Number 1
Number 2
Number 3
Number 4
Number 5
Number 6
Index to Volume 30
“I have all my teeth, my friends don’t have theirs.”
Clinical Research
A Screening Test for Unstimulated Salivary Flow Measurement
Clinical Relevance:
Hyposalivation is the systemic condition that has one of the greatest influences on restorative treatment prognosis and outcomes. This article provides preliminary data to validate an easy method for assessment of hyposalivation in clinical practice.
SUMMARY:
It is well established that saliva is an important factor for the health of both soft and hard tissues in the oral cavity. This study determined: 1) the correlation between unstimulated salivary flow assessed using the Modified Schirmer tear strip Test (MST), with gravimetric and volumetric measurements and 2) the MST value that would allow the most reliable identification of patients with severe (<0.1 ml/minute) and moderate (<0.2 ml/minute) hyposalivation. A retrospective clinical study was conducted using data from 90 patients seen at the Indiana University School of Dentistry. All patients had a sample of unstimulated whole saliva collected by drooling for five minutes for volumetric/gravimetric assessment, followed by placement of the Schirmer strip in the floor of the mouth for three minutes (MST). Results showed a non-linear association between the MST and volumetric/gravimetric methods, with moderate Spearman correlation coefficients (0.67-0.71). Analysis of ROC-curves suggests that a cutoff screening value of 25 mm/three minutes provides high sensitivity (77%) and positive predictive value (71%) without significantly affecting specificity (80%). In conclusion, this study supports use of the MST test as a screening tool for hyposalivation.
Clinical Relevance:
Within the limits of this study, restorations with fiber posts and composite were found to be more effective than amalgam in preventing root fractures but less effective in preventing secondary caries; the overall failure rate was not significantly different for the two kinds of restorations.
SUMMARY:
Prospective clinical studies comparing the results of different types of restorations of endodontically treated teeth are lacking. This study compared the clinical success rate of endodontically treated premolars restored with fiber posts and direct composite to the restorations of premolars using amalgam.
Premolars with Class II carious lesions were selected and randomly assigned to one of two experimental groups: (1) restoration with amalgam or (2) restoration with fiber posts and composite. One hundred and nine teeth were included in Group 1 and 110 in Group 2.
Patients were recalled after 1, 3 and 5 years.
No statistically significant difference was found between the proportion of failed teeth in the two experimental groups. Significant differences were observed between the proportion of root fractures (p=0.029) and caries (p=0.047), with more root fractures and less caries observed in the teeth restored with amalgam at the five-year recall. Within the limits of this study, it can be concluded that restorations with fiber posts and composite were found to be more effective than amalgam in preventing root fractures but less effective in preventing secondary caries.
The Performance of Air-turbine Handpieces in General Dental Practice
Clinical Relevance:
The long-term monitoring of air-turbine handpieces in service can reveal progressive changes in behavior which may be used as measures of deterioration. It is also demonstrated that adherence to a proper lubrication protocol can lead to bearing longevity several times that commonly experienced. Such investigations will permit clinicians to make informed decisions about the acquisition and maintenance of an essential item of equipment for clinical dentistry.
SUMMARY:
Objective: To investigate variation in performance measures of fibre-optic, high-speed air-turbine handpieces during the course of daily use in general dental practice.
Materials and Methods: Four groups of five new high-speed fibre-optic handpieces were used in the routine treatment of patients over a period of 30 months by four general dental practitioners in two dental practices: Groups A, B: Super-Torque Lux 3 650B (KaVo, Biberach, Germany); Group C: BORA 898LE (BienAir SA, Bienne, Switzerland) and Group D: Toplight (W&H Dentalwerk, Burmoos, Austria). The dental practice teams had been rehearsed in the procedures to be followed before starting the study. Each dentist used the handpieces in strict rotation, while the groups were rotated monthly between practitioners. Four performance characteristics were measured before use, then at regular intervals: free-running speed (Hz) and bearing resistance (µNm) were measured using a purpose-built testing machine (Darvell-Dyson); illuminance (lux) and sound pressure level (dB(A)) were also measured. Handpieces were cleaned and lubricated in accordance with manufacturers’ directions; all were autoclaved wet at 134°C for three minutes.
Results: Free-running speed showed an initial increase after use for Groups A, B and C, which may be associated with a decrease in bearing resistance. All handpieces in Group C suffered bearing failure between months 21 and 23, preceded by a substantial increase in noise, while those in Group D suffered failure of the fibre-optic system between months 18 and 24. Other deterioration due to use was identified but Groups A, B and D were still in use at month 30.
Conclusions: Variation in free-running speed, bearing resistance, illuminance and sound pressure level can be used effectively to monitor changes in air-turbine handpieces due to normal use. Although an increase in bearing resistance is associated with decreasing free-running speed, noise appears to be a useful indicator of imminent bearing failure. Assiduous adherence to manufacturers’ directions for cleaning and lubrication may have contributed to increased bearing life.
Laboratory Research
SUMMARY:
The measurement of performance characteristics of dental air turbine handpieces is of interest with respect to product comparisons, standards specifications and monitoring of bearing longevity in clinical service. Previously, however, bulky and expensive laboratory equipment was required. A portable test machine is described for determining three key characteristics of dental air-turbine handpieces: free-running speed, stall torque and bearing resistance. It relies on a special circuit design for performing a hardware integration of a force signal with respect to rotational position, independent of the rate at which the turbine is allowed to turn during both stall torque and bearing resistance measurements. Free-running speed without the introduction of any imbalance can be readily monitored. From the essential linear relationship between torque and speed, dynamic torque and, hence, power, can then be calculated. In order for these measurements to be performed routinely with the necessary precision of location on the test stage, a detailed procedure for ensuring proper gripping of the handpiece is described. The machine may be used to verify performance claims, standard compliance checks should this be established as appropriate, monitor deterioration with time and usage in the clinical environment and for laboratory investigation of design development.
Clinical Relevance:
Microleakage scores in this in vitro study suggest that gingival margins of resin com-posite restorations showed significantly less leakage in enamel than dentin, conventional and packable resin composites do not perform differently and flowable linings not only showed significant leakage for both conventional and packable resin composites, but leaked significantly more than either restorative material, alone.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated gingival wall microleakage in packable and microhybrid conventional composite restorations with and without a flowable composite liner. Each group was evaluated with gingival margins situated in both enamel and cementum/dentin.
Two hundred and forty Class II cavities were prepared in extracted third molars, half with gingival margins in enamel and half with margins in dentin/cementum. In groups of 30, restoration was undertaken with packable alone (3M Filtek P60), conventional alone (3M Z250), packable plus flowable liner (3M Filtek Flow) and conventional plus flowable liner. All used 37% phosphoric acid etch and Scotchbond 1 (3M) as the bonding system. After restoration, the teeth were thermocycled (between 5°C, 37°C and 60°C) 1,500 times, soaked in 0.1% methylene blue, sectioned and microleakage from the gingival margin scored. Statistical analysis was performed using Kruskal Wallis and Mann-Whitney U tests.
There was no significant difference between systems in terms of leakage scores when gingival margins were situated in enamel (p=0.70). All restorations with margins in cementum/dentin leaked significantly more than those with margins in enamel (p<0.001). There was no significant difference between leakage scores of 3M Z250 and Filtek P60 with cementum/dentin gingival margins (p=0.68). Use of a flowable composite liner (3M Filtek Flow) against cementum/dentin was associated with increased microleakage (p<0.001).
In this study, leakage scores suggest that gingival margins should be placed in enamel. The conventional and packable resin composites tested were not associated with differences in microleakage. Leakage data do not support the use of flowable resin composite linings in Class II resin composite restorations.
One-day Bonding Effectiveness of New Self-etch Adhesives to Bur-cut Enamel and Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
A trend exists toward simplified adhesive application procedures for bonding of resin composites. However, the most “advanced” one-step adhesives seem significantly less effective; whereas, some two-step self-etch adhesives approach the bonding performance of three-step etch-and-rinse adhesives.
SUMMARY:
Self-etch adhesives try to solve difficulties commonly associated with the clinical application of etch-and-rinse adhesives. Their application procedure is considered less time-consuming and, more importantly, less technique-sensitive. The main objective of this study was to determine the bonding effectiveness to and the interaction with enamel/dentin of three contemporary one- and two-step self-etch adhesives by microtensile bond strength testing (µTBS), Fe-SEM and TEM when compared to a control two-step self-etch and a three-step etch-and-rinse adhesive. The one-step self-etch adhesive, Adper Prompt (3M ESPE), scored the lowest µTBS of all experimental and control adhesives tested. Conversely, the two-step self-etch adhesives Clearfil SE (Kuraray) and OptiBond Solo Plus Self-Etch (Kerr) approached the values obtained by the three-step etch-and-rinse control (OptiBond FL, Kerr) when bonded to enamel and dentin. Ultra-morphological characterization showed that interfacial morphology and the pH of the self-etch primer/adhesive are strongly associated. The interaction with dentin varied from the formation of a submicron, hydroxyapatite-containing hybrid layer for the “mild” self-etch adhesive Clearfil SE to a 3-5 µm thick, hydroxyapatite-depleted hybrid layer for the “strong” self-etch adhesive Adper Prompt. The two-step self-etch adhesives AdheSE and OptiBond Solo Plus Self-Etch presented with a hybrid layer with a hydroxyapatite-depleted top part and a hydroxyapatite-containing base part and were therefore classified into a new group of self-etch adhesives, namely “intermediary strong” self-etch adhesives.
Clinical Relevance:
The effect of light curing prior to resin cementation on microtensile bond strength was dependent on the specific dentinal adhesive. Light curing the adhesive prior to resin cementation increased film thickness for all the dentin adhesives tested but this effect may be tolerable if a careful technique is utilized. Any benefits of pre-curing the adhesive to the microtensile bond strength must be weighed against the risk of incomplete restoration seating.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the influence of dentin adhesive application technique (pre-curing vs non pre-curing) on microtensile bond strength (µTBS) to dentin and adhesive layer thickness in indirect resin restorations. Seven proprietary dentin adhesives were tested, including one-step and multi-step products. Experimental groups included adhesive pre-cure (PC) with a halogen light source and no pre-cure (NPC) prior to resin cement insertion.
Thirty caries-free molars received an MO inlay preparation. Inlays made with Tetric Ceram resin composite were cemented using a dual-cured resin luting agent. Prior to inlay cementation, each tooth was treated with one dentin bonding agent, using pre-cure (PC) or no pre-cure (NPC). After storage in distilled water at 37°C for 24 hours, the teeth were sectioned along their long axis to produce serial sticks for microtensile bond strength testing at 0.5 mm/minute. The results were subjected to statistical analysis by one-way and two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Tukey’s multiple comparison test (p ≤ 0.05). For the film thickness evaluation, 10 additional teeth were restored and sectioned mesiodistally. The thickness of the adhesive layer was evaluated by SEM at 1000x magnification at the pre-selected locations.
The µTBS varied from 11.7 ± 4.5 MPa to 43.4 ± 9.8 MPa. The effect of pre-curing the adhesive was material specific. No adhesive layer was visualized for the adhesives used without the pre-curing step. The thickness of the adhesive layer for the pre-cured groups varied according to the different areas analyzed.
Approximal Carious Lesion Depth Assessment with Insight and Ultraspeed Films
Clinical Relevance:
The new film, Insight, performed equally well as Ultraspeed at approximal carious lesions depth assessment.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the efficiency of a new E/F-speed film, Insight, at the determination of approximal carious lesion depths compared with Ultraspeed. Radiographs of 80 extracted human molars and premolars were taken with both films under standardized conditions. The presence or absence of caries and depth of lesions was determined by three observers using a predetermined scale. The actual status of each surface was determined histologically. Observer responses were assessed with the Gamma measure of association test. Differences between the observers’ agreement levels were not significant.
The efficiency of Insight and Ultraspeed at true depth diagnosis was found to be 54.9%; 55.8% and Gamma values were found to be 0.883 and 0.922, respectively, at p<0.001. The difference between the two films was not statistically significant (p=0.852). This study suggested that there was no statistically significant difference between the two films at detecting the depths of approximal carious lesions.
Dentin Bond Strength of Self-etching Primers/Adhesives
Clinical Relevance:
Not all the self-etching systems tested were capable of producing predictable bond strengths to that achieved by the total-etch system. SBS to dentin with self-etching systems may depend on the specific composition of those systems.
SUMMARY:
This study compared the shear bond strengths (SBS) to dentin achieved with six self-etching systems and one total-etch one-bottle adhesive system. Seventy freshly extracted bovine incisors were mounted in acrylic molds and the facial surfaces ground to expose middle dentin, which was polished by 600-grit sand paper. The incisors were randomly assigned to groups (n=10): Adper Prompt Self-Etch Adhesive, 3M-ESPE (ADP) and One-Up Bond F, Tokuyama (OU) as self-etching adhesives; AdheSE, Ivoclar-Vivadent (ADH), Clearfil SE Bond, Kuraray (SE), Optibond Solo Plus–Self-Etch, Kerr (OP) as self-etching primers, Tyrian SPE, BISCO (TY) as a self-priming etchant and Single Bond, 3M-ESPE (SB), a total-etch one-bottle adhesive served as a control. All adhesives were applied according to the manufacturers’ instructions with the respective hybrid composites. The specimens were thermocycled for 500 cycles (5°C to 55°C), then loaded to failure in an Instron Universal Testing Machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. Mean bond strengths were analyzed with one-way ANOVA, followed by a Duncan’s post hoc test. SBS (mean ±SD) were: ADH = 13.2 (±5.3)b; ADP = 6.8 (±4.4)c; OP = 18.2 (±3.8)a; OU = 3.5 (±1.5)c; SB = 12.2 (±4.2)b; SE = 12.4 (±4.0)b; TY = 5.5 (±1.4)c. Superscript letters indicate Duncan’s homogeneous subsets. The self-etching adhesives OU and ADP and the self-priming etchant TY resulted in lower dentin SBS. OP resulted in the highest mean dentin SBS, while the other materials tested in this study (SE and ADH) presented similar dentin SBS to a total-etch one-bottle bonding system (SB).
Barcoll Hardness of Different Resin-based Composites Cured by Halogen or Light Emitting Diode (LED)
Clinical Relevance:
Barcoll hardness of resin-based composites cured by LED LCU was statistically equivalent to those cured by a halogen LCU. With its inherent advantages, such as a constant power output over the lifetime of the diodes, LED LCUs have great potential for achieving a clinically consistent quality of resin composite cure.
SUMMARY:
The clinical performance of light curing resin composites is greatly influenced by the quality of the light-curing unit (LCU). Halogen LCUs are commonly used for curing composite materials. However, they have some drawbacks. The development of new, blue, super bright light emitting diodes (LED LCU) of 470-nm wavelength with high light irradiance comes as an alternative to standard halogen LCUs of 450-470-nm wavelengths.
This study evaluated the surface hardness of the different resin-based composites (flowable, hybrid and packable resin composites) cured by LED LCU or halogen LCU. A Teflon mold 10-mm in diameter and 2-mm in depth was made to obtain five disk-shaped specimens for each experimental group. Then, the specimens were cured by an LED LCU or halogen LCU for 40 seconds. The hardness of the upper and lower surfaces was measured with a Barcoll hardness-measuring instrument. The statistical analysis was performed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and Duncan test at a p=0.05 significance level.
The results of the hardness test indicated that the hardness of resin composites cured by an LED LCU were greater than those cured by a halogen LCU. Additionally, for all resin-based composites, the hardness values for the upper surfaces were higher than the lower surfaces. However, for both results no statistically significant differences were observed (p>0.05).
The Antimicrobial Activity of a Dentin Conditioner Combined with Antibacterial Agents
Clinical Relevance:
The use of a cetrimide containing glass ionomer cement dentin conditioner may be useful in eliminating residual cariogenic bacteria.
SUMMARY:
Dental hand instruments are not efficient in removing all infected dentin when performing carious removal for minimal intervention techniques. The use of an antibacterial dentin conditioner may therefore be useful when restoring cavities that have residual carious dentin. Antibacterial agents—chlorhexidine hydrochloride, cetylpyridinium chloride, cetrimide, benzalkonium chloride and sodium hypochlorite, were added either to a dentin conditioner used for glass ionomer cements or distilled water at 1% concentration. Dentin conditioning solutions at pH 2.5, 4.9 and 7.7 were also prepared, along with 1% aqueous thymol. Using an agar diffusion test, 25 µl aliquots were examined for their inhibitory effects on three cariogenic bacteria. After 24 hours, an agar pellet was extracted adjacent to the agar well and placed on a second inoculated agar plate to observe sustained inhibitory effects, after which this procedure was repeated one more time. Antibacterial dentin conditioners showed significant inhibitory effect compared to the control over the three test periods (p<0.016). The combination of dentin conditioners with antibacterial agents significantly reduced the inhibitory effect compared to the antibacterial aqueous solutions (p<0.016). One-percent aqueous thymol showed no inhibitory effect against the test bacteria. The cetrimide-dentin conditioner showed the greatest inhibitory effect against all three test bacteria over the three experimental periods (p<0.016). The inhibitory effect of antibacterial agents was significantly reduced when combined with a dentin conditioner. Only the cetrimide-dentin conditioner combination produced significant inhibitory effects against all three test organisms.
