into account when restorations are cured.

Colorimetric and Roughness Changes of Ceramic Blocks by Polishing and Glazing

BH Cho • SJ Heo • CG Chang • HH Son • HC Kwon • CM Um

Clinical Relevance:
Color changes caused by polishing or glazing of porcelain blocks could be easily perceived by the naked eye.

SUMMARY:
After polishing or glazing, slight color changes of machined porcelain restorations may be perceived, compared to the originally selected shade. This study compared the precision of the tristimulus colorimeter with the spectrophotometer to quantitatively measure the color changes of milled porcelain restorations after polishing or glazing and to evaluate the relationship between the color changes and the surface roughness. Ten two-millimeter thickness specimens of each shade were prepared from five shades of Vita Cerec Mark II porcelain blocks. Each specimen was ground with #220 grit SiC paper on an automatic polishing machine to simulate the surface roughness of milled restoration ground with 54 or 64 µm diamond grinding tools. To compare the precision of the spectrophotometer with the tristimulus colorimeter, CIE Lab* values of each specimen were measured and the coefficients of variation (CV) for each instrument computed. Ra values were also obtained using a Surface Analyzer. After verifying the precision of the tristimulus colorimeter, a second set of measurements were taken after the polishing or glazing procedure to quantitatively evaluate the effect of these procedures on the shade of the milled restorations. To evaluate the relationship between the color change and the surface roughness, a second set of Ra measurements were taken and the correlation between them analyzed. The tristimulus colorimeter measured the L* value more precisely than the spectrophotometer (p<0.05), but on the a* and b* color coordinates, it was not significantly superior to the spectrophotometer (p>0.05). The color difference values produced by polishing or glazing were greater than 2 DE units. After polishing and glazing, among the three coordinates examined, DL* was the most prominent determinant on DE*(DR2/polishing=0.9744 and DR2/glazing=0.9413), but Da* and Db* had little effect. There was no statistically significant correlation between the changes in surface roughness and color in either polishing (r=0.3555, p=0.0812) or glazing (r=-0.1570, p=0.4520).

Microleakage and Internal Voids in Class II Composite Restorations with Flowable Composite Linings

S-F Chuang • J-K Liu • Y-T Jin

Clinical Relevance:
In a simulated Class II box-only composite restoration, the use of a flowable resin composite lining achieved a reduction in the number of internal voids but no benefit regarding marginal sealing. In addition, this study revealed no absolute correlation between the extent of microleakage and the presence of internal voids in a restoration.

SUMMARY:
This study determined the influence of a flowable composite lining on marginal microleakage and internal voids in a Class II composite restoration. Forty-eight extracted molars were prepared with Class II cavities and randomly divided into four groups: Group I–Prodigy filling/ Revolution lining; Group II–Prodigy filling only; Group III–Tetric Ceram/Tetric Flow lining; Group IV–Tetric Ceram filling only. After thermocycling tests and dye soaking, these teeth were sectioned longitudinally. Gingival-marginal microleakage and internal voids in three separate portions of the restoration (Interface, Cervical and Occlusal voids) were observed with a stereomicroscope. Results revealed no significant difference in the marginal sealing between pairs with or without the flowable composite lining. Restorations conducted with a flowable composite lining (Groups I and III) exhibited fewer total voids and fewer voids in the interface (p<0.05). However, there was no significant correlation between the number of restoration voids and the associated microleakage. A flowable composite lining in a Class II resin filling could effectively reduce the voids in the interface and the total number of voids in the restoration, but may not necessarily improve marginal sealing.

Pulp Tissue Reaction to Four Dental Cements

H Sonoda • S Inokoshi • M Otsuki • J Tagami

Clinical Relevance:
Protection of pulp is recommended in deep cavities to prevent post-cementation sensitivity, which may be caused by chemical irritation of the dental cements.

SUMMARY:
Pulp tissue reactions to four commonly used dental cements were histo-pathologically evaluated by placing the cements on exposed monkey dental pulp followed by a surface-sealed adhesive restoration. Evaluations were done at 3 or 5, and 30 and 90 days after operation. No serious inflammatory reaction of the pulp, such as necrosis or abscess formation, was observed. However, the conventional dental cements showed irritating effects on the exposed monkey dental pulp without bacterial contamination. Reactions of exposed dental pulp beneath the dental cements differed depending on the materials used.


Clinical Technique/Case Report

Fabricating A Natural Tooth Pontic Bridge Using a Pre-Impregnated Fiber-Reinforced Composite Technique

JC Meiers • MA Freilich

SUMMARY:
Pre-impregnated fiber reinforced composites (FRC) can be used chairside for splinting and immediate tooth replacement. These materials may provide a more predictable long-term result than previous adhesive techniques employing composite reinforcement because of their improved mechanical properties. This article describes a technique using pre-impregnated FRC for the immediate replacement of an extracted tooth using the crown of the extracted tooth as the pontic.



MAY-JUNE, Volume 26, Number 3

Editorial

Whatever Lola Wants...

Dr Michael A Cochran


Clinical Research

pH Stabilizing Properties of a Posterior Light Cured Resin Composite: An In Vivo Study

Y Chacko • L Lakshminarayanan

Clinical Relevance:
Posterior composite restoratives that stabilize the pH of saliva can be beneficial in countering acid demineralization of enamel.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated, in vivo, the pH stabilizing properties of a posterior resin composite (Ariston pHc, Vivadent Ets, Schaan/ Liechtenstein). Fifteen human subjects with four or more active carious lesions were selected. Their salivary pH, in relation to the occlusal surface of these lesions, was recorded. The teeth were restored with resin composite, and the pH in relation to the restorations was recorded one day, one week, one month and two months post-operative. Results showed that the resin composite countered the acidic pH of saliva and maintained it at levels where demineralization would not occur.


Laboratory Research

Diagnostic Accuracy of Intraoral Film and Direct Digital Images for Detection of Simulated Recurrent Decay

MK Nair • JB Ludlow • KN May • UP Nair • MP Johnson • JM Close

Clinical Relevance:
PSP and CCD-based digital images provided a level of diagnostic performance comparable to Ektaspeed Plus film. Contrast and brightness enhancements improved digital image performance.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the diagnostic accuracy of bitewing images for detection of simulated recurrent caries using the following imaging modalities: Ektaspeed Plus film and different digital imaging system technologies comprised of a charge-coupled device (CCD) based digital imaging unit, a photo-stimulable phosphor (PSP) based unit and contrast-and brightness-enhanced PSP images.

Study Design: Twenty-four extracted posterior teeth with MOD inlay preparations were secured in models simulating a natural arrangement of teeth. Lesions were created in proximal boxes using dental burs of varying sizes. Defects were filled with wax and plaster and preparations were restored with composite or amalgam.

Results: Averages of receiver operating curve areas (Az) revealed diagnostic performances of Az=0.74 for film, Az=0.80 for CCD, Az=0.73 for unenhanced PSP and Az=0.64 for enhanced PSP. The differences between these means were significant (MANOVA p<0.0001). Unenhanced PSP produced significantly poorer performance than other modalities. CCD performance was not significantly better than enhanced PSP. Lesions under radiopaque composite restorations were easier to detect, followed by those under amalgam and radiolucent composites across imaging modalities and lesion locations. Based on lesion location, those located at the buccal point angle were easiest to detect, followed by those at mid-gingival floor and lingual-point angle sites.

Conclusions: Contrast and brightness-enhanced digital images enabled better signal detection and a comparable performance with film for detection of artificially induced recurrent caries.

Effects of APF Gel on the Physical Structure of Compomers and Glass Ionomer Cements

KH-K Yip • D Peng • RJ Smales

Clinical Relevance:
The erosive effect of APF gel could increase restoration wear and bacterial adhesion and may reduce the longevity of restorations.

SUMMARY:
This study assessed the effect of an acidulated phosphate fluoride (APF) gel on the surfaces of eight modern esthetic restorative materials. Five specimens each of three high powder: liquid ratio conventional glass ionomer cements (ChemFlex, Fuji IX GP, Ionofil Molar), four polyacid-modified resin composites (compomers) (Compoglass F, Dyract AP, Freedom, F2000) and an alkaline glass filled resin composite (Ariston pHc) were prepared and immersed at 37°C in 2 mL of artificial saliva for six weeks. The aged specimens were then coated with 1.23% APF gel for four minutes, rinsed and again immersed in artificial saliva for another six weeks. The immersed, fresh specimens for each material were then examined with SEM and surface profilometry. After APF gel application, mean surface roughness (Ra) measurements and SEMs showed that roughness increased significantly, generally from the resin composite and compomers to the conventional glass ionomer cements (p<0.05).

Characterization of Dentin-Bonding-Amalgam Interfaces

SB Geiger • Y Mazor •E Klein • H Judes

Clinical Relevance:
The lowest degree of gap formation and microleakage between restoration and tooth surface in bonded amalgam restorations is achieved by applying a bonding agent over the etched cavity surface, followed by a layer of resinous adhesive material and immediate condensation of amalgam.

SUMMARY:
Applying a bonding agent and a resinous adhesive layer before amalgam condensation has become a common clinical procedure. However, interactions between the different interfaces formed, and the extent of sealing obtained, have not been extensively studied. This study characterized the interfaces formed in the bonded amalgam restoration. Specifically, the individual contributions of the bonding agent (One-Step) and the adhesive resin (Resinomer) were examined, along with their mode of application on the prevention of microleakage and the formation of a tight, continuous adhesion to amalgam. To this end, a dye penetration assay and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) were used, including high resolution elemental analysis, for the characterization of the sealing properties and the interface structure obtained following various procedures of applying amalgam adhesives. Results indicated that placing bonding material under the amalgam restoration is essential to preventing microleakage. When condensed against uncured or cured adhesive material, the adhesive resinous glass layer creates a thick interface with protrusions and inclusions in the amalgam, though microleakage studies indicate that condensation over the uncured adhesive results in a better seal than that of the cured adhesive. SEM combined with elemental analysis indicates that the adhesion between amalgam and adhesive material is mainly of mechanical character and is formed by interdigitations of the adhesive material protruding into the amalgam. Gaps formed at the various interfaces in the different modalities could be localized. In addition, resinous glass composite alone, without bonding, was found to provide an unacceptable degree of sealing between the tooth and amalgam. The clinical significance of these findings is further discussed.

The Effect of Acid Etching on Vascular Diameter of Pulp-Vessels in Rat Incisor (Vitalmicroscopic Study)

I Iványi • B Kispélyi • Á Fazekas • L Rosivall • I Nyárasdy

Clinical Relevance:
In the dental pulp of rats, acid etching applied for 15 or 20 seconds in very deep cavities has no deleterious effect; however, prolonged etching time results in failure in microcirculation of the rat dental pulp.

SUMMARY:
Conditioning agents used on dentin with composite materials are biologically active and may have deleterious effects on the pulpal microcirculation. No data are available on the immediate vascular effect of etching materials applied on a constant thin pulpal dentin. In this study the authors examined whether the application of 36% phosphoric acid (Conditioner 36, 15 seconds) or itakonic acid with 10% maleic acid (NRC Non-Rinse Conditioner, 20 seconds), as recommended by the manufacturers, alters the blood circulation in the pulp of the rat’s lower incisors. The effect of prolonged etching time (60 seconds) was also assessed (Conditioner 36). The application of saline served as the untreated control. The technique of vitalmicroscopy was used on the first lower incisor of 40 (10-10 in each group) male Sprague-Dawley rats (weighing 350 ± 8g SE) to record the changes in vessel diameter prior to and at 5, 15, 30 and 60 minutes after the test materials were administered on the dentin. In the control rats, the vessel diameter was stable during the entire experiment. Acid conditioning as recommended by the manufacturers tended to cause vasodilatation, though these alterations were statistically not significant when compared to the control group (ANOVA, p>0.05). After prolonged etching time (Conditioner 36, 60 seconds) significant vasoconstriction (-14.4 ± 6.13; -10.59 ± 4.2; -11.96 ± 6.75; -5.49 ± 5.78%) was observed (ANOVA, p<0.05). In this group, stasis developed in pulpal blood circulation in 40% of rats (Cochran’s-Q test, p<0.05), gas-bubble formation was observed in 30% and the disappearance of the pulpal wall occurred in 20%. These results suggest that exposition time with acid is crucial to the pulpal microcirculation. That is, acid conditioning applied as indicated (for 15-20 seconds) onto a very thin layer of dentin only slightly affects the blood supply to the dental pulp; however, prolonged etching time (for 60 seconds) results in immediate failure of microcirculation in the dental pulp of rats.

Influence of Different Restorative Techniques on Microleakage in Class II Cavities with Gingival Wall in Cementum

FF Demarco • OLV Ramos • CS Mota • E Formolo • LM Justino

Clinical Relevance:
The combination of amalgam/composite in Class II cavities with gingival margin in cementum could be an alternative to reducing microleakage.

SUMMARY:
This study compared marginal leakage of Class II cavities with gingival margin in cementum using different techniques. Twenty-four recently extracted third molars were used. Proximal standard box cavities were prepared in both mesial and distal surfaces. The gingival margin was located apical to the cemento-enamel junction. All the preparations and restorations were performed by the same operator. Standard cavities were randomly divided into three groups (n=16) and restored as follows: Group 1–light-cured composite resin; Group 2–self-cured composite resin + light-cured composite resin and Group 3–amalgam + light-cured composite resin. After polishing, the teeth were thermocycled and their gingival margins exposed to dye. Specimens were sectioned and leakage scores observed in accordance with a standard ranking. Data were subjected to statistical analysis (Kruskal-Wallis). Results showed that the amalgam/resin composite combination demonstrated the least leakage.

Soft-Start Polymerization: Influence on Effectiveness of Cure and Post-Gel Shrinkage

AUJ Yap • SC Ng • KS Siow

Clinical Relevance:
Soft-start polymerization involving step-wise modulation of light energy does not reduce the effectiveness of cure. No significant reduction in polymerization shrinkage was observed with the soft-start curing regimen.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of soft-start polymerization on the effectiveness of cure and post-gel shrinkage of a visible light cured resin composite (Z100). Three cure modes (LH–high intensity; LA–soft-start polymerization involving step-wise modulation of light intensity and LL–low intensity) of a commercial light-cure unit (Kavo PolyLUX II) were examined and compared to another light-cure unit (Spectrum). The effectiveness of cure with the different cure modes was assessed by computing the hardness gradient between top and bottom surfaces of 2 mm composites specimens after different light exposure times. A strain-monitoring device was used to measure the linear polymerization shrinkage associated with the different cure modes and exposure times over 180 minutes. A sample size of five was used for both experiments. Data was analyzed using one-way ANOVA and Scheffe’s post-hoc test at significance level 0.05. Results showed that effectiveness of cure generally increased with increase cure time. Although modulation of light energy intensity (LA 40/80 seconds) resulted in lower polymerization shrinkage compared to LH 40 seconds, no significant difference was observed between these three cure regimes. Curing with the Spectrum curing light resulted in the lowest polymerization shrinkage.

Influence of Different Transitional Restorations on the Fracture Resistance of Premolar Teeth

AJE Qualtrough •SG Cawte • NHF Wilson

Clinical Relevance:
Fracture resistance testing indicates that use of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement alone may offer advantages over alternative materials and techniques in the transitional restoration of teeth destined to be crowned.