Clinical Relevance:
From anassessment of an in vitro objective method for the clinical evaluation of carious dentin using colorimetry, the rates of bacterial detection in caries were inversely related to the lightness of the carious dentin stained with a caries detector dye.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study aimed to design a method for the objective evaluation of carious dentin using numerical values. This study also investigated the relationship between the color of carious dentin stained with a caries detector dye using this objective method and the rate of bacterial detection as detected by a polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In 15 molars with occlusal dentin caries and three extracted sound molars, dentin was removed in multiple steps with 300 µm removed each step. Before and after every removal, images of a color-matching sticker and carious surfaces stained with a caries detector dye were acquired simultaneously using a CCD camera and dentinal tissue samples were removed with a round bur. Next, corrected L*, a* and b* values of the carious surfaces (CIE 1976 L*a*b* color system) were calculated from the color changes of the stickers in the images. In addition, bacterial DNA in the dentinal tissue was detected by PCR. From evaluations of the receiver operating characteristic curves for the L*, a* and b* values, the L* value was determined to be a more useful parameter than a* or b* for detecting bacterial infection using the caries detector dye. The bacterial detection rates of carious dentin decreased as the L* values of carious dentin stained with the dye increased. When the L* values were more than 60, the dentin had no bacterial infection. This study clarified the relationship between the colors of lesions stained with a caries detector dye and the rates of bacterial detection.
Bonding to Sound vs Caries-affected Dentin Using Photo- and Dual-cure Adhesives
Clinical Relevance:
Bond strengths to sound and caries-affected dentin were compromised when dual-cure adhesive was used.
SUMMARY:
This study aimed to evaluate the microtensile bond strength (µTBS) of photo- and dual-cure adhesives to sound and caries-affected dentin using total- and self-etch techniques. Human third molars with occlusal caries were prepared as previously described by Nakajima and others (1995). Dentin surfaces were bonded with Optibond Solo Plus (Kerr; photo-cure adhesive) or Optibond Solo Plus + Dual-cure activator (Kerr; dual-cure adhesive) with total- and self-etch technique. Clearfil AP-X (Kuraray) was used for composite buildups. Following storage in distilled water at 37°C for 24 hours, the teeth were sectioned into 0.7-mm thick slices to obtain sound and caries-affected dentin slabs, then trimmed to form hour glass shapes with a 1 mm2 cross-sectional area. The specimens were subjected to microtensile testing using EZ-test (Shimadzu) at 1 mm/minute. Data were analyzed using three-way ANOVA and Student’s t-Test (p<0.05). Bond strengths to sound dentin with photo- and dual-cure adhesives using total- and self-etch techniques were significantly higher than those to caries-affected dentin. Dual-cure adhesive significantly decreased bond strengths both to sound and caries-affected dentin. The total-etch technique showed no beneficial effect on caries-affected dentin compared with the self-etch technique. Scanning electron microscopic observation of the resin-dentin interfaces revealed that hybrid layers in caries-affected dentin were thicker than those observed in sound dentin with photo- and dual-cure adhesives. Resin infiltration into dentinal tubules of caries-affected dentin was hampered by the presence of mineral deposits.
Effect of Hygiene Maintenance Procedures on Surface Roughness of Composite Restoratives
Clinical Relevance:
Composite restorations may require re-polishing after exposure to some hygiene maintenance procedures. The surface finish of composite restoratives is least affected by the use of prophylaxis gels.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the effect of various hygiene maintenance procedures on the surface finish of minifill (Filtek A110 [AO], 3M-ESPE), flowable (Filtek Flow [FF], 3M-ESPE) and polyacid-modified (F2000 [FT], 3M-ESPE) composites. Procedures included pumice-water slurry with rotating brush (PB), pumice-water slurry with rotating rubber cup (PC), prophylaxis paste with rubber cup (ZC), prophylaxis gel with rubber cup (GC) and air-powder polishing (AP). Specimens not exposed to these procedures were used as the control group. For each material, 48 specimens (3-mm long x 3-mm wide x 2-mm deep) were made and stored in distilled water at 37°C for one month. The specimens were then treated with 1200 grit sandpaper using a lapping device, stored for an additional two months in distilled water at 37°C and randomly divided into six groups (n=8). The mean surface roughness (Ra, µm) of the specimens after exposure to the various hygiene procedures was determined using a surface profilometer. Data was subjected to ANOVA/Scheffe’s test at significance level 0.05. Mean Ra values ranged from 0.09 to 2.17, 0.06 to 1.38 and 0.38 to 1.25 for AO, FF and FT, respectively. The effect of hygiene procedures on surface roughness was material dependent. Among the various procedures, the smoothest surface was observed after treatment with prophylaxis gel and the roughest with air-powder polishing. For all materials, the use of pumice-water slurry with brush also caused significant roughening. Composite restorations may require re-polishing after exposure to some hygiene maintenance procedures, as Ra values exceeded the critical threshold surface roughness for bacterial adhesion (0.2 µm).
Clinical Relevance:
The process of applying a conditioner agent to hard tooth tissues decreases the microleakage of GIC (glass ionomer cement) and establishes a good bond between GIC and enamel and dentin.
SUMMARY:
The smear layer, which occurs during cavity preparation procedures, does not constitute a stable substructure in the bond of restorative material to dental hard tissues. Depending on the dissolution of this material in the course of time, microleakage occurs between the tooth and restorative material.
This study evaluated the effects of different conditioner agents (Fuji Cavity Conditioner, 10% maleic acid, 35% phosphoric acid and 3% hydrogen peroxide) on Fuji IX microleakage, Fuji IX-enamel and Fuji IX-dentin combination in Class I cavities prepared to standards having the dimensions of 4x3x2 mm3 in extracted primary molars. The restorations were then subjected to thermocycling procedures and soaked in the 0.5% basic-fuchsin dye for 24 hours. Some sections were taken, parallel to the long axis of the tooth in a mesio-distal direction, and evaluated under a stereomicroscope for leakage. Also, two samples of Fuji IX-enamel and dentin combinations were chosen randomly from each group for evaluation in scanning electron microscopy (SEM).
The distribution of microleakage occurred as follows: Control Group > Hydrogen Peroxide > 10% Maleic acid > Fuji Cavity Conditioner = Phosphoric acid. The difference between microleakage scores obtained from the groups was statistically significant (p<0.05). The SEM evaluation revealed a close interface connection in all groups except for the control and hydrogen peroxide groups in the Fuji IX-enamel combination. In the Fuji IX-dentin combination, however, a close interface connection was observed except in the control group.
In conclusion, the application of conditioner agents to Class I cavities restored with glass ionomer cement with a high viscosity in vitro either diminishes or completely eliminates microleakage.
Microleakage at the Composite-repair Interface: Effect of Different Surface Treatment Methods
Clinical Relevance:
Surface preparation and the use of an adhesive system promote an adequate bonding, able to prevent microleakage at the repair interface.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated microleakage at the composite-repair interface after using different methods of surface treatment. Eighty resin composite specimens (Filtek Z250, 3M Dental Products) aged in artificial saliva for three months were divided into four groups (n=20) according to the following surface treatment methods: untreated control–no roughening or abrasion of the surface; roughening with diamond burs; jet prophylaxis with sodium bicarbonate particles and air abrasion with 50 µm aluminum oxide particles. Each method was examined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) to evaluate changes in surface topography. All groups were then etched with 37% phosphoric acid, coated with a bonding agent (Single Bond, 3M Dental Products) and received new resin applications. The samples were then thermocycled (800 cycles/5°C to 55°C [±2]) and immersed in 2% methylene blue buffered dye solution (7.0 pH) for four hours. Three examiners measured the extent of microleakage in a stereoscope microscope using four representative scores. For all experimental groups, no significant difference in repair microleakage was identified by the Kruskal-Wallis test (p>0.05). Therefore, different testing methods of surface treatment showed the same effect on dye penetration along the repair interface.
Polymerization Shrinkage of Flowable Resin-based Restorative Materials
Clinical Relevance:
Polymerization shrinkage is a critical limitation of flowable resin-based restorative materials. The dental community, although aware of the problem, should place more emphasis on this property. In this study, a wide range of values was measured for both polymerization shrinkage properties that were studied. Dentists should be aware of these differences in order to choose the more suitable material for each clinical use.
SUMMARY:
This study measured the linear polymerization displacement and polymerization forces induced by polymerization shrinkage of a series of flowable resin-based restorative materials.
The materials tested were 22 flowable resin-based restorative materials (Admira Flow, Aelite Flow, Aeliteflow LV, Aria, Crystal Essence, Definite Flow, Dyract Flow, Filtek Flow, FloRestore, Flow-it, Flow-Line, Freedom, Glacier, OmegaFlo, PermaFlo, Photo SC, Revolution 2, Star Flow, Synergy Flow, Tetric Flow, Ultraseal XT and Wave). Measurements for linear polymerization displacement and polymerization forces were performed using custom made measuring devices. Polymerization of the test materials was carried out for 60 seconds by means of a light curing unit, and each property was measured for 180 seconds from the start of curing in eight specimens for each material. Statistical evaluation of the data was performed with one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Tukey’s Studentized Range (HSD) test (p=0.05) and simple linear regression.
A wide range of values was recorded for linear polymerization displacement (26.61 to 80.74 microns) and polymerization forces (3.23 to 7.48 kilograms). Statistically significant differences among materials were found for both properties studied. Very few materials (Freedom, Glacier, and Photo SC) presented low values of linear polymerization displacement and polymerization forces (similar to hybrid resin composites), while the majority of materials presented very high values in both properties studied. Study of the shrinkage kinetics revealed the exponential growth process of both properties. The polymerization forces development exhibited a few seconds delay over linear polymerization displacement. Simple linear regression showed that the two polymerization shrinkage properties that were studied were not highly correlated (r2=0.59).
Influence of Dietary Solvents on Strength of Nanofill and Ormocer Composites
Clinical Relevance:
The strength of nanofill and ormocer composites is generally not affected by dietary solvents. These materials are weaker than minifill composites but stronger than compomers and highly viscous glass ionomer cements.
SUMMARY:
The objective of this study was to determine the influence of dietary solvents on the shear punch strength of nanofill (Filtek Supreme [FS], 3M-ESPE) and ormocer (Admira [AM], Voco) composites. The strength of these materials was also compared to a minifill composite (Z250 [ZT], 3M-ESPE), a compomer (F2000 [FT], 3M-ESPE) and a highly viscous glass ionomer cement (Ketac Molar Quick [KM], 3M-ESPE). Thirty-two specimens (8.7 mm diameter and 1-mm thick) of each material were made, randomly divided into four groups of eight and conditioned for one week as follows–Group 1 (control): distilled water at 37°C; Group 2: 0.02M citric acid at 37°C; Group 3: 50% ethanol-water solution at 37°C and Group 4: heptane at 37°C. After conditioning, the specimens were restrained with a torque of 2.5 Nm and subjected to shear punch strength testing using a 2-mm diameter punch at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. The shear punch strength of the specimens was computed and data subjected to ANOVA/Scheffe’s tests at significance level 0.05. With the exception of AM, the strength of all materials was not significantly influenced by dietary solvents. For AM, conditioning in heptane resulted in significantly higher shear strength values. The strength of the nanofill and ormocer composites was lower than the minifill composite but higher than the compomer and highly viscous glass ionomer cement investigated.
Awards
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Dr Warren Johnson
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Dr David Bridgeman
In Memoriam, Dr Ralph J Werner
Clinical Research
Polishing Occlusal Surfaces of Direct Class II Composite Restorations In Vivo
Clinical Relevance:
Under clinical conditions, the four polishing methods under consideration had similar smoothing effects on occlusal composite surfaces. The use of Occlubrush was of limited efficiency with respect to achieving rounded occlusal contours.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effects of four polishing methods on the occlusal surfaces of direct Class II composite restorations under clinical conditions.
Forty premolars and 40 molars were treated with direct Class II restorations using the hybrid composite Herculite XRV (Kerr). After placement of the restorations, all of which were on occlusal surfaces, they were finished with a sequence of 30 µm diamonds and tungsten carbide instruments. Twenty restorations each, consisting of 10 premolars and 10 molars, were polished with one of the four following methods: (1) Diafix-oral (Mueller-Dental), (2) MPS gel (Premier), (3) P 403-W (Dentsply) and (4) Occlubrush (KerrHawe). Selection of the polishing methods followed a randomized protocol. Replicas of the restored teeth were fabricated and the occlusal surfaces were evaluated quantitatively for roughness with the help of profilometry. Qualitative assessment of the surfaces by SEM was done with respect to roundness of contours and surface roughness. The results were analyzed statisti-cally by two-way ANOVA, chi-squared test for crosstables and Kruskal-Wallis test.
Analysis of the quantitative data showed that there was no significant effect of the polishing methods on occlusal surface roughness (p>0.05). Localization of the restoration in premolars or molars had no effect on surface roughness (p>0.05). With respect to occlusal relief, SEM examination revealed that the use of the Occlubrush resulted in significantly more edged contours compared to the other polishing methods (p=0.008). Qualitative roughness evaluation showed that there were no significant differences among the four polishing methods (p>0.05).
Response of Human Pulp Capped with a Bonding Agent After Bleeding Control with Hemostatic Agents
Clinical Relevance:
Calcium hydroxide should be used as the material of choice for pulp capping. The use of dentin bonding agents in vital pulp capping even after successful hemostasis is contraindicated.
SUMMARY:
Purpose: This study evaluated the response of human pulps capped with a bonding agent after bleeding control with different hemostatic agents. Material and Methods: Twenty-five Class II cavities were prepared in 25 caries-free human premolars scheduled for extraction due to orthodontic treatment. The pulp exposures were performed on the occlusal floor. The teeth were randomly divided into five groups. Groups 1-4 were capped with an adhesive system after hemostasis with different agents: Group 1—saline solution; 2—ferric sulfate; 3—2.5% NaOCl; 4—Ca(OH)2 solution. In Group 5, after hemostasis with saline solution, the pulp was capped with calcium hydroxide (control group). Then, ScotchBond Multi Purpose Plus was applied and the resin composite Z-100 placed incrementally according to the manufacturers’ directions. After 60 days, the teeth were extracted and processed for light microscopic examination (HE) and the groups were categorized in a histological score system. The data were subjected to a non-parametric test (a=0.05). Results: Overall, the histological features showed that the pulp response from Groups 1 through 4 was inferior to the response from Group 5, where dentin bridging occurred. In all groups, where the adhesive system was used for capping, the pulp response varied from an acute inflammatory, with varying degrees, to necrosis. No dentin bridge was formed after adhesive capping.
Clinical Relevance:
The outcome of this clinical study suggests that the three evaluated bleaching techniques resulted in the desired whitening of teeth within the recommended application time periods. Each method was also well accepted by the patients. The side effects that occurred were reversible and none of the products tested resulted in detectable changes in the enamel surface.
SUMMARY:
This clinical study compared the efficacy of three different bleaching techniques with respect to the bleaching times required in order to achieve six grades of whitening in human teeth. Any side effects that were noted and the patients’ acceptance of the method were recorded by a visual analog scale ranging from 0 to 10. Moreover, epoxy casts from the study teeth were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy in order to detect any potential changes in the enamel surface due to treatments.
Laboratory Research
Microleakage of Compomer Restorations in Primary Teeth After Preparation with Bur or Air Abrasion
Clinical Relevance:
Where the cavity had been prepared conventionally or with air abrasion, acid etching may be eliminated for compomer restorations.
SUMMARY:
This study compared the degree of marginal leakage of a compomer in Class V cavities of human primary molars prepared by a conventional dental bur and air abrasion with or without acid etching.
Fifty-six non-carious extracted primary molars were randomly divided into four groups (n=14) to be prepared by four techniques: Group-1: Bur followed by acid etching: Class V cavity preparations were placed on the buccal surfaces of each tooth using a high-speed handpiece. The preparations were 1.5-mm deep, 3-mm long and 2-mm wide, with the occlusal margin in enamel and the cervical margin extending 0.5 mm below the cementoenamel junction. The preparations were acid etched with 37% phosphoric acid starting at the enamel margins for 30 seconds and rinsed with water for 20 seconds. The preparations were then restored with Compoglass F. 2-Group 2: Bur: The preparations and the treatment procedures were the same as in Group 1, with the exception of 37% phosphoric acid application. Group 3: Air abrasion followed by acid etching: Class V cavity preparations were placed on the buccal surfaces of each tooth using a handpiece of an air-abrasive system (PrepStart, Danville Engineering). The system was supplied with dry compressed air at 80 psi. In all tests, the air-abrasion system was operated with an 80˚-angle handpiece tip and 50-mm aluminum oxide particles. A tip with a 0.38-mm inner diameter was used at a 2-mm distance. The treatment procedures were the same as in Groups 1 and 2. Group 4: Air abrasion: The preparations and treatment procedures were the same as in Group 3, with the exception of 37% phosphoric acid. After finishing the restorations, the teeth were stored in distilled water at 37˚C for 24 hours. The samples were thermocycled for 500 cycles between 5˚C and 55˚C with a dwell time of 30 seconds. The samples were then immersed in 0.5 percent basic fuchsin dye for 24 hours at 37˚C. The surface-adhered dye was then rinsed in tap water and the teeth were embedded in a chemically-activated acrylic resin and bisected longitudinally in a mesiodistal direction with a low speed diamond disk. Each section was examined under a stereomicroscope (Nikon, Tokyo, Japan) at 20x magnification. The data were analyzed statistically by Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance to determine any statistical significant differences in microleakage scores among the groups at a p-value of 0.05. Also, the enamel versus cementum-dentin microleakage scores of each group were compared using z-test at the 0.05 significance level. There was no statistically significant difference among the groups (p>0.05), but a statistical difference between enamel and cementum-dentin surfaces was evaluated (p<0.05).
Clinical Relevance:
Dentin surface irradiated by CO2 laser could be an adherent only when the carbonized dentin layer on the surface to be bonded was mechanically removed, although long-term durability of the interface is still to be studied.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated, mechanically and morphologically, whether the dentin surface irradi-ated by CO2 laser could be a possible adherent when bonded with simplified-step adhesives. Buccal enamel and cementum of extracted human premolars were removed to expose a flat dentin surface. The dentin surfaces were irradiated continuously with CO2 laser at 1.0 W. Before bonding with either a single-bottle adhesive (Single Bond) or a self-etching priming system (Mega Bond), the irradiated dentin surface was treated as follows: no treatment, NaHCO3 powder abrasion and wet-grinding with 600-grit SiC paper. The treated dentin surfaces were bonded to resin composite with either of the two adhesives. Non-irradiated dentin surfaces were also used as control. Resin bonded specimens were stored in water at 37°C for 24 hours and subjected to microtensile bond test. Additionally, to observe the resin/irradiated dentin interface, resin-bonded specimens were similarly prepared, sectioned into slabs, embedded in epoxy resin, polished with diamond pastes, sputter coated Au-Pd and examined with scanning electron microscopy (SEM). After SEM observation, the specimens were further polished with diamond paste to remove the Au-Pd sputter-coat, immersed in HCL and NaOCl and finally observed by SEM again.
In the presence of carbonized dentin, microtensile bond strength drastically decreased but recovered to the control value by removing the carbonized dentin layer visually with SiC paper for both adhesive systems. However, the laser-affected dentin that remained on the bonded interface was easily dissolved with NaOCl and HCl.
Effect of Prophylaxis Regimens on Surface Roughness of Glass Ionomer Cements
Clinical Relevance:
The effect of prophylaxis regimens on glass ionomer cements was material dependent. Glass ionomer restorations may require re-polishing after exposure to some prophy-laxis regimens.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the surface roughness of conventional (Fuji II Capsulated [FC], GC Corporation, Tokyo, Japan), resin-modified (Fuji II LC [FL], GC Corporation) [FL] and highly viscous (Fuji IX GP Fast [FN], GC Corporation) glass ionomer cements [GICs] after exposure to five prophylaxis regimes. The surface roughness obtained was compared to untreated polished specimens (control). The prophylaxis regimes evaluated were rotating brush with pumice-water slurry [PB]; rotating rubber cup with pumice-water slurry [PC]; rotating rubber cup with prophylaxis paste [PP]; rotating rubber cup with prophylaxis gel [PG] and air-powder polishing [PJ]. Forty-eight specimens (3-mm long x 3-mm wide x 2-mm deep) were made for each material. The specimens were stored in distilled water at 37°C for one month, polished with 1200 grit sandpaper using a lapping device and randomly divided into six groups (n=8). They were then stored for an additional two months in distilled water at 37°C prior to exposure to the various prophylaxis regimens. The mean surface roughness value (Ra; µm) was measured with a profilometer. Data was subjected to ANOVA/Scheffe’s tests at significance level 0.05. Mean Ra ranged from 0.30 to 1.70 µm for FC, 0.40 to 2.52 µm for FL and 0.36 to 1.79 µm for FN. Regardless of the type of glass ionomer, treatment with PJ resulted in significantly rougher surfaces when compared to the control group. For FC and FN, a significant increase in roughness was observed after treatment with PB and PP, respectively. Glass ionomer restorations may require re-polishing after exposure to some prophylaxis regimens.
Curing Depth of a Resin-modified Glass Ionomer and Two Resin-based Luting Agents
Clinical Relevance:
Chemical cure of dual-cure luting agents was unable to provide a high degree of conversion for the dual-cured composites.
SUMMARY:
The degree of conversion of resin-based luting agents used for retention of prefabricated posts has been questioned due to the difficulty of light penetration into the resin-filled root canal. This study evaluated the depth of cure of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement (Rely X–3M ESPE) and two resin-based luting agents (Rely X ARC—3M ESPE and Enforce–Dentsply). Twenty-four 14x2x2mm3 specimens were prepared in a Teflon split mold with the three luting agents (n=8). After preparation, the specimens were stored at 37°C in a dark box for 24 hours prior to microhardness testing. Measurements of Knoop hardness were performed at three different depths: superficial, medium and deep thirds. The results (KHN) were statistically analyzed by repeated measures ANOVA and Tukey test (0.05), which showed that resin-based luting agents presented the highest Knoop hardness values within the superficial third. Within the medium third, there were no significant differences among luting materials. However, within the deep third, Rely X presented the highest values. KHN values of resin-based luting agents decreased remarkably as depth increased.
Clinical Relevance:
The use of systems providing magnification aided occlusal caries diagnosis according to a ranked visual scoring system (ERK).
SUMMARY:
This study compared the efficiency of unaided visual examination, intraoral camera and operating microscope according to a visual scoring system (ERK) at occlusal caries detection.
A total of 84 extracted human molars were mounted to create mouth models with a premolar in contact on both sides. The models were examined in a phantom head simulating clinical conditions by four observers using the three techniques: unaided visual examination, an intraoral camera and on operating microscope according to the ERK scale. The teeth were than sectioned in a mesio-distal direction and examined under a stereomicroscope with 10x magnification for histological validation.
The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive and negative predictive values were calculated for the four observers with three techniques and statistical analyses were performed using Friedman and DUNN tests, while strength of agreement was determined by calculating Kappa values.
From the data, mean sensitivity values were calculated as 0.26, 0.43, 0.49 and mean specificity values as 0.87, 0.80 and 0.73 for unaided visual examination, intraoral camera and operating microscope, respectively. The Kappa values ranged between 0.187 and 0.301 for visual examination, 0.328 and 0.459 for intraoral camera and 0.363 and 0.516 for operating microscope.
As a result, the use of an intraoral camera and operating microscope improved occlusal caries detection according to the ERK scale.
Microtensile Bond Strengths of One-step and Self-etching Adhesive Systems
Clinical Relevance:
In this investigation, conventional one-step adhesives showed significantly higher microtensile bond strengths than self-etching adhesives.
SUMMARY:
The microtensile bond strength of resin com-posite bonded to human enamel was evaluated utilizing four light-cure bonding agents. Human third molars were embedded in auto-cure acrylic and the buccal surfaces were sequentially abraded to 400 grit. Resin composite cylinders were then bonded using the four bonding systems according to the manufacturer’s specifications. Each bonded tooth produced three to four longitudinal sections which were then laterally notched to give a square bond area (~2.25 mm2). Specimens (n=10) were assigned to two groups: Group I was stored in distilled water at 37° ± 2°C for seven days. Group II was stored in distilled water at 37° ± 2°C for seven days, during which time it was thermocycled in hot and cold water baths for 1,000 cycles. In addition, a water sorption test was performed on three of the four adhesive systems. The microtensile bond strength of the conventional adhesive Optibond Solo Plus was significantly greater than that of the self-etching adhesives Tyrian SPE and Prompt L-Pop. Adhesive systems that were more hydrophilic tended to show lower bond strengths, especially after thermocycling.
Clinical Relevance:
The first step towards a successful adhesive restorative procedure is pre-treatment of the substrate for bonding. The total-etch bonding technique involves treatment of cavities with mineral or organic acids. This treatment removes all minerals to a depth of 6-8 µm and exposes the collagenous fiber network of the matrix, making it available for adhesive resin infiltration. The role of the collagen network on dentin bonding has also been questioned, and self-etching primers have been suggested as an improved technique for bonding to dentin; they are less aggressive and promote a more uniform surface after treatment. The morphological alterations of smear layer-covered dentin promoted by these agents, evaluated by this study, are important to better understand bonding techniques.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study morphologically evaluated the effect of some current surface pre-treatments on dentin, using scanning electron microscopy, and related these morphological alterations to clinical implications. The labial surfaces of 30 bovine lower incisors were ground to obtain a flat dentin \surface and were finished with 600-grit SiC paper to produce standardized smear layers. The teeth were randomly divided into six groups of five each. Group 1 was the control group, smear layer covered dentin; Group 2 was etched with 37% phosphoric acid (PA) for 15 seconds; Group 3, 37% PA for 15 seconds, followed by 10% NaOCl for 60 seconds; Group 4, 10% NaOCl for 60 seconds; Group 5, a self-etching primer (Clearfil SE Bond, CSEB-primer) was applied for 20 seconds; Group 6, CSEB-primer for 20 seconds, followed by NaOCl for 60 seconds. The specimens were fixed, dehydrated, dried and analyzed by SEM. Treatment with 37% PA removed the smear layer, funneled the tubules and resulted in a collagen-rich surface which appeared to have collapsed in its outermost part, producing a dense surface layer covered with silica particles. When 37% PA treatment was followed by 10% NaOCl, the col-lagen network was removed to reveal an eroded, rough mineral surface with numerous lateral branches and larger than normal tubular orifices. The action of 10% NaOCl on the smear layer-covered dentin showed no significant alteration in surface morphology. The treatment with CSEB-primer dissolved the smear layer but only partially dissolved the smear plugs. The tubules did not present the typical funnel shape seen following PA treatment. These morphological aspects on dentin surface must influence bonding results. The dentin surface alterations produced by PA appeared to be a very severe demineralization pattern, quite irregular and less permeable to monomer infiltration, while the surface provided by the self-etching primer appeared to be a more uniform, less porous surface, and the association with simultaneous monomer infiltration may reduce the occurrence of mistakes in clinical bonding procedures.
Influence of Different Beverages on the Microhardness and Surface Roughness of Resin Composites
Clinical Relevance:
The outcomes of the reported study reveal that certain types of beverages can yield significant alterations to the mechanical properties of resin composites.
SUMMARY:
This study assessed the influence of different beverages on the microhardness and surface roughness of microfilled (A110, 3M/ESPE), hybrid (Z250 3M/ESPE) and flowable (Flow, 3M/ESPE) resin composites, over time. Twenty-four disc-shaped specimens (10 mm; 2-mm thick) of each resin composite were fabricated, thereby forming three groups (n=24). Knoop microhardness and surface roughness (Ra) were analyzed at predetermined evaluation periods: 24 hours, and 7, 30 and 60 days after specimens fabrication. The 24-hour measurements were recorded after storage in artificial saliva. Next, each group (n=24) was divided into four subgroups (n=6) according to the test beverages: Coca-Cola, sugar cane spirit, coffee and artificial saliva (control). Control specimens were kept in saliva throughout the experiment (60 days). For experimental specimens, a 60-day testing cycle was carried out: specimens were initially stored in saliva for four hours, then submitted to a five-minute immersion in the beverages (Coca-Cola, sugar cane spirit, coffee) intercalated by immersions in saliva three times daily. Microhardness/roughness measurements were done at 7-, 30- and 60-day intervals. Data were submitted to three-way ANOVA and Scheffée test (p<0.05). It was observed that the tested beverages somewhat altered (p<0.05) the composites’ microhardness and/or surface roughness. Knoop microhardness—for all resin composites, microhardness remained stable up to the 30-day record, decreasing significantly at the 60-day evaluation. During the interaction beverage X evaluation period, it was observed that the microhardness of materials immersed in coffee and Coca-Cola remained stable up to the seven-day measurement, showing a decrease at the 30-day record and a more accentuated drop at the 60-day evaluation (p<0.05). Specimens immersed in sugar cane spirit exhibited no significant change in microhardness up to the seven-day measurement, increasing significantly at the 30-day record and later decreasing at the 60-day evaluation. Surface Roughness—For all resin composites, surface roughness increased at the seven-day measurement, while decreasing at the 30-day record and even more at the 60-day record. In the interaction beverage X evaluation period, the surface roughness of specimens immersed in test beverages increased at the seven-day measurement, showing a gradual decrease at the following records (30- and 60-day evaluations). The findings of the reported research disclosed that all beverages altered, to some degree, the microhardness and/or surface roughness of the tested resin composites. The alterations’ effects ranged from slightly adverse to a markedly negative impact on the composites’ microhardness and surface roughness, depending on the characteristics of the materials, type of beverage and the evaluated period. Generally, the greater number of immersions in beverages resulted in a more accentuated impact on the resins’ properties.
Clinical Relevance:
For endodontic quartz coated carbon fiber posts that areused to support an adhesively bonded resin-composite core, adhesive resin-composite cements are advised.
SUMMARY:
Clinical studies have shown that endodontically treated teeth restored with short posts or deficient ferrules show a high failure risk. This study evaluated the influence of fatigue loading on the quality of the cement layer between prefabricated quartz coated carbon fiber posts with restricted length and the root canal wall in maxillary premolars. Two adhesive resin composite cements, chemical-cured Panavia 21 (Group 1) and dual-cured RelyX-ARC (Group 2), and one resin-modified glass-ionomer cement, chemical-cured RelyX (Group 3), ∆ were selected for this study. Post-and-core restorations were made on single-rooted human maxillary premolars from which the coronal sections were removed at the level of the proximal cemento-enamel junction (CEJ). Following endodontic treatment, a post-and-core restoration with 6-mm post length was prepared for each tooth. The posts were directly cemented into the root canal and, after applying an adhesive (Clearfil Photo Bond), they were built up with a core build-up composite (Clearfil Photo Core). For each group (n=8), half of the specimens were exposed to fatigue loading (106 load cycles) almost perpendicular to the axial axis (85°), while the other half were used as the control. Three parallel, transverse root sections, 1.5-mm thick, were cut from each specimen at the apical, medial and coronal location. These sections were examined by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to evaluate the integrity of the cement layer, while the retention strength of the cemented post sections was determined with the push-out test. The multivariate results of MANOVA showed that the condition main effect (fatigue or control) was not significant (p=0.059); the two other main effects, type of cement and section location, were significant (p=0.001 and p=0.008). For both the push-out strength and SEM evaluation of the cement layer integrity, the results significantly improved from RelyX to RelyX-ARC to Panavia 21 and also from apical to coronal.
Bonded Amalgam Restorations: Microleakage and Tensile Bond Strength Evaluation
Clinical Relevance:
When a good seal and improved retention are required, the adhesive systems beneath bonding amalgam restorations should be activated by two methods (light and chemical curing). When only sealing is required, light-cured adhesives can be employed prior to amalgam condensation.
SUMMARY:
Purpose: The objective of this study was to evaluate the tensile bond strength (BS) and microleakage (MI) of bonded amalgam restorations to dentin when an unfilled and a filled system are used under three application modes. Material and Methods: Seventy-two and 96 human molars, respectively, were employed for BS and MI tests. For BS, the occlusal surface of the molars was ground flat until dentin exposure. A 3-mm area was delimited for bonding. For MI, Class V cavities were prepared in the CEJ (4 mm x 4 mm x 2 mm). For each test, the molars were randomly divided into six treatment groups defined by a combination of the levels: Adhesive system (Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus [SBMP], Optibond dual cure [OPTB]) and Application mode (light–LC, chemical–C and combination of light and chemical curing–LCC). After adhesive application, the amalgam was condensed into a Teflon mold (BS) and into the cavities (MI). After storage in saline solution for seven days at 37°C, the specimens were subjected to the BS test at 0.5 mm/minute. For microleakage evaluation, the restorations were sealed with nail varnish, except for an area 1 mm around the restoration, immersed in 5% methylene blue solution for 24 hours and sectioned into two halves. Each half was evaluated by two trained examiners at 25x magnification in a 0-3 score system and the highest score was recorded. The BS data was evaluated by two-way ANOVA and Tukey’s test (a=0.05). The MI data were analyzed by Kruskal Wallis and Mann-Whitney tests (a= 0.05). Results: The main factors were significant for the BS test: the highest BS mean was obtained using the LCC technique and the OPTB system. Regarding the MI test, only the application mode was significant: lower dye infiltration was observed for LC and LCC.
Effect of Flexural Load Cycling on Microleakage of Extended Root Caries Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
The marginal sealing ability of a flowable resin composite with dentin adhesive under a flexural cycling load was better than in other selected materials; and flowable resin composite and dentin adhesive may be suitable for the restoration of advanced root caries.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the microleakage of resin-modified glass ionomer, flowable compomer and flowable resin composite restorations on a Class V cavity of simulated advanced root caries under a flexural load cycling condition. Thirty-six non-carious human maxillary premolars were mounted in cylindrical acrylic resin molds. The cavities were prepared in the proximal root surface, from the middle of the buccal surface to the middle of the lingual surface, approximately 1 mm below the cemento-enamel junction, 2 mm axial width and 1.2 mm in depth. The teeth were randomly assigned to one of three groups with 12 teeth in each group: Group 1: Cavity conditioner and Fuji II LC (GC America), Group 2: Prime & Bond NT and Dyract Flow (Caulk-Dentsply), Group 3: Excite and Tetric flow (Ivoclar/Vivadent). Specimens were settled laterally on a fatigue- testing machine that was adjusted to deliver a force of 60N. The specimens were load cycled at 1Hz for 5000 cycles, placed in a staining solution and sectioned to evaluate microleakage penetration. Results indicate that the coronal and gingival margins showed significant microleakage differences among the three restorations (p<0.05). At the coronal margin, there was no significant difference between Groups 2 and 3. At the gin-gival margin, there was no significant difference between Groups 1 and 2. It was concluded that the marginal sealing ability of a flowable resin composite under a flexural cycling load was better than in other selected materials and that flowable resin composite with dentin adhesive was a desirable alternative for root caries restorations extended to the proximal surface.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the flexural strength, flexural modulus, modulus of resilience and water sorption of eight flowable light-cured restorative materials compared with two conventional restoratives (as control). Forty specimens of each material were made. Twenty specimens were immediately flexural tested, while the remaining 20 were weight-measured and immersed in distilled water in a 37°C incubator. After 24 hours, the samples were weight-measured again to identify water sorption and they were flexural tested. The findings were statistically analyzed using t-test, one-way ANOVA, Tukey test and Pearson’s Product-Moment Correlation. The results of the flexural strength test were also analyzed using Weibull statistic. All flowable light-cured restorative materials except Palfique Estelite Low Flow exhibited immediate flexural strength values between the conventional ones. All flowable light-cured restorative materials showed 24-hour flexural strength values between the conventional ones. The Weibull modulus for immediate flexural strength of the materials varied from 6.37 to 15.23, while for 24-hour flexural strength, the strength varied from 8.10 to 14.30. In both conditions, all flowable light-cured resin composites showed lower flexural moduli but higher modulus of resilience than the conventional ones. The water sorption of all resin composites was lower than the flowable light-cured compomer. There was a distinct relation (r=-0.84, p<0.01) between the increasing ratio in modulus of resilience and the amount of water sorption.