SUMMARY:
Controversy exists over the most favorable material and type of restoration to be used to transitionally restore teeth destined to be crowned. This in vitro study uses fracture resistance testing to compare eight different transitional restorations in maxillary premolars. Ninety sound maxillary premolars were randomly selected and allocated to nine groups, each comprising 10 teeth. One group remained unrestored and was used as the control. Teeth in the remaining groups were prepared to a standard cavity form using: a copy milling process removing the palatal cusp. Restorations were placed using amalgam with dentin pins and cavity varnish; amalgam with an amalgam bonding agent; resin composite with dentin pins and a dentin bonding agent; resin composite with a dentin bonding agent only; resin-modified glass ionomer with dentin pins; resin-modified glass ionomer cement alone and cermet with dentin pins and cermet alone. Each restored tooth was then subjected to axial loading via a bar contacting the buccal and restored palatal cusps until failure of the restored tooth occurred. The mean load-to-fracture values were statistically compared and the modes of failure recorded. It was found that the choice of restorative material and type of restoration had little effect on the fracture resistance of the restored tooth with the exception of those teeth restored with reinforced glass ionomer cement alone, which exhibited a significantly lower resistance to fracture than the other restored teeth. However, the choice of restorative material/technique did influence the mode of failure. Failure in teeth restored with resin-modified glass ionomer cement alone produced the least damage to the remaining tooth tissue when failure occurred. Consequently, this material may offer the most favorable range of properties for the transitional restoration of extensively broken-down maxillary premolar teeth destined to be crowned. Furthermore, the findings of this study fail to support the use of dentin pins in the placement of bonded build-up restorations.

Repair of Non-Carious Amalgam Margin Defects

HW Roberts • DG Charlton • DF Murchison

Clinical Relevance:
Flowable resin composite may provide an adequate marginal seal for selected non-carious amalgam margin defects.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the microleakage associated with the repair of non-carious amalgam defects using flowable resin composite. Occlusal amalgam preparations were accomplished on 36 non-carious mandibular molars. A standardized 40-micron marginal defect was made by condensing amalgam against a mylar matrix strip. Specimens then underwent a corrosion protocol designed to simulate intraoral corrosion seen with amalgam restorations. The resultant specimens were divided into three treatment groups: 1) No treatment (control); 2) Air abrasion of the amalgam defect surface, acid etching of both amalgam and enamel surfaces, then placement of a flowable composite and 3) Air abrasion of the amalgam defect, application of a fifth-generation dentin bonding agent and placement of the flowable composite. Specimens were thermocycled, sealed with glass ionomer and fingernail polish to within 1 mm of repaired margins, then immersed in basic fuchsin for 24 hours. Specimens were sectioned and microleakage assessed. Results indicated that a flowable resin composite significantly reduced marginal microleakage compared to the control (p<0.05). There was no difference in microleakage between flowable resin composite repairs done with or without the use of a dentin-bonding agent.

Effect of Bonding Variables on the Shear Bond Strength and Interfacial Morphology of a One-Bottle Adhesive

V Medina III • K Shinkai • M Shirono • N Tanaka • Y Katoh

Clinical Relevance:
The use of Prime & Bond and Dyract AP on etched, moist or dry enamel and moist dentin resulted in high bond strengths and intimate adaptation of resin to the substrate.

SUMMARY:
This study’s objectives were: 1) to determine the combination of bonding procedures (with or without acid etching, moist or dry substrate, one or two applications of primer/adhesive) that would produce the highest shear bond strength of Prime & Bond and Dyract AP and 2) to characterize the resin-dentin/enamel interface produced by these bonding procedures. Ninety-six bovine incisors were randomly assigned to eight groups for shear bond testing to enamel (n=6) and dentin (n=6). Prime & Bond and Dyract AP were applied and cured following manufacturers’ instructions. Shear bond testing was conducted in a Universal Testing Machine. Thirty-two bovine incisors were sectioned to produce blocks with enamel and dentin, then bonded in pairs for evaluation of interfacial morphology. They were polished and argon ion-etched using a high-speed argon ion-etching machine and examined by SEM. The groups where enamel was etched, kept moist or dry and received a single application of Prime & Bond produced the highest shear bond strength. Dentin bond strengths were high in the groups where dentin was etched and kept moist. The number of Prime & Bond applications had no effect on dentin bond strength. Acid etching results in better adaptation of Prime & Bond to enamel and dentin regardless of whether moisture is present.

Re-Attachment of Anterior Fractured Teeth: Fracture Strength Using Different Techniques

A Reis • C Francci • AD Loguercio • MRO Carrilho • LE Rodrigues Filho

Clinical Relevance:
The re-attachment of coronal fragments to the remaining tooth, using an overcontour or an internal groove technique as well as a composite build-up, can provide high fracture strength to restored teeth.

SUMMARY:
Fracture of anterior teeth by trauma is a common problem in children and teenagers. Complex metal-ceramic crowns with considerable loss of remaining sound structure are no longer necessary due to adhesive techniques, such as composite restorations and re-attachment techniques. This study compared the fracture strength of sound and restored anterior teeth using a resin composite and four re-attachment techniques. A “one bottle” adhesive system (One-Step, BISCO) and a dual cure resin cement (Duo-Link, BISCO) were applied. Thirty-five sound permanent lower central incisors were fractured by an axial load applied to the buccal area and randomly divided into five groups. The teeth were restored as follows: 1) bonded only = just bonding the fragment; 2) chamfer-group = after bonding, a chamfer was prepared on the enamel at the bonding line and filled with composite; 3) overcontour group = after bonding, a thin composite overcontour was applied on the buccal surface around the fracture line; 4) internal dentinal groove = before bonding, an internal groove was made and filled with a resin composite; 5) resin composite group = after a bevel preparation on the enamel edge, the adhesive system was applied and the fractured part of the teeth rebuilt by resin composite. Restored teeth were subjected to the same loading in the same buccal area. Fracture strength after restorative procedure was expressed as a percentage of the original fracture strength and the results analyzed by Kruskal-Wallis statistical analysis. The mean percentages of fracture strength were: Group 1: 37.09%, Group 2: 60.62%, Group 3: 97.2%, Group 4: 90.54% and Group 5: 95.8%. It was concluded that the re-attachment techniques used in Groups 3 and 4, as well as the composite restored group (Group 5), were statistically similar and reached the highest fracture resistance, similar to the fracture resistance of sound teeth.

Mechanical Properties of an Improved Visible Light-Cured Resin-Modified Glass Ionomer Cement

AUJ Yap • S Mudambi • CL Chew • JCL Neo

Clinical Relevance:
The maximum mechanical properties of Fuji II LC Improved were achieved at one week. Therefore, finishing/polishing should be delayed and not conducted immediately after light polymerization. A decrease in mechanical properties was observed at one month and may be attributed to water sorption. Mechanical properties were significantly affected by increased powder:liquid ratio.

SUMMARY:
This study investigates the mechanical properties (hardness, flexural strength and compressive strength) of a new light-cured resin-modified glass ionomer cement (Fuji II LC Improved). Effects of the increased powder:liquid ratio on mechanical properties and the correlation between different mechanical properties were also studied. Mechanical properties of the cement at manufacturer’s recommended powder: liquid ratio (F), 2% (F2) and 4% (F4) increased powder weight were measured after one day, one week and one month storage in distilled water at 37°C. Hardness testing (KHN; n=5) was done with a digital microhardness tester (load=500g, dwell time=15 seconds). Flexural and compressive strength testing (MPa; n=5) were conducted based on ISO 4049 and BS6039, respectively. Results were analyzed using ANOVA/Scheffe’s test (p<0.05) and Pearson’s correlation (p<0.01). The maximum mechanical properties of Fuji II LC Improved were achieved at one week. The hardness, flexural and compressive strength at one week was significantly higher than at one day. A decrease in all mechanical properties was observed at one month. Mechanical properties were significantly affected by increased powder: liquid ratio. After one month storage, significance was as follows: Hardness–F, F2>F4; Flexural strength–F4>F, F2 and F>F2; Compressive strength–F, F2>F4 and F2>F. A significant very strong and negative correlation was observed between flexural and compressive strengths (r=-0.97).

Microleakage of Posterior Packable Resin Composites With and Without Flowable Liners

SC Leevailoj • MA Cochran • BA Matis • BK Moore • JA Platt

Clinical Relevance:
When used as a liners in Class II cavities, flowable composites reduced, but did not eliminate, microleakage of the tested packable and microhybrid resin composites at gingival margins apical to the CEJ.

SUMMARY:
The use of flowable composites as liners in Class II packable composites has been suggested by some manufacturers. However, the contributions of this technique are unproven. This study evaluated marginal microleakage in Class II packable composite restorations with and without the use of a flowable composite liner. A conventional microhybrid composite was used as a control. Microleakage at occlusal and gingival margins of Class II cavities was evaluated using 45Ca and autoradiographs.

Fifty non-carious, restoration-free human molar teeth were used. Separate mesio-occlusal and disto-occlusal Class II cavity preparations were made in each tooth. Gingival margins of all cavities were placed 1 mm apical to the cementoenamel junction (CEJ). Four Packable composites (Alert, Surefil, Pyramid and Solitaire) and one conventional microhybrid composite (Renew) with their respective manufacturer’s bonding agents were used to restore the cavities. One side of each tooth was restored with composite alone, while the other side was restored with the composite lined with that manufacturer’s flowable liner. The restored teeth were thermally stressed and 45Ca was used to evaluate microleakage. Two independent evaluators scored leakage based on the autoradiographs.

The results showed flowable composites helped reduce microleakage at gingival margins of Class II restorations (p<0.05). Gingival margins had higher microleakage than occlusal margins (p<0.05). Without flowable liners, three packable composites (Alert, Pyramid and Surefil) showed higher leakage (p<0.05) than the microhybrid control. Only Solitaire packable composite without liner showed no significant difference in microleakage to the control (p>0.05). Although the flowable liners help reduce microleakage, Alert and Pyramid packable composites with liners still showed higher leakage than the control (p<0.05). Surefil and Solitaire packable composites with flowable liners showed no significant difference in microleakage (p>0.05) to the control.

Evaluation of Cutting Patterns Produced with Air-Abrasion Systems Using Different Tip Designs

L Santos-Pinto • C Peruchi • VA Marker • R Cordeiro

Clinical Relevance:
The variety of cutting patterns produced with the different air abrasion tip designs indicated that clinicians must select specific tip parameters to achieve expected outcomes.

SUMMARY:
This study assessed cavity preparations produced with different air abrasion tip parameters. Twelve test groups of extracted teeth were prepared to evaluate the parameters of 80° or 45° nozzle angles and 0.38 or 0.48 mm inner tip diameters. All other factors were held constant. A device was made to hold the specimen and air abrasion handpiece that standardized the distance and position relative to the tooth and time of application. The cavities were evaluated by assessing the rounding of the cavosurface margins and cavity floor. Measurements of cavosurface angles and the angle of concavity were made at the deepest portion of the abraded surface using scanning electron micrographs. The cavosurface angles were compared using paired t-test, and the effects of the tip design parameters were analyzed by ANOVA and Duncan’s Multiple Range test. From the cavity patterns found in this study, the authors suggest that 80° angle tips are more appropriate than 45° angle tips for making narrow, deep cuts for preventive resin restorations. Conversely, when shallow preparations are needed, as in the case of Class V cavity preparations, cutting patterns of 45° angle tips are more suitable.

The Effect of Double Adhesive Application on the Shear Bond Strength to Dentin of Compomers Using Three One-Bottle Adhesive Systems

JA Platt • J Almeida • C Gonzalez-Cabezas • B Rhodes • BK Moore

Clinical Relevance:
One of three one-bottle adhesives tested had more reliable performance when the number of manufacturer recommended applications was doubled. Doubling the number of applications had no effect on the other one-bottle adhesives tested.

SUMMARY:
The development of one-bottle dentin adhesive systems resulted in much optimism about providing simplified predictable esthetic dentistry. However, laboratory testing of these systems continues to provide significant variations between facilities. A potential effect of the number of applications was noted in this author’s laboratory. This study evaluated the effect of doubling the manufacturer’s recommended number of applications on shear bond strength to dentin.

Ninety human molars were divided into groups of 15. The occlusal surfaces were finished to 600 grit SiC to provide a flat dentin bonding surface. Prime & Bond NT—Dyract, Optibond Solo—Elan and One Step—Dyract were evaluated. Each material was tested using: (1) the recommended number of adhesive applications and (2) twice the number of applications recommended. All adhesive applications were accomplished before light curing the adhesive. The specimens were thermocycled after one week of storage and tested in shear after two weeks.

Specimens were also fabricated after adding Rhodamine D to the adhesive to allow for visualization using confocal microscopy. These teeth were sectioned and viewed 24 hours after fabrication.

A t-test was used to compare differences within product groups. The results showed a significant effect (p<0.001) when a double application of Prime & Bond NT was used. No difference was seen with Optibond Solo or One Step. All specimens appeared to have a uniform, glossy appearance of adhesive during fabrication. Therefore, the appearance of the adhesive after application may not be a reliable predictor of acceptable bonding. Confocal microscopy showed that single application Prime & Bond NT specimens did not exhibit a uniform thickness of adhesive across the entire interface. Tubule penetration and hybridization was apparent for all specimens.



JULY-AUGUST, Volume 26, Number 4

Editorial

The Academy of Operative Dentistry Recommendations for Clinical Practice

Peter T Triolo, Jr.


Buonocore Memorial Lecture

Adhesive Dentistry Applied to the Treatment of Traumatic Dental Injuries

JO Andreasen

SUMMARY:
Dental adhesive techniques have led to a significant simplification of the immediate and definitive treatment of traumatic dental injuries. Composite restoration of fractured teeth, bonding of tooth fragments, the use of laminate veneers or porcelain onlays and resin retained bridges are some of the ways adhesive techniques are used to treat fractured teeth. Furthermore, splinting of luxated teeth almost entirely relies on the combination of adhesion and a flexible resin which simulates the mobility of a normal periodontal ligament during the healing period. The internal strengthening of immature root-filled teeth with composite using an adhesive technique may possibly prevent late root fractures caused by weakening of the tooth structure resulting from endodontic procedures. Finally, the adhesive principle using a retro-seal with composite after apicoectomy significantly increases the healing rate and healing mode.


Clinical Research

Pulpal Inflammatory Responses Following Non-Carious Class V Restorations

I About • PE Murray • J-C Franquin • M Remusat • AJ Smith

Clinical Relevance:
The interactions between cavity preparation and restoration events which result in pulpal inflammation have been characterized in 202 restored Class V cavities. This information explains how pulpal inflammatory activity can be minimized, and the probability of post-operative complications reduced.