Influence of Disinfectants on Dentin Bond Strength of Different Adhesive Systems
Clinical Relevance:
Contamination of human dentin with disinfectants in the waterlines of dental units may have an influence on dentin bonding, depending on the adhesive system used.
SUMMARY:
The influence of water disinfectants used in dental unit waterlines on the dentin bonding of different adhesive systems was investigated by using push-out tests. Three hundred and twenty dentin disc specimens were prepared from caries-free human molars. In each specimen, a standardized conical cavity was prepared while cooling with water from a dental unit containing one of three different disinfectants (n=80 each group; A=control: water without disinfectant, B: Alpron neutral, C: Alpron mint, D: Dentosept P). Subsequent rinsing of the cavities was performed with the respective disinfectant. The cavities were filled with the following combinations of dentin adhesives and composites, resulting in 16 subgroups (n=20): Syntac Classic/Tetric Ceram, Clearfil Liner Bond 2V/Luxacore, OptiBond FL/Prodigy and Prime&Bond NT/Spectrum. After polishing the fillings, one half of each subgroup (n=10) was stored in water (37°C) for 24 hours. The other half was stored in water (37°C) for 180 days and additionally thermocycled (2000 cycles at 5/55°C). The bond strength was then measured by push-out tests. Statistical analysis of the data was carried out using ANOVA and pairwise t-tests (Significance level p≤0.01). The disinfectants showed no significant influence on the loads required for debonding of Syntac Classic/Tetric Ceram, Clearfil Liner Bond 2V/Luxacore and OptiBond FL/Prodigy as compared to the controls. However, the use of disinfectants in the water supply of a dental unit decreased dentin bond strength in the specimens filled with Prime&Bond NT/Spectrum.
Disinfectants in the water of dental unit waterlines may have an influence on dentin bonding, depending on the adhesive system used.
Thermal Emission and Curing Efficiency of LED and Halogen Curing Lights
Clinical Relevance:
A second-generation light-emitting diode (LED) curing light has a similar thermal emission and curing efficiency as a quartz-tungsten-halogen (QTH) curing light at similar energy densities.
SUMMARY:
The purpose of this study was to compare the thermal emission and curing efficiency of LED (LEDemetron 1, SDS/Kerr) and QTH (VIP, BISCO) curing lights at maximum output and similar power, power density and energy density using the same light guide. Also, another LED curing light (Allegro, Den-Mat) and the QTH light at reduced power density were tested for comparison. Increase in temperature from the tips of the light guides was measured at 0 and 5 mm in air (23°C) using a temperature probe (Fluke Corp). Pulpal temperature increase was measured using a digital thermometer (Omega Co) and a K-type thermocouple placed on the central pulpal roof of human molars with a Class I occlusal preparation. Measurements were made over 90 seconds with an initial light activation of 40 seconds. To test curing efficiency, resin composites (Z100, A110, 3M/ESPE) were placed in a 2-mm deep and 8-mm wide plastic mold and cured with the LED and QTH curing lights at 1- and 5-mm curing distances. Knoop Hardness Numbers (KHN) were determined on the top and bottom surfaces (Leco). Bottom hardness values were expressed as a percentage of maximum top hardness. No significant differences were found in maximum thermal emission or KHN ratios between the LED (LEDemetron 1) and the QTH (VIP) at maximum output and similar energy densities (ANOVA/Tukey’s; a=0.05).
The Effect of Whitening Agents on Caries Susceptibility of Human Enamel
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this study provide support for the concept that vital tooth whitening does not produce caries susceptibility in human enamel.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated whether the treatment of human enamel with whitening agents containing different concentrations of carbamide or hydrogen peroxide changes the susceptibility of enamel to caries. Twenty-four sound human incisors were selected for this study. For each tooth, the crown was sectioned into two halves in the cervical-incisal direction. One half of the sectioned tooth was treated and the other half was used as a control specimen. Each half was randomly divided into three treatment groups (eight two-halves/group). The whitening agents were 10% carbamide peroxide, 20% carbamide peroxide with fluoride and 35% hydrogen peroxide. Following pretreatment, the specimens were demineralized for four days in an in vitro microbial caries model and then analyzed using a confocal laser scanning microscope (CLSM). Results showed that there were no significant differences between the treated and controlled specimens for teeth treated with 10% carbamide peroxide or 35% hydrogen peroxide. However, specimens treated with 20% carbamide peroxide with FP (0.11% fluoride and potassium nitrate) were less susceptible to caries than their controls at p≤ 0.05. In conclusion, application of bleaching agents does not increase the caries susceptibility of human enamel.
Dental amalgam is 50% mercury…or is it?
In Memoriam, Dr Floyd Eugene Hamstrom
Clinical Research
Three-year Clinical Evaluation of a Compomer and a Resin Composite as Class V Filling Materials
Clinical Relevance:
Silux Plus, a microfilled composite, retained its surface finish better than F2000, a compomer; no other statistically significant differences were found. The retention rate for F2000 and Single Bond was 100%; for F2000, the self-etching primer was 96.6% and for Silux Plus with Single Bond, the retention rate was 90.3%. A compomer can be retained well with a self-etching primer; however, all three combinations were satisfactory at three years.
SUMMARY:
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the placement of two restorative materials, including a compomer (F2000, 3M ESPE) and a resin composite (Silux Plus, 3M ESPE), in non-carious cervical lesions using a self-etching bonding agent (F2000 self-etching primer/adhesive) and a fifth generation bonding agent (Single Bond, 3M ESPE) and to evaluate and compare these restorations for marginal discoloration, secondary caries, anatomical form, retention, surface texture and marginal adaptation at baseline and annually for three years. F2000 and Silux Plus were used to restore the teeth with moderate-sized non-carious cervical lesions. F2000 was placed using two different bonding agents: F2000 self-etching primer/adhesive (F2000SE group) and Single Bond (F2000SB group); Silux Plus was placed as a control using Single Bond (SiluxSB group). Thirty restorations of each material/dentin adhesive combination were placed. All restorations were evaluated at baseline and annually for three years using a modified USPHS scale. At the end of the three-year recall, Silux Plus had significantly better surface texture than F2000 (p<0.0001). In addition, marginal adaptation significantly worsened over time starting at one year, as compared with baseline, for all groups (p<0.0001). When anatomic form was compared between F2000 and Silux Plus, the p-value was 0.085, demonstrating that F2000 was slightly better than Silux Plus.
Likewise, when comparing marginal adaptation between the F2000SE and SiluxSB groups, the p-value was 0.064, demonstrating that F2000 with the self-etching primer had better margins than Silux Plus with Single Bond. No other differences were found among the groups.
Two-year Clinical Performance of Occlusal and Cervical Giomer Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
Beautifil showed promise as a direct-tooth colored fluoride releasing restorative material for occlusal and non-undercut cervical lesions. Reactmer showed mixed promise as a restorative material for cervical cavities.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the two-year clinical performance of two types of giomers (Beautifil, a surface reaction giomer and Reactmer, a full-reaction giomer), in occlusal (Class I) and cervical (Class V) cavities using the USPHS criteria. Forty-two cervical erosion and carious lesions were restored using Beautifil and Reactmer following manufacturer’s instructions. Twenty occlusal cavities were restored with Beautifil. Fifteen patients (mean age 35, ranging in age from 20 to 50 years) participated in the study. The success rate for cervical Beautifil restorations after two years was 80%, while the success rate for cervical Reactmer restorations was 71%. Occlusal Beautifil restorations had a 100% success rate.
Clinical Relevance:
Whether a fourth- or fifth-generation bonding system is used, Solitaire 2 can function successfully as a posterior restorative material, although the fourth-generation material showed a tendency to produce better performance than the fifth-generation material.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the clinical performance of a posterior resin composite used with a fourth- and fifth-generation bonding agent. Sixty-two Class I and II restorations were placed with half the restorations restored with Gluma Solid Bond (a fourth-generation bonding system, or total etch two-step system) and the other half restored with Gluma Comfort Bond and Desensitizer (a fifth-generation bonding system, or total etch one-step system). Solitaire 2 was used as the restorative material for all restorations. The bonding systems and resin composite were used according to the manufacturer’s instructions and all procedures were performed with rubber dam isolation. All restorations were evaluated at baseline, six months and one and two years. A modified USPHS scale was used to evaluate the restorations for marginal discoloration, recurrent caries, anatomic form, marginal adaptation and proximal contact. Statistical analysis revealed that at two years no significant differences were found between the two bonding agents. Overall, Solitaire 2 performed well clinically whether Gluma Solid Bond or Gluma Comfort Bond and Desensitizer was used. It was thus concluded that Solitaire 2 functions successfully when used as a posterior restorative material for at least two years.
Laboratory Research
Clinical Relevance:
The value of short- to medium-duration thermal stressing in the in vitro evaluation of resin composites remains questionable.
SUMMARY:
Thermocycling is commonly employed in laboratory studies to simulate the in vivo aging of restorative materials. However, there is little consistency in the regimens used, and some researchers have questioned the clinical relevance and, hence, the necessity of including thermal stressing in in vitro protocols. This study examined the effects of five thermal stressing regimens on the flexural and dentin bond strengths of a hybrid resin composite. Methods: For flexural strength tests, 95 rectangular specimens (15 mm x 2 mm x 2 mm) were fabricated using a stainless steel split mold, then light cured for 60 seconds. For bond strength tests, 75 caries-free molars were flattened occlusally to expose dentin, then polished through 600 grit SiC paper; dentin surfaces were etched, rinsed and blotted dry. A dentin adhesive was applied and light cured for 30 seconds; resin composite was condensed through a stainless steel split mold (4.3 mm diameter x 3.5 mm high), then light cured for 60 seconds. All specimens were stored in deionized water for 24 hours, then stressed for 100 hours according to one of five regimens: 1) cycled between 5°C and 55°C (9000 cycles; 20-second dwell time); 2) held at 5°C constant; 3) held at 22°C constant; 4) held at 55°C constant; 5) held at 5°C for 50 hours, then at 55°C for 50 hours. Flexural strengths were measured using an Instron 5500R and three-point bending apparatus at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. Shear bond strengths were measured using an MTS Bionix 200 at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. Results: ANOVA revealed no significant differences in either flexural strength or shear bond strength among the five thermal regimens.
Hybrid Layer Thickness and Morphology: The Influence of Cavity Preparation With Er:YAG Laser
Clinical Relevance:
The thinner, irregular hybrid layer found when a cavity is prepared with a LASER may have a negative effect on bonding.
SUMMARY:
Dentinal surfaces prepared with Er:YAG laser have significantly different characteristics from those prepared with conventional instruments. Different hybrid layer morphologies and thicknesses occur, which may result in differences in the quality of restorations placed on dentinal surfaces prepared with a diamond bur when compared with using an Er:YAG Laser. This study compared the hybrid layer thickness and morphology formed utilizing Scotchbond Multipurpose Plus (SBMP) on dentin prepared with a diamond bur in a high speed handpiece and dentin prepared with an Er:YAG laser. Flat dentin surfaces obtained from five human teeth were treated with the two methods and then with the dentin adhesive system according to the manufacturer’s instructions. After a layer of composite was applied, the specimens were sectioned, flattened, polished and prepared for SEM observation. Ten different measurements of hybrid layer thickness were obtained along the bonded surface in each specimen. Results showed that SBMP produced a 3.43 ± 0.75 µm hybrid layer in dentin prepared with a diamond bur. This hybrid layer was regular and constantly found. In the laser group, the dentin adhesive system produced a 1.54 ± 0.35 µm hybrid layer that was very irregular and not found constantly. Statistical analysis of variance (p≤0.05) showed that there was a statistically significant difference between the groups. These data indicate that the Er:YAG laser, with parameters used in the experiment, is not a preparation method that allows for a thick hybrid layer formation, which is in opposition to using a diamond bur in a high speed turbine.
The Microtensile Bond Strength of Fuji IX Glass Ionomer Cement to Antibacterial Conditioned Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
One percent concentration antibacterial dentin conditioners can be left in situ without affecting the bond strength of GIC to dentin.
SUMMARY:
Introduction: Adding antibacterial agents to a dentin conditioner used for a glass ionomer cement (GIC) has been shown to be antibacterial; however, it is not known whether this antimicrobial conditioning agent affects the bond strength to dentin in situ. This study applied GIC to antibacterial conditioned dentin without rinsing and determined whether there is an affect on the material’s bond strength.
Materials and Methods: Chlorhexidine acetate (CX), benzalkonium chloride (BC) and cetrimide (CT) were added to Dentin Conditioner (DC) (GC Corp, Japan) at 1% and 5% concentrations. Molars were sectioned coronally to expose dentin, onto which 50 µl of the test conditioners was applied for 20 seconds with a gentle scrubbing action and the residual liquid was blotted dry, as would occur under “field” conditions when performing atraumatic restorative therapy. To serve as the control, the DC was left in situ and compared to the DC that was washed off. Proportioned Fuji IX GIC (GC Corp, Japan) was built-up on the prepared dentin surface and varnish was applied and stored for 24 hours. An annular saw was used to create sticks of GIC bonded to dentin, with a bonding area 1 mm2. After 24 hours, the specimens were tested to failure in a Universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute.
Results: Five percent CX-DC was not tested, as it formed a precipitate. Results in MPa: DC-not washed, 9.3 ± 2.4; DC-washed, 9.3 ± 2.5; 1%BC-DC, 8.8 ± 2.5; 1%CX-DC, 8.7 ± 2.7; 1%CT-DC, 8.2 ±1.7; 5%CT-DC, 8.1 ± 2.7; 5%BC-DC, 5.4 ± 1.0. One-way ANOVA showed that there was a significant difference between the test groups (p<0.05), and Tukey’s studentized range test showed that only 5% BC-dentin conditioner left in situ was significantly different from the other groups.
Conclusion: Under the conditions tested, only the 5% BC-DC left in situ affected the bond strength of Fuji IX to dentin.
Effect of Peroxide-based Bleaching Agents on Enamel Ultimate Tensile Strength
Clinical Relevance:
According to results of this in vitro study, the intrinsic strength of enamel can be affected after peroxide bleaching regimens; however, its in vivo effect must be further evaluated, since no clinical reports about bleached enamel fractures have been described.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effects of peroxide bleaching regimens on the ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of human enamel. A resin composite block was built-up on the bonded occlusal surface of 14 extracted, sound, erupted third molars to enable posterior preparation for the microtensile test. The bonded teeth were serially sectioned in a buccal-lingual direction into approximately 0.7-mm thick slices. Each slice was trimmed with a fine diamond bur to reduce the area of the buccal, internal slope of the cusps to a dumb-bell shape with a cross-sectional area of less than 1 mm2. The samples were randomly divided into seven groups (n=10): unbleached control group and bleached groups treated with six bleaching regimens. The specimens were tested in tension at 0.5 mm/minute and the data were analyzed by ANOVA and Tukey test.
Specimens from the control group presented 51.3 ± 8.6 MPa, while the UTS of bleached enamel ranged from 22.0 ± 5.6 to 36.3 ± 9.1 MPa. All bleaching procedures significantly reduced enamel UTS (p<0.05). Differences were also observed among treatments. The results suggested that bleaching regimens can significantly reduce enamel UTS.
Liner and Light Exposure: Effect on In-Vitro Class V Microleakage
Clinical Relevance:
The results of this study suggest that ramp and pulse-delay light curing methods did not improve marginal sealing compared to the conventional technique. The reduced microleakage of glass ionomer/resin restorations make it a positive restorative option, while high intensity light curing increased microleakage in cavities with dentin margins.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the influence of different glass ionomer liners and curing methods on microleakage of resin composite restorations. Class V root preparations were made in 120 bovine incisors randomly divided into 12 groups according to liner and curing method. The resin composite system (Single Bond + Z100) was inserted and polymerized in one increment in all groups. Cavity preparations were either not lined (control), lined with a resin modified glass-ionomer cement (Vitrebond) or a conventional glass-ionomer cement (Ketac Bond). The restorations were light-cured using one of four curing methods. The teeth were thermocycled and immersed in 0.5% basic fuchsin, sectioned, and dye penetration was measured (Image Tool). No significant difference in leakage among conventional, ramp or pulse-delay methods was seen. High intensity light groups showed significantly greater penetration compared to other curing methods. No significant difference existed in marginal leakage between liners, but microleakage was significantly higher in groups restored using no liner. No relationship between lining technique and light curing method was observed. The use of glass ionomer liners reduced microleakage, while high intensity light curing produced the greatest dye penetration.
Clinical Relevance:
During root canal treatment, maintaining partially removed amalgam or composite permanent restorations does not seem to cause a problem with achieving a marginal seal.
SUMMARY:
Aim: This study evaluated microleakage at the interface between various temporary restorative materials and existing amalgam or composite restorations, and dental tissues in previously restored teeth after partial removal of the restoration.
Materials and Methods: The distal half of amalgam (Ag) and composite restorations (Co) in 45 teeth were removed, then filled with temporary restorative materials (IRM, Coltosol and CLIP). After thermal cycling, microleakage was measured microscopically as the penetration of basic fuchsine according to a four-unit-scale: The data were evaluated with Friedman and Kruskal-Wallis tests using Bonferroni correction (p<0.05).
Results: In almost all groups except the Co-IRM and Ag-CLIP interface, lower microleakage values were observed in temporary restoration-permanent restoration interfaces compared to temporary restoration-tooth interfaces. For the Ag and Co groups except for the Ag-IRM-b interfaces, the highest microleakage values were observed with IRM for b and c interfaces followed by Coltosol and CLIP. Interestingly, although CLIP was a temporary restoration, CLIP-tooth interface (Ag-CLIP-c) values were lower than amalgam-tooth interface (Ag-CLIP-a) values.
Conclusions: CLIP provided a better seal against microleakage at amalgam and especially composite interfaces. This material also provided a better seal against microleakage at the tooth tissue interface. The use of a resin based temporary restorative material over partially removed resin composite restorations could be beneficial in achieving better resistance to marginal leakage.
Within the limitations of this study, maintaining partially removed permanent restorations does not seem to cause a problem with achieving marginal seal.
Factors Affecting Microleakage of a Packable Resin Composite: An In Vitro Study
Clinical Relevance:
Different adhesive systems may not equally affect microleakage of a packable resin composite. When the self-etching adhesive Prompt L-Pop was selected as a bonding agent, the flowable resin composite reduced microleakage. However, cavity preparation techniques had no effect on microleakage of the packable resin composite used in this study.
SUMMARY:
This study was designed to determine the effects of three factors on the microleakage of a packable resin composite: different adhesive systems (single-step self-etching adhesive or total-etch and one-bottle adhesive), the use of a flowable resin composite (as a liner) and the different techniques of cavity preparation. Sixty extracted non-carious human first and second molars were selected and randomly divided into six groups. Cervical cavities were prepared using the conventional technique on the distal sides and the air-abrasive technique was used on the mesial sides of the teeth. The experimental groups were restored with PQ1 + SureFil or Prompt L-Pop + SureFil with or without PermaFlo. In the control groups, only SureFil was used on 10 teeth and PermaFlo + SureFil was applied on the remaining 10 teeth. The restored teeth were stored in 100% humidity at 37°C for 24 hours and thermocycled between 5°C and 55°C for 100 cycles. Each tooth was immersed in India ink for 48 hours, then sectioned. Dye penetration at the occlusal and gingival margins was scored by two independent operators. The data were statistically analyzed to assess the differences between the test and control groups. No significant differences among the adhesives in terms of the occlusal margins of the cavities were observed. However, PQ1 led to less microleakage compared to Prompt L-Pop at the gingival margins (p<0.0062). When flowable resin composite was used with Prompt L-Pop, microleakage was reduced (p<0.0125). However, no significant difference was observed between the two cavity preparation techniques (p>0.0125).
Measurement of Linear Polymerization Contraction Using Digital Laser Interferometry
Clinical Relevance:
Digital holographic interferometry as a new method of polymerization shrinkage measurement presents new insights into the setting of composite material during polymerization with curing lights of different light intensity. Based on this, the clinican should be able to choose an adequate curing light for resin composite polymerization that can maximally compensate its negative influence on polymerization shrinkage.
SUMMARY:
Polymerization shrinkage is an unavoidable consequence of resin composite photopolymerization and is one of the most important factors in determining the clinical quality and durability of composite filling. Many different methods of measuring polymerization shrinkage are described in the literature. Digital laser interferometry is a method that enables direct observation of polymerization shrinkage in real time. This study used the digital holographic interferometry method to measure the linear polymerization contraction of composite materials: Tetric Ceram (Vivadent), Spectrum TPH (Dentsply) and Valux Plus (3M Dental Products) polymerized with three different curing modes of the Elipar Trilight (ESPE) halogen curing unit. The highest polymerization contraction was recorded by “standard mode” (ETS) (1.24±2.66% lin), and the lowest by “medium mode” (ETM) (0.40±0.41% lin) during 40 second illumination. The “exponentional mode” (ETE) showed the highest expansion during the first 10 seconds of illumination. Curing units with initial low intensity enable better inner adaptation of composite material, preventing the detachment of material from dentin during polymerization and avoiding the negative consequences of polymerization shrinkage.
Clinical Relevance:
The data suggests that the bonding mechanism of the adhesive system used in this study can be influenced by NaOCl treatment on the etched dentin surface. Besides their effect and ability to remove organic substrates from adherent dentin, the penetration ability of adhesive resin should be considered.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of NaOCl treatment of etched air-dried dentin on the bond strength and state of monomer penetration. Ten percent NaOCl was applied after rinsing the etchant and air drying the dentin surface. Wet bonded, untreated teeth were used as a control. The resin composite was bonded and stored in 37°C water for 24 hours, then shear tested. One-way ANOVA, followed by the Duncan test, was done. For Raman microscopy, bonded specimens were cut parallel to the dentinal tubules and polished. Raman spectra were successively recorded along lines perpendicular to the dentin-adhesive interface. The decreased bond strengths found with air-dried dentin increased with NaOCl treatment, but the highest bond strength was obtained with wet bonding. From Raman spectroscopy, the widths of demineralized dentin decreased with prolonged NaOCl treatment time. The patterns of gradual transition of components differed among the groups.
Clinical Relevance:
The data suggests that the dentin bond strengths of self-etching primer systems can be influenced by contamination of metal conditioners. Care should be taken when restoring secondary caries at a crown margin when self-etching primer systems, combined with metal conditioners, are used.
SUMMARY:
Carious lesions around crown margins sometimes lead to failure of fixed prosthodontics. This study examined the influence of metal conditioner application on a dentin surface prior to bonding procedures, using two-step self-etching primer systems. Commercially available metal conditioners and self-etching primer dentin bonding systems were used. Bovine mandibular incisors were mounted in self-curing resin, and the facial dentin surfaces were ground wet on 600-grit SiC paper. The metal primers were applied on the dentin surface followed by bonding procedures with four different types of self-etching primer systems. The resin composites were condensed into a mold on the dentin surface and light activated. Ten specimens per test group were stored in 37°C water for 24 hours; they were then shear tested at a crosshead speed of 1.0 mm/minute. Two-way ANOVA and Tukey’s HSD tests were done. When the metal conditioners were applied on dentin surfaces before bonding procedures, there was a tendency for decreased dentin bond strengths compared to those obtained with the controls. This tendency differed among the combinations of metal conditioners and self-etching primer systems used. Appropriate surface treatments are required to get optimum bond strengths with the use of technique sensitive bonding systems combined with metal conditioners.
Clinical Relevance:
The use of fluoride-releasing restorative materials is important in inhibiting the occurrence of secondary carious lesions, especially in patients who are at high risk and/or high caries activity. Considering the commercial availability of these restorative materials, a comparative evaluation of their cariostatic action is required.
SUMMARY:
Considering that caries around restorations is a serious problem in dentistry, and some restorative materials with fluoride may be important in inhibiting these lesions, this research is aimed at performing an in vitro evaluation of the cariostatic action of some esthetic restorative materials. Standardized cavities were prepared in the center of either intact blocks of bovine enamel or with bovine teeth containing early artificial carious lesions. The specimens were restored with a high viscosity glass ionomer cement (Molar Ketac), a resin-modified glass ionomer cement (Vitremer), a polyacid-modified resin composite (Dyract AP) and a conventional resin composite (Z-250). In addition to the restored specimens, four corresponding control groups were evaluated. All groups, except for two control groups, were subjected to a demineralization/remineralization cycling model for 14 days, simulating a situation of severe cariogenic challenge. The blocks were then longitudinally sectioned through the restorations. Mineral loss was evaluated in these specimens using the Knoop microhardness profiles in longitudinal sections at three different distances of the cavities and at eight distinct depths in relation to the external enamel surface. Statistical analysis of the results showed significant differences (p<0.05) among the groups, although none of the study materials completely inhibited creation of the lesions. Vitremer demonstrated the best cariostatic action in intact bovine enamel. Ketac Molar, in intact or demineralized enamel, and Vitremer, in demineralized enamel, presented intermediate cariostatic potential. Z-250 and Dyract AP did not demonstrate any cariostatic effect. The data suggests that glass ionomer cements demonstrated better cariostatic action compared to the other restorative materials.
Clinical Relevance:
In this study, the type of organic solvent and dentin moisture had an influence on bond strength to dentin. The results showed that the application of a total-etch, ethanol-based adhesive system to moist dentin results in higher bond strengths.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of organic solvent (acetone or ethanol) on the microtensile bond strengths (MTBS) of an adhesive system applied to dry and moist dentin. Sixteen extracted human third molars were ground to expose a flat occlusal dentin surface and acid etched for 20 seconds (20% phosphoric acid gel, Gluma Etch 20 Gel, Heraeus/Kulzer). After rinsing the acid etchant, an ethanol-based one-bottle adhesive system was applied to the mesial half of the occlusal dentin surface. An acetone-based, one-bottle adhesive system was applied to the distal half of the ground dentin surface. The teeth were randomly assigned to groups. In Group 1, the etched dentin was thoroughly air dried and an ethanol-based one-bottle adhesive system was applied (Gluma Comfort Bond, Heraeus/Kulzer) (GCB). In Group 2, the etched dentin was thoroughly air dried and an acetone-based one-bottle adhesive system was applied (Gluma One Bond, Heraeus/Kulzer)(GOB). In Group 3, excess moisture was removed after acid etching, leaving a moist dentin surface and a one-bottle ethanol-based adhesive was applied (Gluma Comfort Bond). In Group 4, excess moisture was removed after acid etching, leaving a moist dentin surface and an acetone-based adhesive was applied (Gluma One Bond). A hybrid resin composite (Venus, Heraeus/Kulzer) was applied to the bonded surface in four 1-mm increments and light cured according to manufacturer’s directions. The specimens were then sectioned with a slow-speed diamond saw in two perpendicular directions to obtain sticks with a cross-section of 0.5 ± 0.05 mm2. The microtensile bond strength (MTBS) test was performed with a Bencor device in an Instron machine at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/minute. The data were subjected to a two-way ANOVA and Scheffé Post hoc test (p<0.05). The experimental MTBS measured for dry dentin were Group 1=37.0±10.6 and Group 2=34.7±9.0 in MPa (mean ±SD); and on moist dentin, Group 3=50.7±11.0 and Group 4=38.5±10.5 in MPa (mean ±SD). The ethanol based adhesives resulted in higher MTBS than acetone-based adhesive (p<0.008) and bonding to moist dentin resulted in higher MTBS (p<0.001). GCB applied on moist dentin resulted in statistically higher bond strengths than the other groups. The highest MTBS were achieved with the use of an ethanol-based adhesive to moist dentin.
The Shear Bond Strength Between Luting Cements and Zirconia Ceramics After Two Pre-treatments
Clinical Relevance:
The luting cements tested exhibited considerable differences with regard to their shear strengths following conditioning. This fact should be considered when clinically employing these agents in order to improve the adhesive properties of dental restorations.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the shear-bond strength of 11 luting cements from different material classes to manufactured pre-treated zirconia ceramics (Lava: 97% ZrO2, stabilized with 3% Y2O3). In addition, the influence of the curing method on shear-bond strength was investigated. The cements examined were one zinc-phosphate cement (Fleck’s zinc cement), two standard glass-ionomer cements (Fuji I, Ketac-Cem), three resin-modified glass-ionomer cements (Fuji Plus, Fuji Cem, RelyX Luting), four standard resin cements (RelyX ARC, Panavia F, Variolink II, Compolute) and one self-adhesive universal resin cement (RelyX Unicem). The ceramic surface was sandblasted with 100-µm alumina or tribochemically coated with silica. After bonding procedure, one group was tested after 30 minutes (Time I), the other group was stored in distilled water at 37°C for 14 days and subsequently thermocycled 1000 times (Time II). Statistical analysis was performed by multifactorial ANOVA models with interactions. For multiple pairwise comparisons, the Tukey method was used. After sandblasting, the highest shear-bond strength was obtained for the self-adhesive universal resin cement at 9.7 MPa (Time I) and 12.7 MPa (Time II), respectively. When using the Rocatec system, the highest values were found for one of the resin cements at 15.0 MPa (Time I) and for the self-adhesive universal resin cement at 19.9 MPa (Time II).
Clinical Relevance:
Employing post-curing methods on conventional composites resulted in better mechanical properties that were comparable or superior to laboratory resin, enabling them to be used in indirect restorations and resulting in a significant reduction in final treatment costs.
SUMMARY:
This study determined the microhardness and diametral tensile strength of two hybrid resin composites submitted to conventional light curing, which were post-cured with different methods, and compared these data with the same data collected from one indirect resin composite. Two hybrid composites (TPH Spectrum and Filtek P60) and an indirect one (Solidex) were used. Conventional composites were polymerized with 1) conventional light curing for 40 seconds. Additional curing methods were applied with 2) laboratory multi-focal light curing for seven minutes, 3) microwave curing for five minutes at 500W, 4) oven curing for 15 minutes at 100°C, 5) autoclave curing for 15 minutes at 100°C and (6) were polymerized only with a laboratory light curing unit in three increments for three minutes and post-polymerized for seven minutes. The Solidex group was done following the manufacturers’ instructions only. Diametral tensile strength and Knoop hardness tests were applied for all groups of five samples. Data were compared using ANOVA, Tukey and Student t-tests (p<0.05). Post-curing methods increased the Knoop hardness and diametral tensile strength of conventional composites. In general, Filtek P60 showed higher hardness and diametral tensile strength values than TPH Spectrum resin. The Indirect resin composite showed poorer mechanical properties than conventional composites.
Clinical Technique/Case Report
Restoring Erosion Associated with Gastroesophageal Reflux Using Direct Resins: Case Report
Clinical Relevance:
Gastroesophageal reflux disease is a systemic condition that can have an impact on the oral health by compromising tooth integrity, function and esthetics. Appropriate diagnostic and clinical management, using a conservative direct technique with resin composite is described in this article.
SUMMARY:
Gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is a condition where stomach acids are chronically regurgitated into the esophagus and oral cavity, resulting in pathology, such as esophagitis, varices or ulcers. Continual exposure of the teeth to these acids can also cause severe dental erosion. This condition frequently is asymptomatic, and the only evident sign may be the irreversible erosion of tooth structure. The dentist often is the first health care professional to identify the affected dentition. Knowledge of this cause and effect relationship between GERD and dental erosion will better prepare the practitioner to refer patients for appropriate diagnosis and treatment of the underlying medical condition and provide treatment for the affected teeth. This article presents a case report where dental erosion was present due to GERD. After management of the disease with medication, dental treatment of the eroded dentition is described, including diagnosis, treatment planning and restorative reconstruction.
Immediate Esthetic Management of a Catastrophically Fractured Anterior
Clinical Relevance:
This technique presents a method for the expeditious management of a catastrophically fractured anterior tooth.
INTRODUCTION:
The patient who arrives at the end of the workday with a catastrophic fracture of a tooth presents both an esthetic and time management challenge to the practitioner. The great majority of these cases will be cuspal fractures of posterior teeth that can usually be addressed by the simple application of glass ionomer cement, since treatment would not involve an esthetically sensitive area (Carroll, 1999). When an anterior tooth is involved, there is often sufficient tooth structure remaining to reattach the fractured segment (Farik & others, 2002; Garcia-Ballesta & others, 2001; Small, 1996; Maia & others, 2003; Vissichelli, 1996). However, a patient will occasionally present with a significant portion or all of the clinical crown missing. Traditional temporary treatment options can be time consuming and unpredictable (Maia & others, 2003; John, Prabhu & Munshi, 1998). Techniques that have been previously described include fabrication of a composite post and core/crown (Howell, 2003), a modification of Croll and Helpin’s (2002) technique of using orthodontic wire and compomer to act as a temporary splint (or, in this case, a fixed partial denture), fabrication of an interim removable partial denture, bonding of a natural tooth pontic and the use of a thermoplastic retainer with composite to replace the missing tooth structure (Blake, Garvey & Fleming, 1998). This paper presents a technique for the immediate interim restoration of a catastrophically fractured maxillary anterior tooth that is fast, non-invasive, esthetic and allows for some limited function without fear of aspiration of tenuously bonded temporary restorative materials.