SUMMARY:
The effects of inflammatory activity following surgical intervention can injure pulp tissues; in severe cases it can lead to pulpal complications. With this article, the authors report on the effects of cavity preparation and restoration events and how they can interact together to reduce or increase the severity of pulpal inflammatory activity in 202 restored Class V cavities. Although some inflammatory activity was observed in the absence of bacteria, the severity of pulpal inflammatory activity was increased when cavity restorations became infected. Zinc oxide eugenol and resin-modified glass ionomer cement prevented bacterial microleakage in cavity restorations, with no severe inflammatory activity observed with these materials. Bacteria were observed in cavities restored with enamel bonding resin and adhesive bonded composites and were associated with severe grades of inflammatory activity. The cavity remaining dentin thickness influenced the grade of inflammatory activity. In the absence of infection, the grade of inflammatory activity decreased after 20 weeks post-operatively. In the presence of infection, the grade of pulpal inflammation remained stable until a minimum of 30 weeks had elapsed.


Laboratory Research

Comparative Wear Resistance of Reinforced Glass Ionomer Restorative Materials

AUJ Yap • JCM Teo • SH Teoh

Clinical Relevance:
Fuji IX GP FAST may serve as a potential substitute for composites in low occlusal stress situations where fluoride release is desirable and aesthetic requirements are not high.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the wear resistance of three restorative reinforced glass ionomer cements (Fuji IX GP FAST [FJ], Miracle Mix [MM] and Ketac Silver [KS]). Microfilled (Silux [SX]) and mini-filled (Z100 [ZO]) composites were used for comparison. Six specimens were made for each material. The specimens were conditioned for one week in distilled water at 37ºC and subjected to wear testing at 20 MPa contact stress against SS304 counterbodies using a reciprocal compression-sliding wear instrumentation. Distilled water was used as lubricant. Wear depth (µm) was measured using profilometry every 2,000 cycles up to 10,000 cycles. Results were analyzed using ANOVA/Scheffe’s test (p<0.05). After 10,000 cycles of wear testing, ranking was as follows: KS>ZO>MM>FJ>SX. Wear ranged from 26.1 µm for SX to 71.5 µm for KS. The wear resistance of KS was significantly lower than FJ, MM and SX at all wear intervals. Although KS had significantly more wear than ZO at 2,000 to 6,000 cycles, no significant difference in wear was observed between these two materials at 8,000 and 10,000 cycles. Sintering of silver particles to glass ionomer cement (KS) did not appear to improve wear resistance. The simple addition of amalgam alloy to glass ionomer may improve wear resistance but results in poor aesthetics (silver-black color). FJ, which relies on improved chemistry instead of metal fillers, showed comparable wear resistance to the composites evaluated and is tooth-colored. It may serve as a potential substitute for composites in low-stress situations where fluoride release is desirable and aesthetic requirements are not high.

Influence of Thermal Cycling on OCA Wear of Composite Restoratives

AUJ Yap • KEC Wee • SH Teoh • CL Chew

Clinical Relevance:
Thermal cycling may have potentially detrimental consequences on the long-term clinical durability of some composites.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the effects of thermal cycling on wear of four commercial composite resins (Silux, Z100, Ariston and Surefil). Specimens of each material were divided into three treatment groups comprising a control and two different thermal cycling regimes. Control specimens were stored in distilled water at 35ºC for 178 hours. Thermal cycled specimens were stored in distilled water at 35ºC for 173 hours and subjected to five hours (300 cycles) of a thermal cycling regime consisting of the cycle ABAC, where A and B represent the fixed temperatures of 35ºC (28 seconds) and 15ºC (two seconds) and C, depending on the treatment group, was either 45ºC or 60ºC (two seconds). All specimens were subsequently subjected to wear testing at 20 MPa contact stress against SS304 counterbodies with distilled water as the lubricant. Wear depth (µm; n=6) was measured using profilometry every 2,000 cycles up to 10,000 cycles. Results were analyzed using ANOVA/Scheffe’s test (p<0.05). The effect of thermal cycling on wear was material-dependent. The wear of Silux and Z100 were not significantly affected by thermal cycling. Thermal cycling of Ariston at an upper temperature of 60ºC significantly decreased wear resistance. Thermal cycling affected only the early wear resistance of Surefil.

Marginal Quality of Tooth-Colored Restorations in Class II Cavities After Artificial Aging

J Manhart • M Schmidt • HY Chen • K-H Kunzelmann • R Hickel

Clinical Relevance:
Marginal quality of tooth-colored restorations in large Class II cavities achieves satisfactory results to enamel-limited margins but adhesion to dentin is still challenging.

SUMMARY:
This in vitro study compared the proximal marginal adaptation of direct composite restorations with composite and ceramic inlays inserted with different resin cements. Standardized MOD Class II inlay cavities with one proximal box extending below and the other above the CEJ were cut in 48 extracted human molars and randomly assigned to six groups (n=8). Incrementally layered direct composite restorations (P60), composite inlays (P60) and ceramic inlays (Empress; Cerec Vitablocs Mark II) were placed in the cavities. Three different resin cements (RelyX ARC; Variolink II high viscosity; Panavia 21) were used for luting the composite inlays. All ceramic inlays were cemented with RelyX ARC. After finishing and polishing, the teeth were stored for 24 hours in Ringer solution at 37°C before they were subjected to thermal and mechanical loading (5/55°C, 2000x; 50 N vertical load, 50000x). Margins were evaluated on epoxy replicas using a scanning electron microscope at X200 magnification. Statistical analysis was performed with non-parametric test methods (a=0.05). The adhesive interfaces to enamel exhibited high percentages of perfect margins for all groups (91.8% to 96%) and a maximum of 5.2% marginal gap formation. Dentin-limited cavity segments demonstrated more marginal openings and less perfect margins than enamel- bound areas; however, this was only statistically significant for direct composite restorations and composite inlays inserted with Variolink II and Panavia 21. RelyX ARC showed a significantly better adaptation to P60 inlays compared with the leucite-reinforced Empress ceramic but not the Vitablocs Mark II ceramic.

Marginal Fit of Alumina-and Zirconia-Based Fixed Partial Dentures Produced by a CAD/CAM System

J Tinschert • G Natt • W Mautsch • H Spiekermann • KJ Anusavice

Clinical Relevance:
The results of this in vitro study demonstrate that the Precident DCS system can produce alumina- and zirconia-based all-ceramic fixed partial dentures with an acceptable marginal fit that ensures a favorable clinical prognosis.

SUMMARY:
Clinical long-term success of all-ceramic dental restorations can be significantly influenced by marginal discrepancies. As a result, this in vitro study evaluated the marginal fit of alumina- and zirconia-based fixed partial dentures (FPDs) machined by the Precident DCS system. Different master steel models of three-, four- and five-unit posterior FPDs with an 0.8 mm chamfer preparation were produced. FPDs made of DC-Zirkon and In-Ceram Zirconia core ceramics were machined by the Precident DCS system. The marginal fit of the milled frameworks placed on the master steel models was determined by a replica technique using a light-body silicone to fill the discrepancies between crown and tooth and a heavy-body material to stabilize the light-body impression material. The impressions were poured into an epoxy resin material and each model was cross-sectioned with a low speed diamond saw to better visualize marginal discrepancies. The marginal fit of the FPDs was evaluated by scanning electron microscopy. The measurements of the marginal fit exhibited mean marginal discrepancies in a range between 60.5 and 74.0 µm, mean marginal gaps in a range from 42.9 to 46.3 µm, mean vertical discrepancies in a range from 20.9 to 48.0 µm and mean horizontal discrepancies in the range of 42.0 to 58.8 µm. Statistical data analysis was performed using the non-parametric test of Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney. The analysis revealed no significant differences (p>0.05) between the mean marginal gaps and vertical and horizontal discrepancies. How-ever, for some FPDs the mean values of the marginal discrepancies were significantly different (p=0.05). The wide range of the measured values may be attributed to the complex geometrical design of long span FPDs and difficulties regarding the milling process of brittle ceramic materials. Based on the selection of 100 µm as the limit of clinical acceptability, the results of this study can conclude that the level of marginal fit for alumina- and zirconia-based FPDs achieved with the Precident DCS system meet the clinical requirements.

Effects of Different Burs on Dentin Bond Strengths of Self-Etching Primer Bonding Systems

M Ogata • N Harada • S Yamaguchi • M Nakajima • PNR Pereira • J Tagami

Clinical Relevance:
Selecting a bur for cavity preparation is an important factor for improved bonding of adhesive systems using self-etching primer to dentin.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effects of cutting dentin with different types of burs on tensile bond strength using three self-etching primer bonding systems (Clearfil Liner Bond 2 [LB2], Clearfil Liner Bond 2V [2V] and Clearfil SE BOND [SE], Kuraray, Co, Ltd, Osaka, Japan). Thirty-six intact extracted human third molars were ground flat to expose occlusal dentin, followed by polishing the dentin surfaces with #600 SiC paper. The teeth were divided into four groups according to bur type and grit: fine cut fissure steel bur (SB600), cross cut fissure steel bur (SB703), regular grit diamond bur (DB). Controls were abraded with #600 grit SiC paper (AP#600). The dentin surfaces of the SB600, SB703 and DB groups were cut under copious air-water spray with the respective burs mounted in a dental handpiece. The teeth were treated with one of three adhesive systems, then composite buildups were created with Clearfil AP-X (Kuraray Co, Ltd, Osaka, Japan). After soaking in water at 37°C for 24 hours, serial vertical sections (0.7 mm thick, 7-8 slices per one tooth) were made, trimmed to form an hour-glass shape with a 1.0 mm2 cross-section and tensile bond strengths were determined at a cross-head speed of 1 mm/min. Statistical analysis was made using one and two-way ANOVA and Fisher’s PLSD test (p<0.05). Eight additional molars were prepared. Burs or abrasive paper were used for SEM observations of the dentin surfaces of each group before and after treatment with the self-etching primers. All adhesive systems yielded the same ranking of bond strengths to the surfaces prepared with different abrasives: from highest to lowest, AP#600 > SB600 > SB703 > DB. This ranking reached statistical significance using Clearfil Liner Bond 2V (p<0.05). Therefore, when cutting dentin, selecting the adequate bur type is important for improved bonding of adhesive systems using self-etching primer to dentin.

Microleakage in Amalgam Restorations: Influence of Cavity Cleanser Solutions and Anticariogenic Agents

E Piva • J Martos • FF Demarco

Clinical Relevance:
Solutions used to treat cavity preparations do not influence the microleakage of amalgam restorations, except for sodium hypochlorite in enamel.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated in vitro the influence of five solutions used to treat cavity preparations on microleakage of amalgam restorations. Seventy-two standard Class V cavities were prepared in buccal and lingual surfaces of 36 recently extracted human third molars. The cervical wall was located in cementum and the occlusal wall was located in enamel. Specimens were randomly divided into six groups (n=12) according to the solution employed to treat the cavities: Group I–2.5% sodium hypochlorite; Group II–Calcium hydroxide solution; Group III–1.23% Acidulated phosphate fluoride; Group IV–2% digluconate of chlorhexidine; Group V–anionic detergent solution (1.25% sodium lauryl sulfate) and Group VI–control group. The solutions were applied for one minute, followed by washing and drying. Two coats of copal varnish were applied in each cavity. The cavities were filled with capsuled amalgam GS-80 (SDI). After finishing and polishing, the specimens were submitted for thermal cycling followed by immersion in methylene blue. Then, the specimens were sectioned and microleakage was evaluated based on a standard ranking under magnification (40x). Data were subjected to statistical analysis using non-parametric tests. Results of the study concluded that leakage was higher in cementum than enamel (p<0.01). The substances employed have no influence on microleakage except for sodium hypochlorite, which increased leakage values in enamel (p<0.05).

Effects of Soft-Start Irradiation on the Depth of Cure and Marginal Adaptation to Dentin

T Hasegawa • K Itoh • W Yukitani • S Wakumoto • H Hisamitsu

Clinical Relevance:
For marginal integrity of resin composite restorations, the optimum combination of dentin bonding system and resin composite is more important than the irradiation method.

SUMMARY:
Marginal adaptation of four resin composites, Clearfil APX, Estelite, Silux Plus and Z-100 cured with two irradiation methods (soft-start or high-power start) of a commercial soft-start halogen lamp unit (Elipar Highlight) were evaluated by measurement of the wall-to-wall contraction gap width. One-hundred and sixty cylindrical cavities, 3 mm in diameter and 1.5 mm in depth, were prepared in extracted human molars. The 80 cavity walls were treated with the Megabond system and each 20 cavities were filled with one of four resin composites. Then, each 10 fillings were irradiated by the soft-start method (soft-power light for 10 seconds followed by high-power light for 30 seconds) or high-power light for 40 seconds. The other 80 cavity walls were treated with an experimental bonding system consisting of 0.5M EDTA as a conditioner, 35% glyceryl mono-methacrylate as a primer and Clearfil Photo Bond as a bonding agent. The cavities were restored wtih the four resin composites and two irradiation methods, the same as the Megabond group. The contraction gap was measured with a light microscope and expressed in % of the cavity diameter. In addition, the curing capability of these two light sources was evaluated by measurement of the curing depth of the four resin composites using a split Teflon mold 4 mm in inner-diameter and 8 mm in height. Marginal gap formation of Clearfil APX, Estelite and Silux Plus with the experimental bonding system was completely prevented regardless of the kind of irradiation methods used. The deterioration of marginal adaptation caused by the Megabond system could not be improved by use of the soft-start method programmed in Elipar Highlight.

Adherence of Plaque Components to Different Restorative Materials

K Kawai • M Urano

Clinical Relevance:
New types of ceramics exhibited the least amount of bacterial and glucan adhesion compared to amalgam, resin composite and casting alloy irrespective of surface finishings.

SUMMARY:
This study compared the amount of artificial plaque synthesized in vitro by Streptococcus sobrinus on various dental materials using radioisotopes. In particular, plaque-retaining capacities of new types of ceramics were the focus of this study.

Specimens were fabricated from the following materials (one amalgam alloy [Spherical-D], one casting gold alloy [Casting Gold TYPE I], one resin composite [Herculite XR] and three ceramics [Vita Celay Blanks, IPS Empress and Dicor MGC]). The amount of bacteria and glucans adhered on the specimens was measured after incubation for 24 hours at 37°C with radio-labeled cariogenic bacteria and sucrose. This adhesion test was performed using two different surfaces with 600-grit roughness and clinical smoothness. Irrespective of the surface roughness, the least amount of plaque adhered to the ceramics. However, in the case of the resin composite and amalgam, the amount of bacteria and glucan adhesion decreased dramatically by polishing, though there were no statistically different changes in the amount of bacteria and glucans that adhered to the ceramics even after polishing. In general, the amount of adhered bacteria showed almost the same tendency as that of glucans. Although no statistical differences in the amount of bacteria and glucan adhesion were detected among the three ceramics investigated in this study, a lesser amount of bacteria and glucans adhered to them compared to the other materials.

Effectiveness of Surface Protection of Resin Modified Glass Ionomer Cements Evaluated Spectrophotometrically

DFG Cefaly • BGM Seabra • CMC Tapety • EM Taga • F Valera • MFL Navarro

Clinical Relevance:
It is necessary to use surface protectors over resin-modified glass ionomer cement restorations; all tested agents showed effective protection.