Awards
Academy of Operative Dentistry
Dr James B Summitt
Academy of Operative Dentistry
Dr Stephen C Bayne
Recommendations for Clinical Practice
Reasons for Replacement of Restorations
Introduction:
Surveys of the time spent on various procedures in general dental practice
show that restorative dentistry, including caries diagnosis and preventive measures, comprises the
major workload (Eklund, 1999; Gilbert, 2004). Non-implant restorative procedures alone represent almost
60% of treatment time in the US and, together with diagnostic and preventive measures, they comprise
about 70% (Gilbert, 2004). Practice-based studies have shown that replacement of restorations involves
from 50% to 80% of all restorative work done in general dental practice (Mjör, 1981; Tveit & Espelid,
1986; Klausner, Green & Charbeneau, 1987; Qvist, Qvist & Mjör, 1990a,b; Mjör & Qvist, 1997; Burke &
others, 1999; Mjör, Moorhead & Dahl, 2000b; Mjör & others, 2002). Thus, “replacement
therapy” constitutes a major part of general dental practice. A number of determining elements
effect the replacement rate of restorations, including patient, material and clinician factors.
Detailed, practice-based, longitudinal studies on the selection of restorative materials, reasons for replacement and longevity of restorations in the primary dentition have recently been published (Qvist & others, 2004a,b; Qvist, Manscher & Teglers, 2004c). This review will be limited to restorations in the permanent teeth of adults and will focus on composite and amalgam restorations, because they are the most frequently used restorations.
Clinical Research
Comparative Study of the Effects of Two Bleaching Agents on Oral Microbiota
Clinical Relevance:
While being a simple and effective procedure for achieving dental
aestetics, 10% carbamide peroxide and 7.5% hydrogen peroxide agents do not provide changes in the
Streptococcus mutans counts during bleaching procedures.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the in vivo effects of bleaching agents containing 10%
carbamide peroxide (Platinum/Colgate) or 7.5% hydrogen peroxide (Day White 2Z/Discus Dental) on
mutans Streptococcus during dental bleaching. The products were applied on 30 volunteers who needed
dental bleaching. In each volunteer, one of the two bleaching agents was used on both dental arches
one hour a day for three weeks. Analysis of the bacterial counts was made by collecting saliva
before (baseline values), during (7 and 21 days) bleaching treatments and 14 days post-treatment.
The Friedman non-parametric analysis (a=0.05) found no differences in micro-organism counts at
different times for each group for both agents (p>0.05). The Mann Whitney non-parametric test
(a=0.05) showed no differences in micro-organism counts for both agents (p>0.05). Different
bleaching agents did not change the oral cavity mutans Streptococcus counts.
Clinical Relevance:
The use of acid etching or a self-etching primer for the minimum
specified time is not, alone, sufficient to retain resin restorations of unprepared Class V lesions.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the clinical performance of unprepared Class V resin
composites, placed using a self-etching primer and a single-bottle adhesive, over a period of 18
months. Thirty-eight pairs of restorations of Renew hybrid resin composite (BISCO, Inc) were
placed using adhesives from the same manufacturer in caries-free cer-vical erosion/abfraction
lesions. Based on insensitivity to air, the dentin in 76% of these lesions was considered to be
sclerotic. The restorations were placed without abrasion of tooth surfaces, except for cleaning
with plain pumice. One of each pair was placed using Tyrian, a self-etching primer and the other
was placed using One-Step, a single-bottle adhesive placed after acid etching. Both the etchant
and self-etching primer were applied for 20 seconds. The restorations were clinically evaluated at
baseline, 6, 12 and 18 months, using modified Ryge/USPHS criteria. For both adhesives, very low
retention of 50% to 56% of the restorations was observed over 18 months, leading to the conclusion
that tooth surfaces must receive some additional treatment prior to restoration with these
adhesives. No statistically significant difference (p=0.75) between the two adhesives was observed
in overall performance, and dentinal sclerosis and axial depth did not appear to be important
factors in the study.
Laboratory Research
Clinical Relevance:
The application of Micro Prime and Gluma Desensitizer to
caries-affected dentin showed no negative effect on bond strength. Therefore, they can be used as
desensitizing and antibacterial agents after caries removal.
SUMMARY:
A self-etching dentin adhesive was evaluated for its ability to bond to
caries-affected and sound dentin after applying three desensitizers to the gingival walls. Sixty
extracted human molars, with approximal dentin caries, were cut horizontally on the long axis of
the tooth through caries-affected gingival walls. Carious dentin was removed with SiC paper by
means of a caries detector to expose caries-affected dentin. The molars were randomly assigned to
four groups: control and three experimental groups—Micro Prime, Glauma Desentizer and
Cervitec. Desensitizers were applied to the dentinal surfaces according to manufacturers’
instructions. A resin composite was bonded to both the caries-affected and sound dentin of each
tooth using a bonding system and plastic rings. The restoration was debonded by shear bond
strength. The application of Micro Prime and Gluma Desensitizer to caries-affected dentin did not
show any effect on bond strength testing. However, Cervitec caused a decrease in bond strength to
caries-affected dentin. The effect of desensitizers on the bond strength of the self-etch bonding
agent to caries-affected dentin changed according to the chemical composition of the materials.
Desensitizer application on sound dentin is recommended with self-etch bonding systems.
Color and Translucency of A2 Shade Resin Composites After Curing, Polishing and Thermocycling
Clinical Relevance:
Color changes from pre-cure to post-cure shades were perceptible in
all composites studied (∆E*ab>3.8), and polishing caused perceptible color changes in some
composites (∆E*ab=1.9-4.5). This study supports the clinical practice of curing a small amount
of composites in the tooth to select the desired shade before esthetic restorative procedures.
SUMMARY:
This study determined the differences in values and changes of color and
translucency of eight brands of A2 shade resin composites after curing, polishing and thermocycling
(TC). The color of specimens 10-mm in diameter and 2-mm thick was measured on a reflection
spectrophotometer with SCE geometry under D65 illumination over a white and black background.
Measurements were obtained before curing, after curing, after polishing and after TC. The color
change (∆E*ab), translucency parameter (TP) and contrast ratio (CR) were then compared. The
range of ∆E*ab after curing was 3.8 to 10.2 (average ∆E*ab for the eight composites
= 6.4), which was deemed perceptible to the observer. Polishing caused ∆E*ab of 1.9 to 4.5,
which was perceptible in five of the eight composites. After 2,000 TC, ∆E*ab was 0.4 to 1.3.
TP values tended to increase after curing and decrease after TC (range before curing was 7.1 to
17.2). Changes in TP values after curing were statistically significant in all composites (p<0.05).
Changes in CR values were similar to the translucency changes in TP. Though the composite shades
were all designated as A2, color coordinates, TP and CR values, changes in color and translucency
after curing, polishing and thermocycling varied by brand.
Clinical Relevance:
The polymerization behavior of dual-cured core build-up resin
composites is strongly material-related. None of the materials can be efficiently polymerized in terms
of the remaining C=C bonds in regions of restorations with no direct light accessibility.
SUMMARY:
This study measured the degree of remaining C=C bonds (RDB), linear
polymerization shrinkage (LPS) and polymerization stresses (PS) of dual-cured resin composite
build-up materials using a variety of light exposure scenarios.
Four commercially available materials were used: Bis-Core, FluoroCore, Build-it! and Permalute. The RDB was measured using FTIR spectroscopy, and custom-made devices were used to measure LPS and PS values. Data were obtained using three different modes of photo-activation: NLC (No Light-Curing); ILC (Immediate Light-Curing, where 60 second light-curing was applied at the start of the observation period); and DLC (Delayed Light-Curing, where 60-second light-curing was applied 10 minutes from the start of the observation period). Statistical evaluation of the data at the end of the 13-minute observation period was performed with two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), Tukey’s Studentized Range (HSD) Test (p=0.05) and simple linear regression. Differences in the development of LPS and PS during the 13 minutes were studied using mathematical calculus.
Bis-Core presented the highest RDB and Permalute the lowest when ILC was applied, while no differences were found between Build-it! and FluoroCore and NLC and DLC increased RDB for FluoroCore and Permalute compared to ILC; whereas, no differences were noted for Build-it! and Bis-Core. Using DLC, a decrease in RDB was found only for Build-it!
Permalute and Bis-Core presented the highest and lowest LPS and PS after ILC, accordingly. Higher LPS and PS were recorded for Build-it! compared to Fluorocore in the ILC group.
FluoroCore and Permalute exhibited a reduction in LPS and PS using NLC relative to ILC. No differences in LPS and PS values were detected for the materials Bis-Core and Build-it! when subjected to NLC or DLC, compared to ILC.
Simple linear regression showed that only the two polymerization shrinkage properties studied were highly correlated (LPS-PS r2=0.85). The RDB rate was not correlated with either polymerization shrinkage properties (RDB-LPS r2=0.40; RDB-PS r2=0.57). A study of the evolution of the real-time curves of percentage values of LPS and PS showed that these properties evolved in a similar exponential mode and that, most often, there was a delay in the development of PS.
Effects of Dentin Disinfectants on the Shear Bond Strength of All-ceramics to Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
Both Consepsis and Tubulicid Red can be safely used to prevent the
potential risk of complications resulting from bacterial activity without affecting the bond strength
of IPS Empress 2 restorations clinical luting procedures.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the effect of dentin disinfectants on the shear bond
strength of all-ceramic restorations luted with two different dual-polymerizing systems to dentin.
Dentin disinfectants chlorhexidine gluconate-based Concepsis and benzalkonium chloride-based
Tubulicid Red were applied in combination with Variolink 2 and Resilute. The buccal surfaces of
non-carious extracted human premolars were flattened to expose dentin and subsequently polished
with 600-grit wet silicon carbide paper. Each dual-polymerizing luting system had two test groups
and a control group. Dentin from the test groups was first treated with dentin disinfectants, then
the all-ceramic restorations were luted with dual polymerizing systems. The dentin without
disinfectant application and ceramic restoration was used as a control. After the all-ceramic
samples were luted to all treated surfaces, the specimens were thermocycled and tested for shear
bond strength until failure. Analysis of the fractured dentin surfaces was performed using Optical
Microscope-Nikon ECLIPSE ME 600 (Nikon Co, Tokyo, Japan) at between 10x and 1000x magnifications
and the images were analyzed with Image Analyzer LUCIA 4.21 (Nikon Co). The data were analyzed
with one-way ANOVA and Duncan test at a significance level of p<0.05. Application of the two
dentin disinfectants increased the shear bond strength of both the Variolink 2 and Resilute
systems, but this increase was statistically significant only in Tubulicid Red treated specimens
(p<0.05). Surface analysis showed that all the specimens showed the adhesive failure mode between
the dentin and composite luting agent interface.
Clinical Relevance:
The second generation LED is an improvement over the first generation
LED. Despite its reported efficiency in composite curing, the second generation LED performs as well
as the QTH system for composite curing and does not produce more rapid composite polymerization
compared to the QTH unit.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effectiveness of second generation light emitting
diode (2ndLED) units in composite curing. In order to compare their effectiveness with that of
conventional quartz tungsten halogen light curing units (QTH) and first generation LEDs (1stLED),
the amount of linear polymerization shrinkage, polymerization speed and microhardness were
measured. Linear polymerization shrinkage was measured every 0.5-0.55 seconds for 60 seconds when
composite specimens (Z250, 3M ESPE Dental Products, St Paul, MN, USA) were light cured with five
different light sources: XL 3000 (QTH, 3M ESPE Dental Products), Elipar FreeLight 2 (2ndLED, 3M
ESPE Dental Products), Ultra-Lume LED2 (2ndLED, Ultradent Products, South Jordan, UT, USA), Elipar
FreeLight (1stLED, 3M ESPE Dental Products) and experimental product X (1stLED, Biomedisys, Seoul,
Korea). The amount of linear polymerization shrinkage in 60 seconds and the speed of polymerization
shrinkage in the first 15 seconds were measured for the different lighting units. The amount of
polymerization was compared with one-way ANOVA using Tukey at the 95% confidence level. In order
to compare the speed of polymerization, the peak time (PT) showing the highest speed of
polymerization and maximum speed of polymerization (Smax) were determined from the data and
compared using one-way ANOVA with Tukey at the 95% confidence level for each material.
Shear Bond Strength of Tooth-colored Indirect Restorations Bonded to Coronal and Cervical Enamel
Clinical Relevance:
The cervical enamel region showed lower bond strengths of bonded
indirect restoratives than the mid-coronal enamel region.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the shear bond strength of resin inlays bonded with
resin cement to cervical and mid-coronal enamel. Two regions of enamel, cervical and mid-coronal,
were chosen from the buccal surface of extracted molars. Composite “inlays” (Estenia,
Kuraray Medical Inc) were fabricated indirectly and cemented with a dual-cured resin cement
(Panavia Fluoro Cement II, Kuraray Medical Inc). The resin cement was cured with or without light
irradiation for 30 seconds. After 24-hours or one-week’s storage in 37°C water, the bonded
inlays were subjected to a microshear bond test, whereby a shear force was applied to the inlays
at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute. The data were statistically analyzed using ANOVA and
Fisher’s PLSD test, with significance defined as p<0.05. Observations using confocal laser
scanning microscopy were also performed after debonding the specimens. The light-cure method
showed significantly higher bond strengths to both enamel regions compared with self-cure,
especially at 24 hours (p<0.05). However, bond strength of the self-cured resin cement
significantly improved after one week’s storage (p<0.05; cervical enamel: p=0.022,
mid-coronal enamel: p=0.0024). The cervical enamel showed significantly lower bonding than
mid-coronal enamel (p<0.05), except for the self-cured specimens at 24 hours. Light curing of
resin cement is a better choice than self-curing for luting of indirect restorations. The bond
strength of indirect restorations to cervical enamel was lower than mid-coronal enamel.
Post-gel Polymerization Shrinkage Associated with Different Light Curing Regimens
Clinical Relevance:
The use of pulse delay and soft-start regimens significantly decreased
post-gel polymerization shrinkage when compared to standard continuous cure.
SUMMARY:
This study compared post-gel polymerization shrinkage associated with five
different light curing regimens of similar light energy density. A light-cure unit (VIP, BISCO)
that allowed for independent command over time and intensity was used. The five regimens
investigated were pulse delay (PD), soft-start (SS); pulse cure (PC), turbo cure (TC) and standard
continuous cure (C) [control]. With the exception of TC, the light energy density for all curing
regimens was fixed at 16 J/cm2. A strain-monitoring device and test configuration were used to
measure the linear polymerization shrinkage of 2-mm thick com-posite specimens (Z100, 3M ESPE)
during and post-light polymerization up to 60 minutes. Five samples were made for each curing
mode. The results were analyzed using ANOVA/Scheffee’s post-hoc test at significance level
0.05. Post-gel shrinkage ranged from 0.30% to 0.46 % at 60 minutes. The use of PD resulted in
significantly lower shrinkage compared to PC, TC, SS and C. Shrinkage associated with SS was, in
general, significantly lower than C. No significant difference in shrinkage was observed between
PC, TC and C at all time intervals. The use of pulse delay and soft-start regimens decreased
post-gel polymerization shrinkage.
Clinical Relevance:
The morphology of the dentin/self-etch bonding system/composite
interface enables a good seal to be obtained with most self-etching adhesives currently in use.
Clinically, this may have an influence on the risk of post-operative sensitivity. Most acid primers
did not systematically provide the best interfaces.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated micromorphological differences in the hybridized
complex formed using 10 commercially available self-etch bonding systems. In addition, the
influence of the pH of the primer of these adhesives was evaluated. The self-etching systems
tested were AdheSE, Adper Prompt L-Pop, Clearfil SE Bond, Etch&Prime 3.0 (Degussa, Germany),
Prime & Bond NT Non Rinse Conditioner (Dentsply, Konstanz, Germany), One-Up Bond F, OptiBond Solo
Plus Self Etch, Prompt L-Pop and Xeno III.
One hundred non-carious human third molars were used. The teeth were divided into two groups of 50 and prepared for evaluation by optical microscopy or scanning electron microscopy. The specimens in each group were further divided into 10 subgroups of five specimens each to evaluate the 10 bonding systems. The pH of the primers of the bonding systems was measured. The results demonstrated morphological differences at the interface, depending on adhesive composition. The differences mainly concerned thickness of the hybrid layer, the absence or presence of microscopic voids at the adhesive-composite interface and whether the dentinal tubuli were completely sealed. The pH was not the determining factor conditioning the action of the self-etching adhesives.
Enamel Bond Strengths of Pairs of Adhesives from the Same Manufacturer
Clinical Relevance:
Some total-etch adhesives bond more effectively to enamel than the
corresponding self-etch adhesives from the same manufacturer. For self-etch adhesives, roughening
enamel with a diamond bur resulted in a tendency toward higher bond strengths.
SUMMARY:
Most manufacturers of dental adhesives have both a total-etch adhesive and a
simplified self-etching adhesive available on the market. This study measured the enamel
microtensile bond strengths of five pairs of enamel adhesives as a function of enamel roughness.
The proximal surfaces of 25 extracted mandibular molars were sectioned with a diamond saw to
obtain 50 enamel rectangles with an area of 8x4 mm2. The enamel rectangles were divided in two
equal parts via a groove to obtain 4x4 mm2 squared bonding surfaces. One half was roughened with a
coarse diamond bur under water for five seconds, while the other half was kept intact. The enamel
surfaces were randomly assigned to 10 enamel adhesives grouped into five pairs. Each pair included
one self-etch adhesive and one total-etch adhesive from the same manufacturer: Adper Prompt and
Adper Single Bond (PLP and SB, 3M ESPE); AdheSE and Excite (ADH and EXC, Ivoclar Vivadent);
OptiBond Solo Plus SE and OptiBond Solo Plus (OPTSE and OPT, Kerr); Tyrian SPE/One-Step Plus and
One-Step (TYR and OST, BISCO, Inc); Xeno III and Prime&Bond NT (XEN and PBNT, Dentsply). The
adhesives were applied according to the manufacturers’ instructions. Buildups were
constructed with Filtek Z250 (3M ESPE). The specimens were sectioned in sticks with a cross
section of 0.8±0.2 mm2 and tested to failure in tension at a crosshead speed of 1 mm/minute.
Two-way ANOVA followed by Duncan’s post-hoc test at p<0.05 was computed. The highest mean
bond strengths were obtained with total-etch adhesives. For “roughened enamel,” three
pairs of materials had statistically different means in which the total-etch adhesive resulted in
statistically higher bond strengths (MPa) than the corresponding self-etch adhesive: EXC (36.6) >
ADH (23.0) at p<0.026; OPT (34.5) > OPTSE (25.3) at p<0.028; PBNT (36.6) > XEN (19.5) at p<0.0001.
For “intact enamel,” four pairs of materials resulted in statistically different means:
SB (31.7) > PLP (20.9) at p<0.049; EXC (37.9) > ADH (16.3) at p<0.0001; OST (30.1) > TYR (18.0);
PBNT (43.8) > XEN (16.0) at p<0.0001. When the same adhesive was compared on intact vs roughened
enamel, all the self-etch materials resulted in lower bond strengths on intact enamel, but this
difference was only significant for TYR (p<0.042) and ADH (p<0.050). For total-etch materials,
only OPT resulted in statistically lower bond strengths when applied on intact enamel (p<0.011).
Clinical Relevance:
The use of fiber posts for the restoration of endodontically treated
teeth has increased tremendously over the last few years. However, the choice of an adhesive system
that provides a reliable, long-lasting bonding mechanism to root canal dentin is still unclear.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the bond strength of a light- and self-cured adhesive
system to different intraradicular dentin areas (cervical, middle and apical thirds). Twenty
single-rooted teeth were instrumented and their roots were prepared to receive a #2 translucent
fiber post (Light Post). The root canals were irrigated with 0.5% sodium hypochlorite for one
minute, rinsed with water and dried using paper tips. The teeth were divided into two groups
(n=10): Single Bond [SB] (light-cured) and Scotchbond Multi-Purpose Plus [SBMP] (self-cured). To
avoid polymerization of the materials through the root lateral walls, the teeth were placed in a
silicone mold and the adhesives applied with a thin microbrush according to manufacturer’s
instructions. The resin cement, Rely X ARC, was inserted into the root canals using Lentulo burs.
The post was then placed and the light-curing procedure was carried out for 40 seconds (±500
mW/cm2). The roots were kept in a 100% relative moisture environment for 24 hours and stored in
distilled water for an additional 24 hours. Each root was perpendicularly sectioned into 1-mm
thick sections, resulting in approximately four slices per region. Dumbbell-shaped slices were
obtained by trimming the proximal surfaces of each slice using a diamond bur until it touched the
post. The bonded area was calculated, slices were attached to a special device and submitted to
microtensile testing at 1 mm/minute crosshead speed. Data were analyzed using ANOVA and
Tukey’s test. The mean bond strength values (MPa) were: SBMP: cervical=10.8a, middle=7.9bc,
apical=7.1bc; SB: cervical=8.1b, middle=6.0c, apical=6.9bc. Significant differences were found
between adhesive systems only for the cervical third. The cervical region showed higher mean bond
strength values than the middle and apical regions (p<0.0001).
Surface Changes and Acid Dissolution of Enamel After Carbamide Peroxide Bleach Treatment
Clinical Relevance:
Bleaching treatment should be performed with caution in patients who
are at high risk for enamel erosion.
SUMMARY:
Objectives: To evaluate the effects of home bleaching (carbamide peroxide) on
enamel surface morphology and the degree of acid dissolution.
Methods: Buccal surfaces of 15 caries-free human premolars were used in the study. The 15 teeth were cut in half in a buccal-lingual direction at midline; in total, 15 pairs of specimens were obtained. Group A consisted of five pairs that studied surface morphology change and Group B consisted of 10 pairs that studied the susceptibility of bleached enamel to acid dissolution. Tooth halves were prepared following a fluoride-free prophylaxis paste cleaning. One half of the tooth was untreated (control), and the other half was bleached (experimental) for eight hours daily for 10 days using 10% carbamide peroxide. Tooth samples were then stored in distilled water for seven days, after which scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed on Group A. Only halves from the same tooth were compared to rule out natural variations between teeth. Group B was etched with 37% phosphoric acid before being examined by SEM. The severity of the acid attack was graded from I to V, and the grades of each pair were compared.
Results: Results of the SEM observation showed that surface porosity slightly increased after bleaching, and more surface dissolution by phosphoric acid was seen with bleached, compared to unbleached, enamel.
Temperature Change and Hardness with Different Resin Composites and Photo-activation Methods
Clinical Relevance:
Temperature increase is affected by the material, shade and light
source; however, light source is the most important factor that produces different temperature changes
during the photo-activation of resin composite.
SUMMARY:
This study verifies whether there is any temperature change during
photoactivation of two resin composites (Filtek Z250 and Filtek Flow) with three different light
curing methods (conventional halogen light curing unit, light emitting diodes curing unit and
xenon plasma arc curing unit) and the relationship of temperature change with resin composite
hardness. A type-K thermocouple registered the temperature rise peak in an elastomer mold during
photoactivation. After photoactivation, the specimens were submitted to Knoop hardness test
performed by an indenter (HMV-2000) under a load of 50g for 15 seconds. Both the temperature
change data and results of the Knoop hardness test were submitted to ANOVA and Tukey’s test
at the 5% significance level. No statistical differences in temperature rise were recorded for
the different composites following processing by light curing unit (p>0.05). The conventional
halogen source produced statistically higher temperatures (p<0.05) than the other units. The
plasma arc source promoted statistically lower (p<0.05) Knoop hardness values and temperature
changes than the other light curing units.
Fluoride Release and Neutralizing Effect by Resin-based Materials
Clinical Relevance:
The fluoride-releasing and neutralizing ability of resin-based
materials are affected by the nature of fluoride incorporated into materials.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the fluoride-releasing and neutralizing abilities of
resin-based materials containing fluoride in water and aqueous lactic acid. Two composites,
containing a low-solubility fluoride component (Heliomolar) and a fluoro-alumino-silicate glass
(UniFil S), and two giomers, containing surface reaction type pre-reacted glass-ionomer filler
(Beautifil) and full reaction type glass-ionomer filler (Reactmer paste), were used. Resin-modified
glass-ionomer cement (Fuji II LC) was used as a control. The fluoride release and pH value in
storage medium, after immersion in each material, was measured for 10 weeks. For UniFil S and
Beautifil, the amount of fluoride released in acid solution markedly increased compared to storage
in water (p<0.05). Although all materials, except Heliomolar, neutralized the storage media, the
neutralizing ability of these resin-based mate-rials in acid solution sharply decreased with
aging of the specimens, except for Fuji II LC. These results suggest that the nature of fluoride
incorporated into resin-based materials affect the fluoride-releasing and neutralizing ability of
materials in water and aqueous lactic acid.
Effect of Handpiece Maintenance Method on Bond Strength
Clinical Relevance:
Handpieces, which do not require the user to lubricate them, are
available. Neither these handpieces, nor the use of more traditional lubricated handpieces, adversely
affect the bond strength of current types of bonding agents.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of dental handpiece lubricant on the shear
bond strength of three bonding agents to dentin. A lubrication-free handpiece (one that does not
require the user to lubricate it) and a handpiece requiring routine lubrication were used in the
study. In addition, two different handpiece lubrication methods (automated versus manual
application) were also investigated. One hundred and eighty extracted human teeth were ground to
expose flat dentin surfaces that were then finished with wet silicon carbide paper. The teeth were
randomly divided into 18 groups (n=10). The dentin surface of each specimen was exposed for 30
seconds to water spray from either a lubrication-free handpiece or a lubricated handpiece. Prior to
exposure, various lubrication regimens were used on the handpieces that required lubrication. The
dentin surfaces were then treated with total-etch, two-step; a self-etch, two-step or a self-etch,
one-step bonding agent. Resin composite cylinders were bonded to dentin, the specimens were then
thermocycled and tested to failure in shear at seven days. Mean bond strength data were analyzed
using Dunnett’s multiple comparison test at an 0.05 level of significance. Results indicated
that within each of the bonding agents, there were no significant differences in bond strength
between the control group and the treatment groups regardless of the type of handpiece or use of
routine lubrication.
Clinical Relevance:
The irrigant solution and endodontic cement used for root canal
treatment can significantly affect post retention when the posts are luted with dual-cured composite
cement.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the influence of 5.25% NaOCl irrigant and root canal
sealers on post retention in different dentin regions. Seventy-two human incisors were decoronated
at the cemento-enamel junction and randomly divided into six groups (n=12) according to irrigant
and sealer technique: G1-Distilled water (DW) without sealer; G2-DW + AH Plus (Dentsply/Maillefer);
G3-DW + Endofill (Dentsply/Maillefer); G4-5.25%NaOCl without sealer; G5-5.25% NaOCl + AH Plus;
G6-5.25% NaOCl + Endofill. Specimens were stored in a humid environment for 30 days at 37°C and
were prepared with FRC Postec’s drills for post insertion. The posts were cemented with Excite
DSC/Variolink II (Ivoclar/Vivadent). The specimens were sectioned through their long axis into
three dental slices approximately 2.5 mm each, representing the cervical (C), middle (M) and
apical (A) thirds of the root preparation. After calculating the adhered area of the specimens,
they were submitted to the push-out test in a universal testing machine. The data were submitted
to an analysis of variance (ANOVA) at a 5% significance level and to the Tukey test (p<0.05). The
mean values (MPa) obtained for cervical, middle and apical areas of the root preparation,
respectively, were: G1=8.6; 12.5 and 14.3, G2=13.5; 15.4 and 16.9; G3=6.9; 10.0 and 12.1; G4=13.0;
14.9 and 15.4; G5=11.3; 13.5 and 18.0; and G6=11.0; 11.8 and 11.5. Based on the results, the
eugenol-based sealer (Endofill) resulted in significantly lower mean retention strength values
compared with the resin-based sealer (AH Plus). The apical region showed the greatest retention.
The lowest resistance to dislodgment was found in the cervical region, mainly in the groups that
used distilled water for irrigating the root canal.
Effect of Curing Time and Light Curing Systems on the Surface Hardness of Compomers
Clinical Relevance:
The LED light curing units used in this study can be expected to
effectively polymerize 2-mm thick compomers in 20 seconds.
SUMMARY:
This study compared the Vickers hardness of the top and bottom surfaces of
two compomers (Compoglass F and Dyract AP) polymerized for 20 and 40 seconds with two different
light curing systems. Five samples for each group were prepared using Teflon molds (9x2 mm) and
were light-cured either with a conventional halogen lamp (Optilux 501) or LED light (LEDemetron I)
for 20 or 40 seconds. After curing, all the samples were stored in distilled water for 24 hours at
37°C. The Vickers hardness measurements were obtained from the top and bottom surfaces of each
sample. ANOVA, Scheffé and t-test were used to evaluate the statistical significance of the
results. For the top and bottom surfaces, the light curing systems and curing times tested showed
no statistical difference, except for Optilux 501, which used 20 seconds for both compomers
(p<0.05). There was no significant difference in the microhardness of both surfaces of Compoglass
F and Dyract AP cured for either 20 or 40 seconds using LEDemetron I. With Optilux 501, the
microhardness of samples cured for 40 seconds was significantly higher than 20 seconds (p<0.05).
Clinical Technique/Case Report
Clinical Relevance:
Endodontically treated molars with almost total coronal destruction may
be salvageable by using multiple posts in divergent canals. In order to avoid possible corrosion stress
fracture, it is best to fabricate all the parts of a metal multiple post and core assembly from the
same metal alloy. This article describes an easy method for making a multi-piece metal post and core
assembly from the same homogeneous casting alloy.
Case Report—Pre-Eruptive Intracoronal Resorption
Clinical Relevance:
A pre-eruptive intracoronal resorption is a radiolucent lesion in the
crown of an unerupted tooth. The reported incidence of pre-eruptive intracoronal resorption is 3% to 6%
of the population and 0.5% to 2% of all teeth (Kupietzky, 1999; Seow, Wan, & Mc Allen, 1999b).
Permanent molars have the highest incidence, followed by permanent premolars (Seow, 1998; Seow &
Hackley, 1996; Seow & others, 1999b). While the cause of these defects is not firmly established, the
current theory is dentin resorption. This theory is supported by histological studies that show
osteoclasts, multinucleated giant cells and macrophages present in the lesions (Seow, 1998; Singer,
Abbott & Booth, 1991). Resorptive cells may enter the developing tooth from the surrounding bone
through breaks in the dental follicle or enamel epithelium and cause resorption until the tooth erupts
(Johnson & Harkness, 1997; Kupietzky, 1999; Seow, 1998; Seow, Lu & Mc Allen, 1999a; Seow & others,
1999b). After eruption into the oral cavity, cariogenic bacteria may then enter the tooth through
grooves in the occlusal surface and begin caries formation in the resorptive lesion (Seow, 1998;
Johnson & Harkness, 1997). Early detection of the resorptive defect before eruption may prevent
unnecessary loss of tooth structure. Many of these lesions go undetected until the permanent tooth has
fully erupted. The purpose of this case report is to increase the dentist’s awareness of this
condition, recognize the radiographic and clinical findings of these lesions and suggest treatment
strategies.
Buonocore Memorial Lecture
Water Treeing in Simplified Dentin Adhesives–Déjà Vu?
INTRODUCTION:
In all the words spoken and written about dentin adhesives, one theme constantly
recurs: how long do these man-made bonds last? This question is becoming increasingly challenging to
answer, as the increasing hydrophilicity and step-reduction in contemporary simplified adhesives render
the adhesives very permeable and susceptible to water sorption and movement. These are alarming
concepts. But the realities we face should trigger alarms. It is not the intention of this paper to
provide an extensive review on the bonding of these adhesives to dentin. Rather, evidence of water
movement across resin-dentin interfaces, which are associated with the use of the simplified dentin
adhesives, will be illustrated and discussed. Once identified, steps may be taken to minimize the
negative impact of water sorption, while maximizing the convenience of self-etching systems.
Clinical Research
Clinical Relevance:
Flowable resin composite and flowable compomer can be used for preventive resin restorations. The repair
should be performed immediately, in case the preventive resin restoration develops a fracture or loss.
SUMMARY:
This clinical study evaluated the retention and caries protection of a flowable resin composite
(Flow Line) and a flowable compomer (Dyract Flow) used in preventive resin restorations as compared
to the conventional preventive resin technique which uses a resin composite (Brilliant) and a
sealant (Concise). This study observed 205 permanent molars with small car-ious cavities less
than 1.5 mm in width, which were obtained from 165 children aged 7 to 15 years. Flowable resin
composite was used to treat 75 teeth, and 71 teeth were treated with flowable compomer in both
cavities and caries-free fissures. For the control group, 59 teeth were treated with resin composite
in cavities and sealant in caries-free fissures. The teeth were evaluated at 3, 6, 12, 18 and
24-month intervals. After three months, all 205 treated teeth were completely intact. After six
months, 66 of the 71 teeth treated with flowable resin composite and 65 of the 70 teeth treated
with flowable compomer were complete, compared to 57 of the 58 teeth treated with the conventional
preventive resin technique. After 12 months, 60 of the 67 teeth treated with flowable resin
composite and 61 of the 67 teeth treated with flowable compomer were complete, compared to 51 of
the 55 teeth treated with the conventional preventive resin technique. After 18 months, 53 of the
61 teeth treated with flowable resin composite and 54 of the 62 teeth treated with flowable
compomer were complete, compared to 47 of the 53 teeth treated with the conventional preventive
resin technique. After 24 months, 49 of the 58 teeth treated with flowable resin composite and 45
of the 57 teeth treated with flowable compomer were complete, compared to 42 of the 52 teeth treated
with the conventional preventive resin technique. There were no statistically significant
differences in retention rates among all groups after 3, 6, 12, 18 or 24-months (p>0.05). One tooth
treated with flowable resin composite and one tooth treated with flowable compomer developed caries
after 18 and 24 months, respectively, resulting from partial loss at “caries-free
fissures.” Five teeth developed caries in the conventional preventive resin group; one after
12 months, two after 18 months and one after 24 months, due to loss at cavities. The final caries
occurred after 24 months, resulting from partial loss at “caries-free fissures.” The
differences in caries development among the three groups were not statistically significant
(p>0.05). This study suggested that flowable resin composite and flowable compomer could be used for
preventive resin restorations. Meanwhile, a vigilant recall should be followed-up due to the risk of
failure for flowable materials in “caries-free” fissures. The repair should be performed
immediately, in case the preventive resin restoration develops a fracture or loss.
A Clinical Evaluation of Bleaching Using Whitening Wraps and Strips
Clinical Relevance:
When used twice daily, Ranir Whitening Wraps were more effective in lightening teeth than Crest
Whitestrips Premium when also used twice a day.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the degree of color change of teeth and the sensitivities of teeth and gums
in an in vivo study. Ranir Whitening Wraps (WW2) and Crest Whitestrips Premium (WP2) were used twice
a day and Ranir Whitening Wraps (WW1) were used once a day. Color evaluations occurred at baseline,
after five and seven-day use of bleaching agent and 14 days post-bleaching. Color change was
evaluated objectively and subjectively. Sensitivity evaluations were also accomplished. Seventy-six
of the 78 subjects enrolled completed the study. All three products significantly lightened teeth.