SUMMARY:
The effectiveness of four surface protectors for resin-modified glass ionomer cements was evaluated by spectrophotometrically determining dye uptake. Ninety specimens, 3.0 mm in diameter and 1.0 mm in height, were made with Photac-Fil, Fuji II LC and Vitremer and divided into six groups for each material. Positive and negative controls were not protected while experimental specimens were protected with proprietary glaze, nail varnish, flowable resin and glaze. The discs were immersed in 0.1% methylene blue solution for 10 minutes after mixing, except for those negative control specimens that were immersed in deionized-water. After 24 hours, the specimens were washed and the protectors trimmed with Sof-Lex discs. The specimens were then removed from the matrixes and individually placed in 1.5 mL of 65% nitric acid for five hours. The absorbance was determined spectrophotometrically at 590 nm. Dye uptake was expressed in µg dye/specimen. The data were analyzed by two-way ANOVA and Tukey-Kramer tests. All surface protectors tested were effective. For Fuji II LC and Vitremer no differences were observed among tested protections. For Photac-Fil, nail varnish showed better performance than the proprietary glaze.

Effect of Liners on Cusp Deflection and Gap Formation in Composite Restorations

QD Alomari • JW Reinhardt • DB Boyer

Clinical Relevance:
Using a resin-modified glass ionomer liner beneath directly placed MOD resin composite restorations decreased the polymerization-induced cusp deflection.

SUMMARY:
This study measured deformation of cusps and gap formation associated with MOD resin composite restorations in maxillary premolars with and without the use of low elastic modulus liners. Low elastic modulus liners may reduce the deformation by absorbing polymerization shrinkage stress. Forty maxillary premolars were mounted in stone and slot MOD cavities were prepared. Teeth were randomized into four groups. In Group A, cavities were etched, Single Bond was applied and the cavities were restored with Z-100 composite. In Group B, the same was done except that a layer of flowable composite (Revolution) was place and cured after the bonding agent. In Group C, the same steps were followed as Group A but a layer of glass ionomer (Vitrebond) was placed and cured before the bonding agent. In Group D, a thin layer of composite was placed (after the bonding agent) as a base and cured and the cavities were filled. The distance between indexed cusp tips was measured before the restorations were finished and five minutes and 24 hours after the restorations were completed. The samples were then sectioned mesiodistally and epoxy resin replicas were made and prepared for SEM evaluation of gap formation. The mean contraction of the cusps in µm at 5 minutes and 24 hours, respectively, for each group was A) 47 and 30, B) 35 and 21, C) 23 and 8 and D) 40 and 28. Groups A and D resulted in the highest deformation, B was intermediate and C was the lowest. There was no statistically significant difference in gap formation between the groups.


Clinical Survey

Current Teaching of Cariology in North American Dental Schools

TD Clark • IA Mjör

Clinical Relevance:
Research in cariology has greatly improved our understanding of the disease dental caries and is providing new, more effective and conservative treatment alternatives. In this paper, the attention given this major field of study by North American Dental Schools was reviewed.

SUMMARY:
All 65 dental schools in the United States and Canada were contacted to obtain information relevant to their cariology teaching effort, the caries management philosophy, the diagnostic threshold for surgical intervention and the non-surgical treatment alternatives implemented.

Forty-three schools (66%) responded to the request for information. Marked variations in the teaching of cariology and the implementation of modern diagnostic and treatment modalities were noted. The results indicate that with exceptions, efforts to increase curricular time and make organizational changes that would promote cariology as an important academic and clinical endeavor have fallen far short of predictions made more than 20 years ago for North America.

Many cariology programs in North American dental schools lack the detail and depth expected for this important area of clinical dentistry.


Clinical Technique/Case Report

Custom Matrix Adaptation with Elastic Cords

DCN Chan

Clinical Relevance:
Proper placement of the matrix and wedge is critical to the success of Class II and III amalgam and resin composite restorations. Improper placement of matrix and wedges can result in poor contours or contacts, overhangs or weakness resulting from poorly condensed restorative material. Occasionally, a clinician encounters a concavity at the gingival cavosurface margin of a Class II cavity, which makes this area difficult to restore properly with amalgam or resin composite. This paper describes a technique for adaptation of the matrix in cases where the gingival cavosurface margin involves a concavity and other anatomical variations.

SUMMARY:
Interproximal dental wedges are commonly used in Class II and Class III restorations. They force teeth apart enough to compensate for the thickness of the matrix, support the matrix against packing pressures of filling materials, prevent matrix displacement or filling excess/overhang and preserve anatomical tooth and tissue contours of the interdental space (Qualtrough & Wilson, 1991). Occasionally, concavity at the gingival cavosurface margin of a prepared cavity makes this area difficult to restore properly with amalgam or resin composite (Figure 1). Such concavities are frequently seen in the cervical area of maxillary premolars, in the mesial roots of mandibular molars and occasionally in the distal aspects of maxillary molars.

Existing preformed triangular-shaped wooden wedges are not adaptable to concavities and other conditions such as root caries or irregular tooth contours. Other wedge material, such as clear acrylic dental wedges used with light-cured composite fillings, are difficult to adapt and adjust. New innovative methods are frequently proposed to tackle such challenges (Ireland, 1985; Khera & Swift, 1989; Woodmansey, 1998).

A new product, Flexi Wedge (Common Sense Dental Products, Inc, Spring Lake, MI), has been specifically designed to solve some of the problem. However, the technique for the placement of Flexi Wedge is quite different from wooden wedges and requires special college pliers, hemostat, Howe pliers or a similar-type instrument. Strong driving force, plus a gentle up-and-down rocking motion, is required to drive the wedge into the correct position.

This paper offers a simple solution for a few of those clinical situations where difficulties are encountered. The solution lies in use of an elastic cord material capable of deforming sufficiently to take on and conform to any concave aspects of adjacent tooth surfaces. Such an elastic cord is readily available in rubber dam procedures. The clinician can employ the conventional wooden wedges for this technique without extra equipment or expense for new products.



SEPTEMBER-OCTOBER, Volume 26, Number 5

Editorial

Oxymoron

Dr Michael A Cochran


Clinical Research

One-Year Clinical Evaluation of Posterior Packable Resin Composite Restorations

AD Loguercio • A Reis • LE Rodrigues Filho • ALS Busato

Clinical Relevance:
Clinical evaluation of four packable posterior composites and a control showed some significant differences after one year.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the clinical performance of four packable resin composite restorative materials in posterior teeth (Class I and II) compared with one hybrid composite after one year. Eighty-four restorations were placed in 16 patients. Each patient received at least five restorations. The tested materials were: (1) Solitaire + Solid Bond; (2) ALERT + Bond-1; (3) Surefil + Prime & Bond NT; (4) Filtek P60 + Single Bond and; (5) TPH Spectrum + Prime & Bond 2.1. All restorations were made using rubber dam isolation, and the cavity design was restricted to the elimination of carious tissue. Deeper cavities were covered with calcium hydroxide and/or glass ionomer cement. In shallow and medium cavities, no protection was performed except for the respective adhesive system used in each group. Each adhesive system and resin composite was placed according to the manufacturer’s instructions. One week later, the restorations were finished/polished and evaluated according to the USPHS modified criteria. All patients attended the one-year recall, and the 84 restorations were evaluated at that time based on the same evaluation criteria. The scores were submitted to statistical analysis (Chi-square test, p<0.05). Solitaire and TPH showed some fractures at marginal ridges. Solitaire, ALERT and TPH showed some concerns related to color match and surface texture. Surefil and Filtek P60 showed an excellent clinical performance after one year.

Color Perception Among Different Dental Personnel

CPC Sim • AUJ Yap • J Teo

Clinical Relevance:
For teeth with very dark shades, shade selection should be done in conjunction with dental technicians, whenever possible.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the differences in color perception among distinct groups of dental personnel. Four groups of dental personnel (10 dental technicians, 15 final-year dental students, 15 general practitioners and 10 prosthodontists) were asked to match seven test tabs of shades A1, A4, B2, B3, C2, C4 and D3 (Z100 shade guide, 3M Dental Products, St Paul, MN 55144, USA) against a standard Vita shade guide under similar lighting conditions. The results obtained were computed into L*a*b* values using a small-area colorimeter (Dental Colorimeter, Minolta Camera Pte Ltd). The data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA/post-hoc Scheffe’s test at significant level p<0.05. The results showed significant differences in ?E (color difference) between the dental technicians and the clinicians for shade C4. The significant difference that was observed in ?E for dark shades between dental personnel was mainly contributed to a disparity in L* values. A significant difference in ?L* was observed between dental technicians and prosthodontists for shade C4.


Laboratory Research

SEM Evaluation of the Interaction Between A Three-Step Adhesive and Dentin

RY Andia-Merlin • N Garone-Netto • VE Arana-Chavez

Clinical Relevance:
The profuse penetration of Scotchbrand Multi-Purpose results in numerous resin tags and microtags that establish intimate contact with collagen fibrils on dentin.

SUMMARY:
Interaction between resin tags and microtags of adhesive systems and dentinal collagen fibrils is a poorly understood aspect of adhesion. This study evaluated this interaction in 25 recently extracted human third molars. Each tooth was embedded in an epoxy resin and cross-sectioned to obtain two 1-mm-thick dentin disks. The outer dentin surfaces were polished with wet 600-grit sandpaper to create a uniform smear layer. After etching with 35% phosphoric acid for 15 seconds, the primer and adhesive of Scotchbond Multi-Purpose and the resin composite Z100 (3M Dental Products, St Paul, MN 55144, USA) were placed on the dentinal surfaces according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The disks were left in distilled water at 37°C for two weeks, then fractured perpendicular to the bonded surfaces in order to obtain two hemi-disks. The fractured surfaces were treated with 2N-chloridric acid and processed for scanning electron microscopy. Gold-coated specimens were examined with a JEOL 6100 scanning electron microscope. Results showed a hybrid layer with resin tags of approximately 100 µm in length and numerous and fine branching resin microtags. The tags and microtags created by this three-step adhesive system were observed in intimate contact with the collagen fibrils of dentin, even in deeper zones which were not affected by acid etching. It suggests that adhesion to dentin may include both micromechanical and chemical aspects.

Effect of Adhesives on the Inhibition of Secondary Caries Around Compomer Restorations

T Itota • S Nakabo • Y Iwai, Konish • M Nagamine • Y Torii • M Yoshiyama

Clinical Relevance:
For compomer restorations, use of an adhesive that does not contain Bis-GMA resin may be beneficial for adhesion to dentin without reducing the contact potential for secondary caries inhibition.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of adhesives on the inhibition of secondary caries around compomer restorations in vitro. Two adhesive systems with a Bis-GMA resin, Scotch bond Multi-purpose (MP) and Single Bond (SB), and one adhesive system with no Bis-GMA resin, F2000 compomer primer/adhesive (PA), were used prior to placement of the compomer (F2000), and non-fluoride releasing resin composite (Z100) was used as a control. Class V cavities prepared on extracted human premolars were restored with various combinations of materials: F2000/MP, F2000/SB, F2000/PA, Z100/MP, Z100/SB and Z100/PA. The restored teeth were incubated in bacterial medium containing sucrose with Streptococcus mutans for two weeks after storage for 14 days. On microradiographs, the radio-opaque layers adjacent to the F2000 restorations were thick and clear, while the layers in the Z100 restorations were unclear. In the F2000 restorations, the mean thickness of the radio-opaque layers in the PA group was significantly greater than that of the MP and SB groups. In fluoride-releasing measurement, F2000 coated with PA showed a significantly higher amount of fluoride release than MP and SB, and no significant difference in the amount of fluoride release from uncoated F2000.

These results indicated that applying an adhesive without Bis-GMA resin to compomer restoration has no suppressive effect on the fluoride release from compomer and might be beneficial for inhibiting secondary caries in vitro.

The Effect of Flexural Load Cycling on the Microleakage of Cervical Resin Composites

S Kubo • H Yokota • Y Sata • Y Hayashi

Clinical Relevance:
Occlusal forces, specifically those that generate tensile stresses on cervical restorations, may also affect long-term marginal integrity.

SUMMARY:
Although several in vitro studies have attempted to investigate the microleakage of Class V resin composites under loading, the effect of load cycling on marginal seal is still unclear. This may be due to the fact that axial loads were applied to the specimens. This study investigated the effect of flexural loads on marginal sealing of cervical resin composites. One hundred and fifty cervical wedge-shaped cavities were restored with Clearfil Photo Bond, Clearfil Liner Bond 2, Scotchbond Multi-Purpose with 10% maleic acid, Scotchbond Multi-Purpose with 35% phosphoric acid or Mac-Bond 2 according to the manufacturers’ instructions. After the restorations were finished, 10 specimens from each group were immersed in 0.5% basic fuchsin solution to examine microleakage. Prior to dye solution immersion, 20 specimens were subjected to flexural load cycling (1 mm labio-lingual or linguo-labial displacement at the incisal edge, 10,000 cycles, 1 cycle/second). The data were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test and the Mann-Whitney U-test (p<0.05). When the flexural loads were not applied, both the incisal and apical margins showed good marginal sealing, regardless of the adhesive system used. Labio-lingual loading significantly deteriorated the marginal integrity at the incisal enamel margins, except for those restored with Clearfil Photo Bond. However, only Clearfil Photo Bond demonstrated a significant increase in microleakage along the apical dentin margins. Linguo-labial loading had no significant effect on the marginal seal.

Influence of Light Energy Density on Effectiveness of Composite Cure

AUJ Yap • C Seneviratne

Clinical Relevance:
Light energy density influences the effectiveness of composite cure. Use of low light intensities with soft-start polymerization and pulse-delay techniques must be compensated for with higher intensity light phases.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of light energy density (intensity x time) on the effectiveness of composite cure in view of the curing profiles of new light-polymerization units. This investigation used a digital microhardness tester to evaluate the hardness of the top/bottom surfaces and hardness ratio of 2 mm thick composite specimens after exposure to different light energy densities. Parameters included five light intensities (200, 300, 400, 500 and 600 mW/cm2) and nine irradiation times (10, 20, 30, 40, 60, 80, 100, 120 and 180 seconds). Six samples were evaluated for each light energy density. KHN values and the hardness ratio obtained with 40 seconds cure at 400 mW/cm2 was used as control. Results were analyzed with one-way ANOVA and Scheffe’s post-hoc test at significance level (0.05). Correlation between curing time and hardness values and ratio was done using Pearson’s correlation at significance level 0.01. Results showed that the adequate hardness for surface finishing could be obtained with 20 seconds irradiation at lower intensities of 200 or 300 mW/cm2. Optimal cure of the bottom surfaces could not be achieved with 200 mW/cm2, but was attained with 300 mW/cm2 only after 120 seconds of irradiation. Optimal cure of the bottom surfaces was possible with 30 and 20 seconds irradiation at 500 and 600 mW/cm2, respectively. Effective cure was not achieved with low light intensities (200 to 300 mW/cm2) but could be achieved with high intensities (500 and 600 mW/cm2) after 30 seconds of irradiation.

Influence of Veneering Composite Composition on the Efficacy of Fiber-Reinforced Restorations (FRR)

A Ellakwa • A Shortall • M Shehata • P Marquis

Clinical Relevance:
This investigation assessed the influence of storage time, up to six months, on the flex- ural properties of four commercially available fiber-reinforced veneer composites. In addition, two experimental composites were used to assess the influence of varying filler loading and resin matrix chemistry on the efficacy of fiber reinforced composites. The results demonstrated that the chemical composition of veneer composites is a critical factor in terms of the degree of reinforcement.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of fiber reinforcement on the flexural properties of four commercial (Artglass, Belleglass HP, Herculite XRV and Solidex) veneering composites (Series A) and two experimental composites (Series B&C). This study investigated how the composition of the veneering composites influenced the enhancement of strength and modulus produced by fiber reinforcement. The formulation of the experimental composites were varied by changing the filler load (Series B) or the resin matrix chemistry (Series C) to assess the effect these changes would have on the degree of reinforcement.

In Series A, the commercial veneering composites were reinforced by an Ultra-High-Molecular-Weight Polyethylene fiber (UHMW-PE/Connect) to evaluate flexural properties after 24 hours and six months. In Series B, experimental composites with the same organic matrix but with different filler loads (40% to 80% by weight) were also reinforced by Connect fiber to evaluate flexural properties. In Series C, experimental composites (Systems 1-4) with the same filler load (76.5% by weight) but with different organic matrix compositions were reinforced by Connect fiber to evaluate flexural properties. For Series B and C, flexural properties were evaluated after 24 hours water storage.

All the samples were prepared in a mold 2 mm x 2 mm x 25 mm and stored in distilled water at 37°C until they were ready for flexural testing in an Instron Universal Testing Machine using a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute. The results showed no significant differences in the flexural strength (FS) between any of the commercial reinforced composites in Series A. The flexural modulus (FM) of the fiber-reinforced Belleglass HP group was significantly higher than for Artglass and Solidex. Water storage for six months had no significant (p>0.05) effect on the flexural strength of three of the four reinforced veneering composites. The flexural strength for Artglass was significantly reduced (p<0.05) by six-month water storage. In Series B, however, increasing the amount of filler loading improved the flexural modulus of the reinforced experimental composite but had no effect on its flexural strength. In Series C, changing the organic matrix formulation had no affect on flexural strength but affected the flexural modulus of the reinforced experimental composite.

Effects of Nd:YAG Laser, Air-Abrasion and Acid-Etching on Human Enamel and Dentin

H Sazak • C Türkmen • M Günday

Clinical Relevance:
Nd:YAG laser and air-abrasive systems created more surface irregularity in less time than acid etchant when applied to enamel and dentin surfaces.

SUMMARY:
The effects of the Nd:YAG laser, air-abrasion and acid-etching systems on mineral content and surface morphology of cut dentin and enamel were examined in 10 extracted human teeth. Enamel specimens were lased for two seconds at a fluence of 0.75 J and a frequency of 15 Hz, air-abraded for two seconds with 50 micron Al-oxide and etched for 60 seconds with 37% ortho-phosphoric acid. Dentinal specimens were subjected to the same procedure for half the time. Untreated areas of the same specimens served as the control. Morphologically, the lased dentin showed an apparently melted surface with partial obstruction of the dentin tubules, as well as cracks along the lased surface. Air-abrasion created very irregular surfaces on enamel and dentin. Dentin tubules were observed on the acid-etched dentin samples but not the air-abraded surfaces. The Nd:YAG laser created the most surface irregularity on both enamel and dentin. Laser treatment appeared to alter the chemical structure and surface morphology of the dentin and enamel.

Relationship Between Nanoleakage and Long-Term Durability of Dentin Bonds

M Okuda • PNR Pereira • M Nakajima • J Tagami

Clinical Relevance:
The bond strength of single bottle adhesive systems to dentin gradually decreases over time.

SUMMARY:
This study tested the hypothesis that long-term durability of resin bonds to dentin would directly relate to the nanoleakage of dentin bonding systems. Twenty extracted third molars were ground flat with #600 grit SIC paper under running water to expose middle dentin. One-Step or Single Bond was applied to the dentin surface according to the manufacturer’s instruction. A crown was built-up with Clearfil AP-X resin composite and the specimens were stored in water for 24 hours at 37°C. The bonded assemblies were cut mesio-distally perpendicular to the interface in approximately 0.7 mm thick slabs and trimmed for microtensile bond strength testing. All slabs were immersed in individual bottles containing 37°C water that was changed daily. Specimens were randomly assigned to four groups (one day, three, six and nine months), and at the specified time period, the specimens to be tested were randomly divided into two subgroups for testing: 50% AgNO3 and the control. In the 50% AgNO3 subgroup, the slabs were coated with fingernail varnish except for approximately 0.5 mm around the bonded interface and immersed for one hour in 50% AgNO3, followed by exposure in a photo developing solution for 12 hours just prior to debonding. The specimens in the control subgroup were soaked in water until they were debonded. Then, all specimens were subjected to microtensile bond testing. Micrographs of the fractured surfaces of the debonded specimens in the AgNO3 subgroup were taken using light microscopy. They were then subjected to image analysis by NIH Image PC (Scion, Fredrick, MD, USA), and the area of silver penetration was quantitated. The fractured surface was further analyzed under the SEM. Bond strength data and the silver penetration areas were subjected to two and three-way ANOVA and Fisher’s PLSD test at the 95% level of confidence. Regression analysis was used to test the relationship between bond strengths and the silver penetration area at each time period. The tensile bond strength of both materials gradually decreased over time. Specimens bonded with One-Step showed less silver nanoleakage at one day compared to three, six and nine months (p<0.05), but there were no significant differences between the nanoleakage measured at three, six and nine months. In contrast, for specimens bonded with Single Bond, there were no statistically significant differences in the silver nanoleakage among the four time periods tested (p>0.05). No correlation was observed between bond strength and nanoleakage for either bonding system. Nanoleakage occurred in both adhesive systems, and bond strengths gradually decreased over time. However, there was no correlation between bond strength and nanoleakage for either adhesive system in this study.

Microleakage of Class V Resin Composite Restorations After Bur, Air-Abrasion or Er:YAG Laser Preparation

SAM Corona • MC Borsatto • RG Palma Dibb • RP Ramos • A Brugnera, Jr • JD Pécora

Clinical Relevance:
Class V cavities prepared by either air-abrasion or Er:YAG laser, with a subsequent phosphoric acid etching, showed microleakage values comparable to conventional dental bur preparation. However, conventional dental bur preparation followed by acid etching produced the best overall seal.

SUMMARY:
This in vitro study compared the microleakage of Class V resin composite restorations placed in cavities prepared with a high-speed dental bur, air-abrasion or Er:YAG laser. Twenty sound extracted human third molars were selected and randomly assigned to four equal Groups (n=10): Group I, cavities were cut by dental drill at high-speed; Group II, aluminum oxide air-abrasion was used for cavity preparation, and in Groups III and IV, cavities were prepared by Er:YAG laser. Following cavity preparation, Groups I and II were acid-etched, Group III was treated only by Er:YAG laser and Group IV was conditioned by Er:YAG laser followed by acid-etching. Cavities were restored (Single Bond + Z-100) and the teeth stored for seven days in distilled water. Then, the restorations were polished and the specimens thermocycled, immersed in a 0.2% Rhodamine solution, sectioned and analyzed for leakage at the occlusal (enamel) and cervical (dentin/cementum) interfaces using an optical microscope connected to a video camera. The images were digitized and software was utilized for microleakage assessment. Upon analyzing the results, statistically significant differences (p<0.01) between the occlusal and cervical regions for all groups was observed, and, as a rule, there was better marginal sealing at the enamel margins. The highest degree of infiltration was observed for cavities prepared and treated exclusively by Er:YAG (Group III). The other experimental groups showed statistical similarities in the amount of marginal leakage at the enamel margins. However, at the cervical margins, there was a significant difference (p<0.05) between Group I and the remaining groups. None of the techniques completely eliminated marginal microleakage at the dentin/cementum margins.

Polymerization Shrinkage of Densely-Filled Resin Composites

TC Aw • JI Nicholls

Clinical Relevance:
Using densely-filled resin composites can reduce the amount of shrinkage that occurs during light curing of composites.

SUMMARY:
A new group of restorative materials called “packable” composites has recently been introduced. These products are essentially highly-filled or densely-filled hybrid resin composites. One of the many claims made about these materials is that they undergo less polymerization shrinkage than their conventional counterparts. This in vitro investigation compared the amount of linear shrinkage that occurs within a variety of densely filled resin composites (DFC) and conventional hybrid resin composites when cured with a visible halogen light. Six DFC resins (Alert, Ariston, P60, Prodigy, Solitaire and Surefil) and two hybrids (TPH-Spectrum, Z100) were used in this study. Dimensional change was measured in a linear direction using a calibrated light microscope. Eighty samples of resin composite were tested, resulting in eight groups of 10 samples (N=10) each. The one-way ANOVA with Student-Newman-Keuls post-hoc test was used to compare the shrinkage between groups, and Pearson’s Correlation was used to test the relationship between filler characteristics and shrinkage. Alert and P-60 had significantly less shrinkage than Solitaire, Ariston, Prodigy, Z-100 and TPH-S. Thus, the shrinkage values of some DFC resins were significantly less and others were no different from conventional hybrid resins. There is a moderate association between filler volume and shrinkage. Filler size and resin chemistry are other factors that may also effect shrinkage.

The Effect of Curing Light Intensity on the Cytotoxicity of a Dentin-Bonding Agent

RS Chen • CC Liuïw • WY Tseng • CY Hong • CC Hsieh • JH Jeng

Clinical Relevance:
A suitable light source should be used to cure dentin bonding agents as completely as possible to avoid any potential for pulpal toxicity.

SUMMARY:
Various dentin-bonding agents (DBAs) have been widely used to improve the bonding strength of dental resins and to prevent microleakage at the resin-dentin interface, although DBA may exert potentially detrimental effects upon dental pulp. In this study, a DBA (Scotchbond Multi-purpose) cured at different light intensities (100, 200 and 300-mW/cm2) for 10 seconds was extracted with Dulbecco’s modified Eagle’s medium (DMEM) for 24 hours. Thereafter, pulp cells (1 x 104 cells/well) were exposed to DMEM with or without DBA extract for 12 hours, 24 hours and five days. Pulp-cell cytotoxicity was measured with a modified 3-(4,5-dimethyl-thiazol -2-yl)-2,5-diphenyl-tetrazolium bromide (MTT) assay. No significant cytotoxicity of DBA eluents on pulp cells was found for the 12-hour exposure group. Following 24-hour exposure of cells to DBA cured at 100-mW/cm2, pulp cells became rounder, more retracted and lost some cellular processes as compared to controls. Five-day exposure of pulp cells to DBA extract cured by light at levels of 100, 200 and 300 mW/cm2, respectively, led to a growth retardation of 26%, 48% and 70% as analyzed by the inhibition of mitochondrial dehydrogenase activity. These results indicate that DBA may exert some cytotoxic effects upon dental pulp, especially when DBA-curing is insufficiently complete, as may occur at a low light intensity.

Fracture Resistance of Teeth Restored with the Bonded Amalgam Technique

GM Dias de Souza • GDS Pereira • CTS Dias • LAMS Paulillo

Clinical Relevance:
Bonding amalgam technique in mesio-occlusal-distal (MOD) cavities within 2/5 the intercuspal distance width and 3/5 the height of the crown depth did not increase the fracture resistance of maxillary premolars.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the fracture resistance of maxillary premolars with MOD Class II cavity preparations restored with silver amalgam (G1), Scotchbond Multi Purpose Plus and silver amalgam (G2) and Panavia F and silver amalgam (G3). After the restorations were made, the specimens were stored at 37ºC for 24 hours at 100% humidity and submitted to the compression test. Statistical analysis of the data (ANOVA and Tukey Test) revealed no significant differences among the three groups that were studied.

Temperature Transmission of High-Output Light-Curing Units Through Dentin

RW Loney • RBT Price

Clinical Relevance:
Light-curing units with concentrating light guides or plasma arc light sources can significantly affect thermal transfer through dentin.

SUMMARY:
Light-curing units used for polymerizing restorative resins produce heat during operation. Newer curing units with concentrating light guides or different light sources may require shorter curing times, however, the effect of such modifications on temperature transfer to the pulp is unknown. This study examined the effect of high output light-curing units on temperature transfer through resin composite and dentin.

Temperature rise was measured for 40 seconds for one curing light (Optilux 401 Curing Light) with either a standard 8 mm light guide tip or a light-concentrating tip (Turbo Light Guide), and for three seconds with a plasma arc lamp (Apollo 95E Curing Light). Temperatures were directly recorded at the tip of the light guide and through a sandwich composed of a 1 mm thick pre-cured cylinder of resin composite and dentin (dentin thickness either 0.58 mm or 1.45 mm).

The mean temperature rise ranged from 1.8°C, measured through the sandwich of 1 mm of composite and 1.45 mm of dentin with the plasma arc unit, to 26.4°C measured directly on the Turbo light guide. For each light guide, the temperature increase was greatest when measured directly on the curing tip and least when measured through the composite and 1.45 mm dentin specimens. When measured through the composite/dentin sandwich, the plasma arc unit produced the lowest temperature increase (0.58 mm thick dentin specimen = 5.1°C; 1.45 mm thick dentin specimen = 1.8°C). For a given thickness of resin, the differences in temperature change for all comparisons among the three curing unit/light guides were significant at the 95% level of confidence. Also, for a given light, the differences in temperature for all comparisons among the dentin thicknesses were significant at the 95% level of confidence. However, there were three comparisons of light unit and dentin thickness interaction that were not significant at the 95% level of confidence. For all other comparisons of interaction, significant differences were found at the 95% level of confidence. The temperature increased by 42% to 56% when the Turbo Light Guide was used compared to the standard light guide for thick and thin dentin specimens, respectively.


Commentary

The Basis for Everyday, Real-Life Operative Dentistry

IA Mjör

SUMMARY:
This “opinion paper” focuses on how clinical judgement develops, the evidence-base for general dental practice in operative dentistry, the impact of dental research and how results from practice-based research may play a significant role in identifying reoccurring problems in dental practice.

Clinical education and dental practice should be based on scientific data, and evidence-based teaching must be the goal for any clinical curriculum. However, many procedures in operative dentistry are based on experience rather than scientific evidence. Black’s principles of cavity preparations for amalgam restorations, for example, were not scientifically based. They represented sound clinical judgments at the time they were developed. On the other hand, the caries-preventing measures taught and practiced in most industrialized countries today, are examples of treatments largely based on scientific evidence. However, discussions over the past decades on evidence-based operative dentistry bemoan the fact that the scientific foundation for many clinical procedures is meager, or as a renowned professor of dentistry put it, “If the teaching in restorative dentistry should be based on scientific evidence only, there would be very little teaching done.” This view sums up the state-of-the-art of evidence-based teaching in restorative dentistry.

The lack of scientific evidence in support of many well-accepted clinical procedures does not mean that the treatment rendered is inadequate or inferior. Trial and error, over decades of practice, has provided an experience base that is largely responsible for the high level of dental care furnished. Undoubtedly, the quality of care would be refined and improved, provided that a scientific basis can be established for all phases of treatment. However, the practice of operative dentistry, to a large extent, is also likely to be based on clinical experience in the future.



NOVEMBER-DECEMBER, Volume 26, Number 6

Editorial

OPERATIVE DENTISTRY: The Vanishing Discipline

Melvin R. Lund


Clinical Research

The Effect of 10% Carbamide Peroxide Bleaching Material on Microhardness of Sound and Demineralized Enamel and Dentin In Situ

RT Basting • AL Rodrigues Jr • MC Serra

Clinical Relevance:
In clinical situations, treatment with 10% carbamide peroxide agent can alter the microhardness of sound and demineralized enamel although it does not affect the microhardness of sound and demineralized dentin.

SUMMARY:
This in situ study evaluated the microhardness of sound and demineralized enamel and dentin submitted to treatment with 10% carbamide peroxide for three weeks. A 10% carbamide peroxide bleaching agent—Opalescence/Ultradent (OPA)— was evaluated against a placebo agent (PLA). Two hundred and forty dental fragments—60 sound enamel fragments (SE), 60 demineralized enamel fragments (DE), 60 sound dentin fragments (SD) and 60 demineralized dentin fragments (DD)—were randomly fixed on the vestibular surface of the first superior molars and second superior premolars of 30 volunteers. The volunteers were divided into two groups that received bleaching or the placebo agent at different sequences and periods at a double blind 2 x 2 crossover study with a wash-out period of two weeks. Microhardness tests were performed on the enamel and dentin surface. The SE and DE submitted to treatment with OPA showed lower microhardness values than the SE and DE submitted to treatment with PLA. There were no statistical differences in microhardness values for SD and DD submitted to the treatment with OPA and PLA. The results suggest that treatment with 10% carbamide peroxide bleaching material for three weeks alters the enamel microhardness, although it does not seem to alter the dentin microhardness.

A Prospective Clinical Study of a Multipurpose Adhesive Used for the Cementation of Resin-Bonded Bridges

YEY Aboush • N Estetah

Clinical Relevance:
The clinical retention rate of anterior resin-bonded bridges cemented with Panavia 21 Opaque adhesive appears similar to that of a multipurpose adhesive; greyness of the abutments, however, was a major disadvantage in using the multipurpose adhesive.

SUMMARY:
A clinical trial was conducted to assess comparatively the clinical performance of anterior resin-bonded bridges (RBBs) cemented with Panavia 21 Opaque (PO) or Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus (SBMP) used in conjunction with Scotchbond Resin Cement (SRC). Thirty-three bridges were cemented with PO and 31 bridges with SRC. The bridges were assessed six months after placement via a postal questionnaire. Two bridges (one in each group) failed at that stage. Clinical assessments at one year revealed that one PO bridge and five SRC bridges had failed. Chi-squared analysis, however, showed no significant difference (p>0.05) in the retention rate of the two groups. At the end of two years, eight bridges had failed (three PO and five SRC). Chi-squared analysis again revealed no significant difference in the retention rate provided by the two adhesives. Greyness of the abutment teeth of bridges cemented with SRC was a drawback in using this material. Many operators who participated in the trial felt the use of SRC/SBMP was time-consuming and rather complicated.

Treatment of Dentin with Polyacrylic Acid—A Retrospective Observational Study of the Effect Upon the Durability of Glass Ionomer Restorations

RG Chadwick • P Bartlett • JF McCabe • MJ Woolford

Clinical Relevance:
Although pre-treatment of cavities restored with conventional glass ionomer cements with polyacrylic acid (Tooth Cleanser) offers no statistical improvement to the long-term durability, it improves the chances of obtaining a dependable restoration.

SUMMARY:
This paper reports on the results of a material specific, retrospective observational study. It sought to determine the consequence of pre-treatment of cavity margins with the conventional glass polyalkenoate Chemfil II prior to restoration with Tooth Cleanser on restoration durability. All restorations were placed and varnished by senior dental students under the supervision of a staff member. Manufacturer recommendations were followed. Data on each restoration was collected and entered into a relational computer database. Data included details of cavity morphology and the use or non-use of Tooth Cleanser. Six years following the study start a manual search of all records was carried out to determine, for those patients continuing to attend the Dental Hospital, the number of failed and surviving restorations. This yielded a dataset of 149 restorations, of which 41 had been placed with the aid of Tooth Cleanser and 108 without. The number of failed restorations was 20 and 62, respectively. Survival analysis by the Kaplan-Meier method revealed median survival times of 2,094 days, when Tooth Cleanser was used and 1,748 days when not. Although 80% survival times of 1111.0 (SE=6.3) (With Tooth Cleanser) and 285.0 (SE=3.8) (Without Tooth Cleanser) days were observed, together with a Hazard Ratio of 1.49 (95% Confidence Intervals 0.92 & 2.31), a Logrank test revealed no statistically significant difference between the survival curves (p=0.12). It was concluded that although there was a trend for the application of Tooth Cleanser to improve the chances of obtaining a dependable restoration, this effect was not statistically significant.


Laboratory Research

Influence of Time and Thermocycling on Marginal Sealing of Several Dentin Adhesive Systems

C Lucena-Martín • MP González-Rodríguez • CM Ferrer-Luque • V Robles-Gijón • JM Navajas

Clinical Relevance:
The levels of leakage in enamel were minimal regardless of the experimental conditions applied or the adhesive used. Optibond Solo showed the best outcomes in dentin/cementum under the three experimental conditions.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the in vitro microleakage of six dentin adhesive systems. Triangle-shaped Class V cavities with coronal margin in enamel and gingival margin in cementum or root dentin were cut in the buccal surfaces of 90 non-carious single-root human teeth. These teeth were randomly assigned into six groups (n=15) for the evaluation of six different dentin adhesive systems: One Step, Prime & Bond 2.0, Syntac Single, Single Bond, Optibond Solo and Syntac Sprint. The preparations were restored with Degufill Ultra composite and polished using the Enhance system. Each group was randomly divided into three subgroups (n=5): samples of the first subgroup were immersed in 2% methylene blue solution for seven days; those of the second subgroup remained in a similar solution for 31 days; those of the third subgroup were thermocycled 500x at 5-55ºC and immersed in 2% methylene blue for seven days. All 90 teeth were then embedded in methacrylate and bucco-lingually sectioned; the dye penetration was evaluated using an 0-4 ordinal scale. All of the dentin adhesive groups showed minimal leakage at the enamel margins with increased leakage at the gingival margins. Optibond Solo showed the best outcomes among the dentin adhesives tested.

Influence of Eugenol-Containing Temporary Restorations on Bond Strength of Composite to Dentin

AUJ Yap • KC Shah • ET Loh • SS Sim • CC Tan

Clinical Relevance:
Using temporary restorations prior to composite placement should be avoided, if possible. Eugenol-containing temporary restorations mixed at a ratio of 10g powder: 2g liquid significantly decreased bond strength of composite to dentin and should not be employed clinically.

SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of eugenol-containing temporary restorations on bond strength of composite to dentin. Thirty-two freshly extracted human molars were embedded and horizontally sectioned at a level 2 mm from the central fossa to obtain a flat dentin surface. The teeth were randomly divided into four groups of eight teeth. Specimens in Group 1 (control) received no pre-treatment with any temporary restorations. Group 2 and 3 specimens were covered with IRM (eugenol-containing) mixed at powder: liquid (P:L) ratio of 10g: 1g and 10g: 2g, respectively. Specimens in Group 4 were covered with polycarboxylate cement (eugenol-free) mixed at a P:L ratio of 2.85g: 1g. The temporary restorations were mechanically removed with an ultrasonic scaler after one-week storage in distilled water at 37ºC. The dentin surfaces were cleaned with pumice-water slurry and treated with Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus bonding system according to manufacturer’s instructions. Composite (Z100) columns (3 mm diameter, 2 mm high) were applied and shear bond testing was carried out after 24 hours storage in distilled water at 37ºC using an Instron Universal testing machine with a cross-head speed of 0.5 mm/minute. The mode of failure was examined using a stereomicroscope at X40 magnification. Results were analyzed using one-way ANOVA/Scheffes’s post-hoc test at significance level 0.05. Ranking of bond strengths was as follows: Group 1 (22.58 MPa) > Group 2 (21.14 MPa) > Group 4 (15.35 MPa) > Group 3 (13.02 MPa). Group 3 had significantly lower bond strength than Groups 1 and 2. No significant difference in dentin bond strength was observed between the Group 1 (control) and Groups 2 and 4. Although the predominant mode of failure for Groups 1, 2 and 4 was cohesive in dentin, all specimens in Group 3 exhibited adhesive failure. Pre-treatment with polycarboxylate cement or IRM mixed at P:L ratio of 10g: 1g did not affect shear bond strength of composite to dentin. IRM mixed at a lower P:L ratio of 10g: 2g significantly decreased bond strength.

3-D Surface Profile Analysis: Different Finishing Methods for Resin Composites

L Marigo • M Rizzi • G La Torre • G Rumi

Clinical Relevance:
High levels of smoothness are produced by certain procedures on resin composite surfaces.

SUMMARY:
A microfilled and hybrid resin composites used for esthetic restoration were finished and polished using four methods: Enhance system, Sof-Lex system, Multi-step system and Identoflex points.

The tested materials were condensed into cylindrical molds, covered with a Mylar matrix at the surface to be tested and incrementally cured according to manufacturers’ instructions. Samples were randomized into four groups of three for each material and were finished/polished using the different methods. The samples were then analyzed by a 3-D surface profiler to obtain roughness average (Ra), root mean square value (rms), greatest distance peak-valley (PV), measure of profile about the center line (Rsk) and measure of steepness of the amplitude density curve of the roughness profile (Rku) directly from the tested area. This method offers the advantage of being error-free. All parameters were determined for each sample and the mean of each parameter was determined for each group. ANOVA and Sheffé’s test were employed to determine whether significant differences existed. The Enhance and Multi-step systems gave the best finish and polish for both materials.

Effect of Preliminary Treatment of the Dentin Surface on the Shear Bond Strength of Resin Composite to Dentin

R Pilo • HS Cardash • B Oz-Ari • A Ben-Amar

Clinical Relevance:
After acid conditioning, treating dentin surfaces with aqueous HEMA solution before applying Prime & Bond 2.1 or 2% chlorhexidine solution prior to One Step is recommended to enhance resin-dentin shear bond strength.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of two dentin disinfectants (Consepsis, Tubulicid), one aqueous HEMA solution (Aqua Prep), a combination of Aqua Prep and Tubulicid and an air abrasion treatment (50 µm aluminum oxide) on the shear bond strength (SBS) of two acetone-based single bottle adhesives (One Step and Prime & Bond 2.1). The occlusal surfaces of 167 freshly extracted human third molars were ground flat to expose the dentin, then polished with a 600 grit-polishing disc. The teeth were randomly assigned to 12 test groups (two bonding agents, six pretreatment protocols). The exposed dentin was etched with 35% phosphoric acid for 20 seconds, rinsed and briefly (1-2 seconds) air dried. Six pretreatment protocols were then applied. The air abrasion groups were exceptional, as etching was carried out only after pretreatment. One Step, or Prime & Bond 2.1 was applied according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Cylinders of Z-100 composite were bonded to the flat dentin surfaces by transparent gelatin capsules. Specimens were thermocycled in water baths between 5º and 55ºC, then sheared in an Instron Testing Machine. One-way and two-way ANOVA and Tukey HSD post-hoc tests were used for statistical analysis. In the One Step group, Consepsis yielded a significantly higher SBS (17.8 MPa) than air abrasion (9.5 MPa), Control (11.8 MPa) and Aqua Prep + Tubilicid (11.9 MPa), and a comparable SBS with Tubilicid (12.5 MPa) and Aqua Prep (14.8 MPa). In the Prime & Bond 2.1 group, Aqua Prep (24.9 MPa) showed a significantly higher SBS than all other groups: air abrasion (9.3 MPa), Control (9.97 MPa), Tubilicid (12.2 MPa), Consepsis (13.0 MPa) and Tubilicid +Aqua Prep (13.3 MPa).

Surface Roughness Assessment of Resin-Based Materials During Brushing Preceded by pH-Cycling Simulations

CP Turssi • CS de Magalhães • MC Serra • AL Rodrigues, Jr

Clinical Relevance:
Depending on the restorative material, brushing under a pH-cycling condition provided a remarkable initial increase in surface roughness which, thereafter remained unaltered or showed further increase.

SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the surface roughness pattern of resin-based restorative materials during brushing preceded by a regimen that simulated a dynamic pH-cycling. Restoratives included two resin composites (Renamel Microfill and Charisma), two polyacid-modified composite resins (Compoglass-F and Dyract AP) and one resin-modified glass ionomer cement (Fuji II LC Improved). Twenty standardized cylindrical specimens of each material were prepared according to a randomized complete block design. After finishing and polishing, the average surface roughness (Ra) and profile-length ratio (LR) of the specimens were determined. The experimental units were subjected to a pH-cycling regimen, and then to 10,000 brushing strokes. New readings of both the Ra and LR parameters were obtained. The same protocol of pH-cycling, brushing simulation and surface roughness measurements were repeated 10 times. Data was analyzed using ANOVA according to split-plot design and Tukey’s test. Results showed the pH-cycling followed by 10,000 brushing strokes provided a remarkable increase in Ra for all restorative materials except for Renamel. Throughout the brushing simulation, Renamel, Charisma, Compoglass-F and Dyract AP showed steady textures, whereas Fuji II LC Improved exhibited a progressive increase in surface roughness. Among the materials tested, Renamel presented the smoothest surface, followed by Charisma and Compoglass-F, which did not differ from each other except at the baseline. Dyract AP was different from both these materials except at the baseline. Fuji II LC Improved had the roughest surface texture.

Depth of Cure and Marginal Adaptation to Dentin of Xenon Lamp Polymerized Resin Composites

T Hasegawa • K Itoh • W Yukitani • S Wakumoto • H Hisamitsu

Clinical Relevance:
The high-powered xenon lamp unit is clinically effective in the polymerization of visible light-cured resin composites.

SUMMARY:
Marginal adaptation of four resin composites (Clearfil APX, Estelite, Silux Plus and Z-100) cured with two xenon lamp units (Plasma Arc Curing System or Apollo 95E) or a halogen lamp unit (Witelite) were evaluated by measuring the wall-to-wall contraction gap width. A cylindrical dentin cavity (ø3 mm x 1.5 mm) prepared in an extracted human molar was treated with the Megabond system or an experimental bonding system consisting of 0.5M EDTA, 35% GM and Clearfil Photo Bond prior to composite filling and was irradiated for three seconds (xenon lamp) or 40 seconds (halogen lamp). The contraction gap was measured with a light microscope. In addition, the curing capability of these three light sources was evaluated by measuring the curing depth of the composites filled in a split Teflon mold (ø4 mm x 8 mm). There was no marginal gap formation for Clearfil APX, Estelite and Silux Plus treated with the experimental bonding system regardless of the type of light sources. The curing depth of the xenon lamp was significantly higher than the halogen lamp, while marginal adaptation did not suffer any significant deterioration.

Color Stability of a Resin-Modified Glass Ionomer Cement

AUJ Yap • CPC Sim • V Loganathan

Clinical Relevance:
Color stability of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement was determined to be shade dependent. As all shades darkened with time, selection of a shade lighter than the original tooth shade is recommended during placement.

SUMMARY:
The color stability of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement (Fuji II LC) was investigated over six months using colorimetry. Five shades (A2, A3, A4, B3 and C4) were selected and 10 square specimens (7 mm wide and long, and 1.5 mm deep) were made for each shade using special grit molds. CIE L*, a*, b* color parameters of the specimens were taken at one day, one week, one month, three months and six months. Results were subjected to MANOVA and ANOVA/Scheffe’s test at significance level 0.05. The effects of time on color parameters (L*, a*, b* values) were found to be shade dependent. All shades exhibited a decrease in L* values over time. With the exception of shade B3, significant differences in L* values were observed at six months. A general decrease in b* values was also observed but differences among the various time intervals were not significant except for shades A3 and C4. No apparent trends were observed for changes in a* values. For all shades, the largest color change (DE) was observed between one day and one week. The color stability of the resin-modified glass ionomer investigated was shade dependent. A general decrease in lightness and yellow chroma was observed.

The Effect of Elapsed Time Following Bleaching on Enamel Bond Strength of Resin Composite

V Cavalli • AF Reis • M Giannini • GMB Ambrosano

Clinical Relevance:
Bond strength of resin composite to enamel can be significantly reduced after bleaching. However, the effects of carbamide peroxide on bond strength may be reversible and short-lived.

SUMMARY:
Recent studies have concluded that carbamide peroxide bleaching agents significantly affect the bond strength of composite to bleached enamel. This study evaluated the effects of bleaching regimen with different carbamide peroxide concentrations and post-treatment times on composite bond strength to enamel. Two hundred and four flat buccal and lingual enamel surfaces obtained from erupted sound third molars were randomly divided into 17 groups (n=12). Sixteen experimental groups comprised the evaluation of four carbamide peroxide home bleaching agents (Opalescence 10%—20 % and Whiteness 10%—16%) and four time intervals after bleaching (one day, one, two and three weeks). Specimens of control group were not submitted to bleaching and were stored in artificial saliva at 37º C for 10 days. The specimens of experimental groups were exposed to one daily application of carbamide peroxide for six hours for 10 consecutive days. After each daily treatment and post-bleaching, the specimens were stored in artificial saliva solution. Bonds were formed with Scothbond MP and Z-100 composite resin, and shear bond test was carried out 24 hours after adhesive-composite application. Two-way ANOVA showed that the bond strengths were significantly different (p<0.05). For the first two weeks post-bleaching, the bond strengths of resin to enamel were low. After a lapse of three weeks, the bond strength returned to that of the untreated control group. Increased concentration did not prolong the time needed prior to bonding.

Effect of Eccentric Load Cycling on Microleakage of Class V Flowable and Packable Composite Resin Restorations

KT Jang • DH Chung • D Shin • F García-Godoy

Clinical Relevance:
The stresses induced on non-carious cervical lesions may increase microleakage of Class V composite restorations regardless of the elasticity of the restorative materials used.

SUMMARY:
Class V composite restorations are subject to the stresses that induce non-carious cervical lesions. This study evaluated the effect of eccentric oblique load on microleakage of restorations. Class V cavities were randomly prepared on the buccal surfaces of 40 recently extracted premolars and restored with composite resin according to manufacturers’ directions. Teeth were randomly assigned to one of four treatment groups with 10 teeth per group: (1) flowable resin (Revolution) without load cycling; (2) packable resin (Prodigy Condensable) without load cycling; (3) flowable resin with load cycling (200,000 cycles) and (4) packable resin with load cycling (200,000 cycles). All teeth were then immersed in 2% methylene blue solution for 24 hours after thermocycling (500 cycles). Dye penetration was measured (scores 0-3). The results indicated that adding load cycling significantly increased microleakage (p<0.05). No significant differences in microleakage were observed for flowable resin vs packable resin. Gingival margins had significantly more microleakage (p<0.05) than occlusal margins.

The Effect of Long-Term Storage on Nanoleakage

HP Li • MF Burrow • MJ Tyas

Clinical Relevance:
Durability of bonds achieved with the dentin bonding systems used in this study may be affected by nanoleakage leading to hydrolytic degradation over time. Clinically nanoleakage may be important, especially for modern dentin bonding systems which can achieve gap-free margins.

SUMMARY:
To evaluate the durability of dentin bonding over time, the nanoleakage of four dentin bonding systems (Single Bond, Stae, Clearfil SE Bond and PermaQuik) over 24 hours, three months, six months and 12 months, was investigated. Flat occlusal dentin surfaces from extracted human molars were finished with wet 600-grit silicon carbide paper and bonded with one of the dentin bonding systems following manufacturers’ instructions. The bonded surface was covered with <1 mm thick layer of Silux Plus resin composite and light cured for 40 seconds. The specimens in each dentin-bonding group were randomly assigned to four sub-groups and kept in phosphate buffered saline solution (pH 7.4) containing 0.01% sodium azide at 37°C for 24 hours, three, six or 12 months. The margins of all specimens were finished and polished with Sof-Lex disks after initial 24-hour storage. At the end of each storage time, the surrounding tooth surfaces except for 1 mm adjacent to the restoration were coated with nail varnish. The samples were immersed in a 50% w/v solution of silver nitrate for 24 hours, placed in photodeveloping solution and exposed to fluorescent light for eight hours. The samples were cut longitudinally and bucco-lingually, polished, mounted on stubs, carbon coated and observed in a Field Emission-SEM using backscattered electron mode.

The results showed that systems using phosphoric acid as the etchant had a line of silver deposition at the base of the hybrid layer. Silver deposition increased in all systems over 12-months storage, with PermaQuik changing the least. Nanoleakage of the dentin bonding systems increased slightly during the 12-month storage period, indicating that they may be subject to hydrolytic attack over time.

Porosity in Manually and Machine Mixed Resin-Modified Glass Ionomer Cements

DA Covey • NO Ewoldsen

Clinical Relevance:
Hand-mixed resin-modified glass ionomer cement has greater porosity and weaker shear force resistance than machine mixed cement.

SUMMARY:
The powder and liquid components of resin-modified glass ionomer cements are available in manual and machine mixed forms. This study quantified the effect mixing methods have on the porosity and shear strength of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement (RMGIC).

A RMGIC (Fuji II LC) was manually or machined mixed according to manufacturer’s instructions. Thin, disc-shaped specimens (n=5) were made by compressing the cement between glass platens to a thickness of approximately 76 µm. The specimens were light cured for 120 seconds. Digital images of the specimens were recorded using a measuring microscope and slide film scanner. Digital imaging software was used to determine the number and volume of the cement’s pores. Shear test specimens of manual and machine mixed cements (n=10) of each group (~800 µm thickness) were made as previously described. Shear punch tests were conducted using a 3.75 mm diameter punch mounted on a universal testing machine.

The mean number and total volume of pores in the manually mixed specimens was considerably greater than that of the machine mixed group (p<0.05). The shear punch test results of the machine mixed group was significantly higher than the manual mixed group, (p<0.05).



Volume 26, Supplement 6

Management Alternatives for the Carious Lesion

Introduction

Carious Lesions: Management Alternatives

W Dan Sneed

Introduction:
During an editorial board meeting of the Journal of Operative Dentistry in 1997, Dr Richard McCoy, then editor, mentioned that there was some interest in an international symposium on alternatives to dental amalgam. No one at the meeting volunteered for the job. Upon returning home from Chicago, I called Richard and said that the Medical University of South Carolina would be interested in organizing and hosting such a symposium. From that phone call, an executive organizing committee was formed. It consisted of Dr Fred Eichmiller, Dr Ivan Stangel, Dr Richard McCoy and myself. We decided to ask some of the most influential and respected people to serve on a larger planning committee.


Theme 1

Current Concepts of Dental Caries and Its Prevention

MH Anderson

SUMMARY:
Diseases in general can be modeled using a non-exclusive contributory model. This model suggests that all diseases may be viewed within its context and that one or a combination of two or three of the elements may interact in any specific disease. For instance, autoimmune diseases such as juvenile onset diabetes require the single constituent known as “genetic.” A disease such as West Nile fever has all three of the component parts required to become active. It takes a susceptible person (genetic), an infectious agent (the virus) and environmental factors to breed the Culex pipiens mosquitoes that acquire and transmit the infectious agent.

Caries Risk Assessment

KJ Anusavice

SUMMARY:
Risk assessment of individual patients is necessary to select optimal therapeutic regimens for the prevention, diagnosis and management of caries as an infectious disease. Because of a marked decline in caries prevalence over the past three decades, the proportion of patients at high risk for caries has declined. We estimate that 25% of adolescents suffer from 75% of the disease consequences. Thus, it is important that this population be targeted with specific therapies to reduce the risk for the disease and to enhance the probability for remineralization of early lesions. Although fluoride is available in many forms, including drinking water, fluoride rinses, gels, varnishes and components of restorative materials, these products are not totally successful in arresting the disease in certain patients. Treatment of extremely high-risk patients may also require an antibacterial agent in combination with fluoride. However, the precise schedule for treatment depends on the initial risk of each patient and his or her compliance with prescribed treatments and home care.

Why should caries risk be assessed? There are two major reasons for assessing caries risk in the current era of reduced caries prevalence: (1) to direct individually-based preventive measures to the highest risk persons who benefit most from prevention and (2) to identify low-risk patients in order to delay restorations and prevent unnecessary surgical intervention. There is a strong likelihood that private practice strategies for caries prevention are based in great measure on concepts learned in dental school during a time of high caries prevalence. Thus, most patients with carious lesions are treated in a similar way, that is, by restoring most teeth with lesions, whether or not the tooth surfaces are cavitated, and recalling all patients at six-month intervals, whether they are at high, moderate or low risk.

By targeting high-risk patients with chemotherapeutic treatment (fluoride and chlorhexidine), plaque control and diet management, several benefits may be realized. This minimally invasive treatment will increase the resistance of teeth to caries attack, delay or prevent surgical intervention, avoid the placement of fillings that will fail by secondary caries, reduce discomfort and trauma and reduce long-term treatment costs.

Enhancing Remineralization

LC Chow • GL Vogel

SUMMARY:
Reports of remineralization of enamel and dentin in vivo can be found in early literature in the form of clinical observations of naturally occurring arrestment of carious lesions. One of the first systematic clinical studies on caries reversal was reported in 1966 (Backer-Dirks, 1966) in which about half of the 72 white spot lesions observed in the buccal surfaces of first molars in children at age eight were found to have remineralized at age 15. In vitro studies on “rehardening” of softened enamel were reported as early as 1912 (Head, 1912) and for dentin in 1944 (Souder & Schoonover, 1944). In the 1960s, in vitro studies have shown that artificially formed lesions in enamel can be partially remineralized as evidenced by increasing hardness (Koulourides, Cueto & Pigman, 1961) or mineral content (von der Fehr, 1965). In the last two decades, a number of improved clinical diagnostic tools for detecting enamel and dentin lesions in vivo and reliable methods for quantitative measurements of lesion mineral contents in vitro were developed. This facilitated studies that have led to a significantly greater understanding of both the demineralization and remineralization processes. There is little doubt that significant remineralization of enamel and dentin lesions can occur under both in vitro and in vivo conditions, and consequently, remineralization is increasingly accepted as a viable non-invasive approach for restoring carious teeth, at least during the earlier stages of the caries process. Because several recent articles (Kashket, 1999; Zero, 1999; Featherstone, 2000) provided comprehensive reviews of research in remineralization and caries prevention, this paper focuses primarily on thermodynamic and mechanistic analyses of this process. However, because remineralization and demineralization processes are intricately linked, it is important to comprehend the different mechanisms that drive the two processes. For this reason, mechanisms of both demineralization and remineralization are discussed.

Replacement Therapy of Dental Caries

JD Hillman

SUMMARY:
There are many examples of positive and negative interactions between different species of bacteria inhabiting the same ecosystem. This observation provides the basis for a novel approach to preventing microbial diseases called replacement therapy. In this approach, a harmless effector strain is permanently implanted in the host’s microflora. Once established, the presence of the effector strain prevents the colonization or outgrowth of a particular pathogen. In the case of dental caries, replacement therapy has involved construction of an effector strain called BCS3-L1, which was derived from a clinical Streptococcus mutans isolate. Recombinant DNA technology was used to delete the gene encoding lactate dehydrogenase in BCS3-L1, making it entirely deficient in lactic acid production. This effector strain was also designed to produce elevated amounts of a novel peptide antibiotic called mutacin 1140, which gives it a strong selective advantage over most other strains of S mutans. In laboratory and rodent model studies, BCS3-L1 was genetically stable and produced no apparent deleterious side effects during prolonged colonization. BCS3-L1 was significantly less cariogenic than wild-type S mutans in gnotobiotic rats, and it did not contribute whatsoever to the cariogenic potential of the indigenous flora of conventional Sprague-Dawley rats. Also, its strong colonization properties indicated that a single application of the BCS3-L1 effector strain to human subjects should result in its permanent implantation and displacement over time of indigenous, disease-causing S mutans strains. Thus, BCS3-L1 replacement therapy for the prevention of dental caries is an example of biofilm engineering that offers the potential for a highly efficient, cost effective augmentation of conventional prevention strategies. It is hoped that the eventual success of replacement therapy for the prevention of dental caries will stimulate using this approach in preventing other bacterial diseases.

Potential for Vaccines in the Prevention of Caries Lesions

MW Russell

SUMMARY:
A large body of experimental work over several decades has demonstrated the feasibility of inducing protective immunity against oral colonization by mutans streptococci and the subsequent development of dental caries in animal models. Current approaches focus on two principal protein antigens, the adhesin AgI/II and glucosyltransferase and the generation of salivary secretory IgA antibodies by novel strategies for the delivery of immunogens to effectively stimulate the common mucosal immune system. Alternative approaches include the development of antibodies suitable for passive application. Further advances to make immunization against caries practicable will depend upon clinical trials aimed at establishing whether appropriate immune responses can be safely generated in humans, particularly in the susceptible age groups, and whether such responses will afford desirable levels of protection.

Biomaterials, Biomimetics and Tissue Engineering Programs at the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research/National Institutes of Health

E Kousvelari

SUMMARY:
The National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research (NIDCR) belongs to the family of institutes that constitute the National Institutes of Health (NIH). The NIH is one of the world’s leading biomedical research facilities. Its mission is to discover new knowledge that will lead to bettering the health of people everywhere. Founded in 1887, the NIH today consists of 25 institutes and centers. About 83% of the NIH budget supports biomedical research in more than 2500 public and private institutions throughout the US and worldwide. About 11% of the NIH budget is for intramural research conducted on the NIH campus.

Dental and craniofacial diseases and disorders are among the most common health problems affecting people around the world. These conditions range from birth defects such as cleft palate and lip, injuries to the head and face, dental caries and periodontal disease, temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disease and head and neck cancers. The NIDCR was established in 1948 to support basic and clinical research and research training on diseases and disorders affecting the oral, craniofacial and dental tissues and organs.

To accomplish its mission, the Institute has two Divisions: the Division of Intramural Research (DIR) and the Division of Extramural Research (DER).

The DIR includes the Office of the Scientific Director and seven research branches:

A majority of NIDR resources are spent for research grants and contracts to institutions outside the NIDR. These monies are distributed through a competitive process that involves two levels of peer review for scientific merit and relevance to the Institute's mission. The different branches and offices of the DER administer the grants. The DER includes the Office of the Division Director, five scientific branches and two offices.

Assessment of Factors Affecting Current Approaches to Dental Education

MA Latta

SUMMARY:
Curricular content in dental education should be evidence based. Unfortunately, there is general agreement that innovative curricula that introduce non-traditional approaches to clinical problems are difficult to inculcate into dental schools. The burden of blame is often placed at the feet of rank-and-file dental faculty, when in fact the factors influencing curricula are complex and multi-factorial. The history of dental education has documented from the 1926 Gies report to the 1995 Institute of Medicine summary a series of consistent and persistent issues which merit attention. While some burden for change must be born by current dental educators, many of the challenges facing dental educators are complicated by factors outside the school environment. This paper documents some of the factors affecting education and the barriers in addressing these factors, with eight specific recommendations to be considered by dentists, educators, researchers and dental organizations in an effort to improve the climate for incorporating new concepts in patient care in dental curricula.

New Approaches for the Underserved

CR Hook

SUMMARY:
Traditionally, the dental profession has been committed to providing oral health care for “all people.” No other health profession has worked more diligently to eradicate the health problems associated with its discipline. In recent years, dentistry has placed emphasis on target groups, including the medically compromised, the geriatric and those suffering from infectious diseases such as AIDS and hepatitis. Dental education has traditionally focused on providing a high quality educational environment for dental students in a school setting where students spend approximately four years learning philosophical and factual information and developing technical skills to become a competent practitioner. Little emphasis, however, has been placed on access to dental care for the underserved. The goals of this paper are to stimulate thought concerning the role that research and education can play to combat dental caries among those who cannot afford to pay and to reawaken the profession’s responsibility for this enormous task.


Theme 2

Performance Standards for Competitive Dental Materials

JA Platt

SUMMARY:
As we move through time, we are continually faced with the opportunity to change. This is as true for our restorative material selection as it is for anything else. In order to know whether or not we should change, we must have an understanding of where we are currently. If the change will not provide improvement, is it wise to pursue?

How we determine improvement depends on our paradigm, our view of the objectives of restorative dentistry. Traditionally, dentists have believed that slowing down the restorative cycle as much as possible is the ideal pursuit of restorative dentistry. We live in a time that challenges that paradigm. The challenge comes through a push for esthetics and the increased predictability of implant dentistry. Lectures are being given which teach that our concern for the disease process should be secondary to improving the self-esteem of our patients by maximizing the esthetic result as rapidly as possible, even if it means re-restoration within a short period of time. Much of that thought is driven by the idea that implant dentistry is always available and is as comfortable, functional and esthetic as a natural dentition.

This paper provides some insight into where we are in terms of restorative dental materials standards. The hope is that we will be better able to pursue changes that will move us in a positive direction. It is written with the belief that in some way the new must resolve to be an improvement over the traditional before we can justify the change. The preservation of tooth structure is an important characteristic of restorative dentistry until proven otherwise.

Mercury, Its Impact on the Environment and Its Biocompatibility

JW Osborne

SUMMARY:
The metal mercury is widely used in our society. Some of its unusual properties include that it is a liquid at room temperature, has a high specific gravity, acts as a catalyst in certain reactions and is toxic in multiple forms to living organisms.

Dentists should be aware of the broad parameters of mercury’s toxic properties, and specifically its hygiene and vapor hazard in the dental office. Dentists should examine the forthcoming technology for reducing mercury discharge from their offices. They should also understand the complex aspects of medical/psychological profiles of patients with “amalgam illness” and the needs of such patients for proper treatment.

Gold as a Historic Standard and its Role for the Future

CT Smith

SUMMARY:
Since antiquity and the dawn of civilization, man has used gold as a dental material. It has always had a very special intrinsic and practical value in dentistry and will continue to do so. Of all the dental restorative materials in use, gold to this day has had the best combination of physical properties that make it a premier restorative material for today as well as tomorrow. In addition, clinical research and experience has shown no other material demonstrates the superb long-term prognosis as properly placed gold restorations. Many of our patients have gold restorations, which have served them for decades, and these patients are walking archives of dental history. Gold restorations have withstood the test of time and to this day are the benchmark by which we judge many other dental restorative materials.

Research into Non-Mercury Containing Metallic Alternatives

FC Eichmiller

SUMMARY:
Many attempts have been made over the years with varying degrees of success to developing metallic alternatives to dental amalgam. Much of the difficulty in achieving success is the inability to meet the physical, mechanical and clinical criteria for an “ideal” alternative. An additional requirement for any new material is that it be “environmentally friendly”—both from a manufacturing standpoint and in use. Gold foil has been one of dentistry’s most successful direct filling materials, but is only used by few/select clinicians and is largely considered a lost art. Metal-modified glass ionomers have achieved some success as crown buildup materials and direct restoratives in the primary teeth of children, but these are slowly being displaced by improved composites. Several attempts have been made to develop metal-filled composites, but only one product is available for use as a crown buildup material. There is a long history of attempts to formulate an acceptable gallium alloy. Early nickel-gallium formulations resulted in severe tumorgenicity in animal trials. Palladium-gallium-tin alloys were less toxic but still exhibited high latent expansion and severe soft tissue inflammation around implants and tissue-embedded particles. More recent attempts to formulate silver-copper-gallium-indium-tin alloys resulted in better biocompatibility, but clinical trials showed corrosion and latent expansion too severe for general clinical acceptability. Studies of consolidated silver materials have resulted in the development of a direct restorative system with favorable properties and biocompatibility, but no human trials have yet evaluated the material’s clinical performance. The demands in today’s market for esthetics and regulatory pressures to reduce heavy metals in wastewater have resulted in less interest in metallic alternatives for amalgam. Future development will likely focus on improving polymeric composites in an attempt to meet the call for an amalgam alternative.


Theme 3

Adhesives and Cements to Promote Preservation Dentistry

B Van Meerbeek • M Vargas • S Inoue • Y Yoshida • M Peumans • P Lambrechts • G Vanherle

SUMMARY:
During the last three decades clinicians have been confronted with a continuous and fairly rapid turnover in adhesive materials. It started in the mid-’60s with the advent of the first commercialized restorative resin composites, followed in the early ’70s with the introduction of the acid-etch technique in clinical practice. Since then, there has been ongoing progress in developing more refined and diversified restorative composites along with the production of steadily improved bonding agents. Effective adhesion to enamel has been achieved with relative ease and has repeatedly proven to be a durable and reliable clinical procedure for routine applications in modern adhesive restorative dentistry. Although adhesion to dentin is not as reliable as adhesion to enamel, today’s adhesives produce superior results in laboratories (Perdigão & Lopes, 1999; Inoue & others, 2000a,b; Tanumiharja, Burrow & Tyas, 2000), along with improved clinical effectiveness (Van Meerbeek & others, 1994b, 1996, 1998a; Brunton & others, 1999; Folwaczny & others, 2000; Tyas, 2000; Van Dijken, 2000), thereby, approaching enamel-bonding performance.

Early one-step dentin bonding agents became multi-step systems with more complicated, time-consuming and technique-sensitive application procedures. In the early ’90s, the selective enamel-etching technique was replaced by a total-etch concept. Since then, universal enamel-dentin conditioners have been simultaneously applied to enamel and dentin. Now that today’s total-etch adhesives have reached a clinically acceptable bonding effectiveness, most recent research and development efforts have focused on simplifying the multi-step bonding process and reducing its sensitivity to errors of inaccurate or incorrect clinical handling (Sano & others, 1998; Finger & Balkenhol, 1999; Inoue & others, 2000b).

In addition to interposition of a resin-based adhesive system between the restorative material and the remaining tooth structure, bonding to tooth tissue can also be clinically achieved directly using glass ionomer cements (Davidson & Mjör, 1999). Glass ionomer-based materials have an auto-adhesive capacity thanks to their specific chemical formula and structural nature (Wilson, Prosser & Powis, 1983; Van Meerbeek & others, 1998b; Yoshida & others, 2000). Parallel with the progress made in resin-based adhesives, glass ionomer technology has undergone many improvements and modifications of its original chemistry since being developed in the early ’70s by Wilson & Kent (1971). A thorough discussion of self-adhering glass ionomer materials is beyond the scope of this paper. Nevertheless, some reference will be made to one of the latest trends in adhesive material development that converges both glass ionomer and composite technology into new adhesive systems and restorative materials with mixed characteristics.

This paper critically reflects on the current status of adhesives. An overview is provided with today’s commercial adhesives classified according to their adhesive approach towards enamel and dentin. Some critical steps in the rather technique-sensitive bonding procedure are discussed in detail. Finally, bonding effectiveness of a selected group of adhesives is presented in terms of micro-tensile bond strength to enamel and dentin and by clinical retention rates in Class V non-carious cervical lesions.

Recent Commercial Composite Formulations

MM Suzuki

SUMMARY:
Vastly improved bonding systems and the enhanced formulation of resin composites has resulted in their increased durability and reliability in a wide spectrum of restorative procedures.

The recent introduction of packable resin composites as posterior restorations has brought about easier handling characteristics; however, difficulties still exist in terms of providing positive proximal contact. Clinical performance of packable composite at the two-year recall revealed no significant difference from that of its predecessor.

Through clinical trials, several suggestions were made for the successful placement of resin composites in the posterior dentition.

Indirect Resin and Ceramic Systems

A Peutzfeldt

SUMMARY:
The esthetic component of dental care has become increasingly more important, while new tooth-colored materials are continually marketed. This article describes currently available indirect resin composites and all-ceramic systems. Mechanical properties of the materials and bonding of the restorations to tooth structure are discussed. A review of the clinical success of the different types of restorations is given, and finally, comparisons of the clinical success are made between new and clinically well known types of restorations.

Various Forms of Glass Ionomers and Compomers

RA Hickel • M Folwaczny

SUMMARY:
In recent years conventional glass ionomers, resin-modified glass ionomers and polyacid-modified resin composites have attained increasing attention in clinical practice. Concerning the restoration of posterior teeth, these materials broadened the therapeutic armamentarium. Tooth-colored direct restorative materials have been advocated with the hope that these materials can substitute for amalgam as the material of choice for posterior restorations. The physical properties of these materials have been reported in numerous studies but little is known about their clinical long-term performance to date. A literature review regarding the longevity of these particular kinds of tooth-colored restorative materials in different clinical indications follows.


Theme 4

Adhesive Restorations in Posterior Teeth: Rationale for the Application of Direct Techniques

D Dietschi • I Krejci

SUMMARY:
Material properties as well as the clinician’s ability to control the development of detrimental polymerization shrinkage stresses govern the behavior and quality of direct composite restorations in posterior teeth. In addition to the use of a strong adhesive, many other compensatory factors can help to achieve a good adaptation. Among the most important ones may be the application of a thick bonding resin layer or the application of a “soft” base-liner, the use of multilayer techniques and the application of the “selective” bonding concept. Understanding the principles of composite polymerization and stress development in the tooth-restoration complex is a prerequisite for achieving optimal results.

New Polymer Resins for Dental Restoratives

JL Ferracane

SUMMARY:
Polymers are used in dentistry for many applications, including provisional restoratives, sealants, adhesives, impressions, dentures, dies and more. In recent years, the greatest emphasis in research has been on their use as restoratives. Resin-based composite restoratives are currently considered adequate for minimal stress-bearing clinical applications. However, enhancements in wear-resistance, biocompatibility and marginal sealing are still needed for posterior composites (ADA, 1998). Further research is encouraged to develop alternative matrix resins and polymerization initiators to produce materials with less polymerization shrinkage, less wear and fracture in sites of heavy occlusion, improved adhesion and easier placement techniques.

Numerous resin systems for dental applications have been synthesized, though few have been commercialized. Recent literature contains several reviews of the composition and properties of current dental resin-based restoratives (Bayne, Heymann & Swift, 1994; Ferracane, 1995; Leinfelder, 1997; Peutzfeldt, 1997a). This paper focuses on the ongoing work in new polymers and studies presented in the past three to four years, dividing them into the following topic areas: reduced polymerization shrinkage and shrinkage stress, enhanced degree of conversion and mechanical properties, fiber reinforcement, reduced hydrophilicity, anti-cariogenic activity, remineralizing activity and surface coatings.

Future Ceramic Systems

J-F Roulet • R Janda

SUMMARY:
Ceramics are everywhere in life; there is no way to think about a life without them. We eat from ceramic plates (feldspathic porcelain), cut with ceramic knifes (zirconium dioxide) and in the bathroom, we encounter lots of ceramics (feldspathic porcelain). Some of our watches have ceramic shells (zirconium dioxide), the chips in our computers are ceramic based, our cars have ceramic parts (aluminum oxide, zirconium dioxide), the milling of steel and other metals is done with ceramic tools, high-tension power lines use ceramics as insulators and nuclear power plants are unthinkable without ceramics serving as fuel structure elements or absorbents. Finally, there are some very special, but from a technological development standpoint, quite old-fashioned ceramics used for dentistry. Covering the whole ceramic world is far beyond the scope of this article; therefore, it will be restricted to dental ceramics. Yes, ceramics are somewhat outdated, but nevertheless, they are very interesting because in dentistry there is one major restriction: dental ceramics must be “white” and translucent, the same as teeth. This eliminates a number of high-performance ceramics, the so-called non-oxidic ceramics such as graphite, silicon carbide, silicon nitride, boron carbide or boron nitride (Salmang & Scholze, 1983).

Biocompatibility of Restorative Materials

A Hensten-Pettersen • N Jacobsen

SUMMARY:
Biocompatibility issues are a major concern in the selection of future restorative materials.

Risk analyses concerning possible adverse biological reactions of new materials start with literature surveys of biological reactions to materials of similar composition. Lack of relevant data may necessitate additional biocompatibility testing, which is often performed according to the methods referred to in ISO 7405 (1997) Dentistry—Preclinical evaluation of biocompatibility of medical devices used in dentistry—Test methods for dental materials. However, traditional, established preclinical tests are mainly suitable for evaluating local irritant effects to the tissues of the skin, oral mucosa and dental pulp tissues, and immune-mediated, delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions. Other clinical reactions, as reviewed below, may not be predictable by animal test methods. One reason is that the statistical power of predictive animal tests is not sufficient to cover events where the incidence is assumed to be low.

Risk management of residual risks not taken into account in the design of the materials is usually covered by detailed instructions for the intended use and handling. Precautionary statements about contraindications in patients and safe-handling procedures have become more common, as experience has shown that most materials may have some risks associated with their use. The Norwegian and Swedish Adverse Reaction Units for Dental Biomaterials have post-market surveillance systems for collating information about adverse reactions in patients and in the dental health team (Gjerdet & Askevold, 1998).

Adverse clinical reactions caused by new chemicals and the types of reaction elicited are usually first identified where the exposure is the highest, that is, in an occupational setting. The causes of occupation-related and patient reactions in dentistry are related to the dental materials and clinical applications used at any given time, and in the specific usage of the various specialties (Hensten-Pettersen & Jacobsen, 1990; 1991; Kallus & Mjör, 1991; Kanerva, Estlander & Jolanki, 1995, Kanerva & others, 2000; Moore, Burke & Felix, 2000; Wallenhammar & others, 2000).



(C) Operative Dentistry, 2001