WW2 lightened more than WP2 and WW1 in L*, a*, b*, E and shade guide value. WP2 lightened more than
WW1 in a*, b*, E and shade guide value. There was no difference in tooth sensitivity, but WW1 and
WP2 caused less gingival sensitivity than WW2. The mean age of smokers was seven years younger than
non-smokers who qualified.
Laboratory Research
Surface Finish Produced on Three Resin Composites by New Polishing Systems
Clinical Relevance:
Diamond micro-polisher disks and rubber-polishing disks produced finished surfaces of equivalent average
roughness compared to aluminum oxide polishing disks.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the surface finish of three direct resin composites polished with three
different systems. Disk-shaped specimens (n=16 per material; f=8.0 mm x h=2.0 mm) were formed in a
stainless steel mold by packing uncured material, either a hybrid composite (Z250, 3M ESPE) or two
micro-hybrid composites (Point 4, Kerr; Esthet-X, Dentsply), and light-cured from the top and the
bottom surfaces with a light-emitting diode (LED) curing unit (NRG, Dentsply). After storing the
specimens in deionized water at 37°C for seven days, one side of each specimen was finished through
1200-grit SiC abrasive (Buehler). Five specimens of each resin composite were randomly assigned to
one of the three polishing systems (Identoflex, Kerr; Pogo, Dentsply; Sof-Lex, 3M ESPE).
Manufacturers’ instructions were followed during the polishing procedures. The average surface
roughness (Ra) was determined by generating tracings across the polished surface of each disk using
a scanning profilometer (Surfanalyzer System 5000, Federal Products Co). The results were analyzed
by Kruskal-Wallis and Mann and Whitney tests (p≤0.05). The smoothest surfaces were produced
with the celluloid strip (control group) on all the resin composites tested. The aluminum oxide
disks (Sof-Lex) produced a statistically equivalent surface finish (Ra) on the three resin
composites. The lowest mean roughness values were recorded with diamond micro-polisher disks (PoGo)
on the hybrid composite (Z250). Overall, the two new polishing systems, Identoflex and PoGo,
created a comparable surface finish to that produced by the Sof-Lex system on all three resin
composites.
Influence of Vision on the Evaluation of Marginal Discrepancies in Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
This paper confirms the importance of the dental explorer in diagnosing marginal discrepancies in
restorations, but highlights the need to develop alternatives to the explorer to distinguish between
steps and gaps along cavosurface margins.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the influence of visual inspection in the detection and discrimination
between principle types of marginal discrepancies in restorations. Using devices simulating vertical
steps, horizontal gaps and the combination of a vertical step and horizontal gap at the margin of
a restoration, and explorers with four different tip diameters, 10 experienced dental faculty
members were asked to identify discrepancies and the boundary between Alpha (excellent) and Bravo
(clinically acceptable) marginal adaptation ratings under three different visual
conditions—with and without visual inspection and visual inspection aided with binocular
loupes. A significant correlation was found to exist between explorer tip diameter and the
Alpha/Bravo boundary for horizontal gaps, but not for vertical steps. There was no significant
difference in the detection of the Alpha/Bravo boundary for the three visual conditions. It was
concluded that visual inspection aided and unaided with loupes had no significant effect on the
evaluation of simulated marginal discrepancies. These findings highlight the importance of the
traditional dental explorer, in the absence of more discriminatory devices in the assessment of
marginal discrepancies in restorations.
Clinical Relevance:
The intrapulpal temperature rise of human dentin depends on the energy released by the light curing unit
and is dependent on the presence of resin composite and dentin thickness.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study evaluated the effect of different polymerization modes and the presence of resin
composite on the temperature rise (TR) in human dentin of different thicknesses. For this purpose,
90 specimens were assigned to 30 groups (n=3): five polymerization modes (1-conventional;
2-soft-start; 3-high intensity; 4-ramp cure: progressive and high intensity; 5-high intensity with
the tip of the light cure at a distance of 1.3 cm for 10 seconds and the tip leaned in the sample);
two levels of resin composite presence (absence or presence of resin composite) and three dentin
thicknesses (1, 2, 3 mm). During polymerization, temperature was measured by a digital laser
thermometer (CMSS2000-SL/SKF). Three-way ANOVA and Tukey tests were performed. There were statistical
differences in TR among polymerization modes, presence of resin composite and dentin thicknesses.
Within the limits of this study, it can be concluded that 1) conventional and high intensity
polymerization modes presented lower TR means, and it was statistically different from soft start,
distanced tip and ramp curing polymerization modes; 2) the presence of resin composite showed a
statistically significant reduction TR means and 3) the thicker the dentin, the less the temperature
rise.
The Effect of 10% Carbamide Peroxide, Carbopol and/or Glycerin on Enamel and Dentin Microhardness
Clinical Relevance:
Changes in enamel and dentin microhardness may be related not only to carbamide peroxide, but also to
the presence of other components in bleaching agents, such as carbopol and glycerin. Carbopol and its
associations may cause alterations in microhardness compared to Opalescence. None of the treatment
agents or associations evaluated was inert for dental microhardness, although glycerin seemed to affect
enamel and dentin to a lesser degree.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effects of 10% carbamide peroxide, carbopol and glycerin and their
associations on microhardness over time on enamel and dentin. Eight treatment agents were evaluated:
a commercial bleaching agent containing 10% carbamide peroxide (Opalescence 10% Ultradent), 10%
carbamide peroxide, carbopol, glycerin, 10% carbamide peroxide + carbopol, 10% carbamide peroxide +
glycerin, carbopol + glycerin and 10% carbamide peroxide + carbopol + glycerin. Three hundred and
twenty human dental fragments, 80 sound enamel fragments (SE), 80 demineralized enamel fragments
(DE), 80 sound dentin fragments (SD) and 80 demineralized dentin (DD) fragments, were exposed to
the treatment agents (n=10). These agents were applied onto the surface of the fragments eight hours
a day for 42 days. After eight hours, they were washed from the dental fragment surfaces after five
back-and-forth movements with a soft bristle toothbrush under distilled and deionized running water.
During the remaining time (16 hours per day), the fragments were kept in individual vials in
artificial saliva. After the 42-day treatment period, the specimens were kept individually in
artificial saliva for 14 days. Knoop microhardness measurements were performed at baseline, after
eight hours, and 7, 14, 21, 28, 35 and 42 days, and 7 and 14 days post-treatment (corresponding to
49 and 56 days after the initial treatment agent applications). The non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis
analysis showed significant differences among the agents at each time interval, except at baseline
for sound and demineralized enamel and dentin. For SE, SD and DD, there was a decrease in
microhardness values during treatment with all agents. There was a tendency towards lower
microhardness values after treatment with carbopol and its associations for sound tissues. DD
showed low microhardness values during and after treatment with CP and its associations. For DE,
there was an increase in microhardness values during treatment with all agents and in the
post-treatment phase. The baseline microhardness values were not recovered during the 14-day
post-treatment phase. Opalescence 10%, carbamide peroxide, carbopol, glycerin and their associations
may change the microhardness of sound and demineralized dental tissues, even in the presence of
artificial saliva.
Surface Roughness of Different Dental Materials Before and After Simulated Toothbrushing In Vitro
Clinical Relevance:
Brushing with toothpaste roughened the surface of most composite materials though, in general, hybrid
composites were more prone to surface alterations than microfilled composites. Dental ceramics and
amalgam, on the other hand, showed no increase in surface roughness after toothbrushing. On the
contrary, the roughness of some ceramic materials even decreased, which was comparable to dentin and
enamel.
SUMMARY:
This study measured the effect of toothbrushing with a slurry of toothpaste on different dental
materials that have been optimally polished. Specimens (n=8) of 21 dental materials, 16 resin
composites, 1 amalgam and 4 ceramic materials, were subjected to 36,000 cycles (approximately five
hours) of circular toothbrushing with a force of 1.7 N and a slurry of toothpaste (RDA 75) in a
device for simulated toothbrushing. The unpolished enamel and dentin of extracted anterior teeth
were used as a control. The mean roughness (Ra) was measured with an optical sensor (FRT MicroProf)
before and after toothbrushing. To compare the roughness of the different materials, ANOVA with a
post hoc Tukey B test was applied (p<0.05). Among the resin composites, the hybrid composites showed
the greatest increase in mean roughness, while the microfilled composites and the compomer
Compoglass F demonstrated the lowest increase. No statistically significant difference in roughness
was found before and after simulated toothbrushing for the Amalcap amalgam, Esthet-X resin composite,
TPH Spectrum resin composite, d.SIGN ceramic and the experimental ceramic. The other ceramic
materials and dentin and enamel specimens showed a statistically significant decrease in mean
roughness after simulated toothbrushing. Glazed Empress demon-strated a statistically significant
higher initial roughness than polished Empress. For resin composites, no correlation was found
between the mean particle size and mean roughness after simulated toothbrushing.
Evaluation of the Adhesion of Fiber Posts to Intraradicular Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
When luting fiber posts to intraradicular dentin, a total-etch resin cement shows greater bonding
potential than a self-etch and a self-adhesive resin cement.
SUMMARY:
The interfacial strength and ultrastructure of a total-etch, self-etch and self-adhesive resin
cement used to lute endodontic glass fiber posts (FRC Postec, Ivoclar-Vivadent) was assessed with
the “thin-slice” push-out test and transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The tested
adhesive cements were Variolink II (Ivoclar-Vivadent), Panavia 21 (Kuraray Co) and RelyX Unicem
(3M ESPE). In each group, seven posted roots were used for push-out tests and two were processed for
TEM observations. The interfacial strength achieved by Variolink II (10.18±2.89 MPa) was
significantly higher than Panavia (5.04±2.81 MPa) and RelyX Unicem (5.01±2.63 MPa), which were
comparable to each other. TEM micrographs of the interface between Variolink II and intraradicular
dentin revealed that the smear layer was totally removed and an 8-10 micron thick hybrid layer was
formed. In the other group specimens, the smear layer was not completely dissolved and smear plugs
were retained. Gaps were present between the hybridized complex and the adhesive layer in the
Panavia 21 specimens and between the smear layer and underlying root dentin in the RelyX Unicem
specimens. Interfacial strengths and microscopic findings were in agreement and indicated that the
bonding potential of the total-etch resin cement was greater. The acidic-resin monomers responsible
for substrate conditioning in Panavia 21 and RelyX Unicem appeared unable to effectively remove the
thick smear layer created on root dentin during post space preparation.
Inhibitory Activity of Glass-ionomer Cements on Cariogenic Bacteria
Clinical Relevance:
This study demonstrated that glass-ionomer materials, especially the resin-modified glass-ionomer cement
Vitrebond, regardless of the curing activation mode used, presented a striking inhibitory effect on
cariogenic bacteria.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the antibacterial activity of the glass-ionomer cements Vitrebond (3M ESPE),
Ketac Molar (3M ESPE) and Fuji IX (GC America) against S mutans, S sobrinus, L acidophilus and A
viscosus, using the agar diffusion test. Inocula were obtained by the seed of indicators cultures in
BHI broth incubated at 37°C for 24 hours. Base layers containing 15 mL of BHI agar and 300 µL of each
bacteria suspension were prepared in Petri dishes. Six wells measuring 4 mm in diam-eter were made
in each plate and completely filled with one of the testing materials. A 0.2% chlorhexidine solution
applied in round filter papers was used as control. Tests were performed 12 times for each material
and bacteria strain. After incubation of the plates at 37°C for 24 hours, the zones of bacterial
growth inhibition around the wells were measured. Overall, the results showed the following sequence
of antibacterial activity: Vitrebond (despite the activation mode) > 0.2% chlorhexidine > Ketac
Molar > Fuji IX, according to Kruskal-Wallis and Mann-Whitney statistical tests.
This study confirmed significant antibacterial activity for two conventional glass-ionomers and one resin-modified glass-ionomer material. The resin-modified glass-ionomer cement Vitrebond, regardless of the activation mode, presented the best antibacterial activity against S mutans and S sobrinus. The antibacterial activity against A viscosus for Vitrebond was similar to 0.2% chlorhexidine, while light activation reduced its antibacterial activity against L acidophilus.
Influence of Light Activation on the Volumetric Change of Core Foundation Resins
Clinical Relevance:
The data suggests that the volumetric shrinkage of core foundation resins can be influenced by the
intensity and duration of curing light. Care should be taken in the method of polymerization when using
core foundation systems for endodontically treated teeth.
SUMMARY:
A core foundation system is frequently used in endodontically treated teeth that suffer excessive
loss of the coronal portion of their structure. The volumetric shrinkage of core foundation resins
may create marginal gaps that influence the bonding ability and longevity of a restored tooth.
Little is known about how activation conditions of resin core foundation resin pastes affect their
volumetric shrinkage. This study evaluated the influence of light intensity and light activation
duration on volumetric shrinkage of direct core foundation resins. Two dual- and one light-activated
core foundation resin pastes were employed. The material was placed in a Teflon mold 4 mm in
diameter and 2 mm in height and extruded into a water-filled dilatometer. The specimens were then
light activated and the change in height of the meniscus of water was recorded using a
charged-coupled device camera. The average volumetric shrinkage of the core foundation resins after
180 seconds ranged from 1.53% to 2.63%. For all materials tested, there was a tendency for increased
volumetric shrinkage with increased light activation time and intensity. The results of this study
indicate that the volumetric change of core foundation resins is influenced by the time and
intensity of light activation.
The Effect of Composite Type on Microhardness When Using Quartz-tungsten-halogen (QTH) or LED Lights
Clinical Relevance:
Resin composite surface microhardness is affected by the selection of different LCUs, with some LEDs
providing similar performance to the QTH source. However, results vary greatly with composite brand and
type (microhybrid and microfill).
SUMMARY:
This study evaluates the Knoop microhardness of resin composites cured with different light-emitting
diode (LED) based light curing units (LCU) or with a conventional quartz-tungsten-halogen light
(QTH). Ten experimental groups with 10 specimens each were used. The specimens were prepared by
placing two light-cured resin composites with similar VITA shade A2–microhybrid Filtek
Z250/3M ESPE and microfill Durafil VS/Heraeus Kulzer—in a 2.0 mm-thick disc shaped mold.
The specimens were polymerized for 40 seconds with the use of one QTH LCU
(Optilux 501/Kerr-Demetron) and four LED LCUs: Elipar FreeLight 1 Cordless LED (3M ESPE), Ultrablue
II LED with cord (DMC), Ultrablue III LED cordless (DMC) and LEC 470 I (MM Optics). Knoop
microhardness was determined at the top and bottom surfaces of the specimens 24 hours following
curing. Microhardness values in the microhybrid resin composite group showed no statistically
significant differences when cured with LED FreeLight 1 LCU and QTH LCU (p<0.05). The other LED
devices evaluated in the study presented lower microhardness values in both surfaces (p<0.05) when
compared to QTH. In the microfill resin composite group, no statistically significant differences
were observed among all LCUs evaluated on the bottom surfaces (p<0.05). However, on the top
surfaces, QTH presented the highest KHN values, and the LED devices presented similar results when
compared with KHN values relative to each other (p<0.05).
Two-year Color Changes of Light-cured Composites: Influence of Different Light-curing Units
Clinical Relevance:
Curing composites using conventional halogen curing units, high intensity halogen curing units and LED
units might reduce color changes of the material when compared to PAC units.
SUMMARY:
This study determined color changes in a composite cured with various types of curing units after
two years. A hybrid (Clearfil AP-X) com-posite was cured with a conventional halogen, a high
intensity halogen, a plasma arc and a light emitting diode unit. The specimens were stored in
light-proof boxes after the curing procedure to avoid further exposure to light and stored in 37°C
in 100% humidity. Colorimetric values of the specimens immediately after curing and after two years
were measured using a colorimeter. The CIE 1976 L*a*b color system was used to determine color
differences. Differences from baseline were calculated as ∆E*ab. Data were analyzed with
two-way analysis of variance (p<0.05). The ∆E*ab values varied significantly, depending on
the curing unit used. The specimens cured with a plasma arc curing unit induced significantly
higher color changes than any other specimen and the color differences were also visually
appreciable by the non-skilled operator (∆E*ab >2.5). The specimens cured with a high
intensity halogen curing unit produced the lowest color change; however, there were no statistically
significant differences among the color changes of specimens cured with conventional halogen, high
intensity halogen and the light emitting diode unit, and the color changes were not clinically
relevant (∆E*ab <2.5). The results of this study suggest that composite materials undergo
measurable changes due to curing unit exposure. The specimens cured with a plasma arc light showed
the highest color changes as compared to specimens cured with other curing units.
Effects of pH on the Microhardness of Resin-based Restorative Materials
Clinical Relevance:
In patients who consume large quantities of acidic beverages and food substances, compomers and giomers
should be used with caution, especially in “stress-bearing” areas.
SUMMARY:
This study determined the effect of pH on the microhardness of commonly used resin-based restorative
materials, which included a resin composite (Esthet-X, Dentsply), a new generation compomer
(Dyract Extra, Dentsply) and a giomer (Beautifil, Shofu). Fifty-four specimens (3-mm wide x 3-mm
long x 2-mm deep) were made for each material. The specimens were divided into six equal groups and
conditioned in the following solutions at 37°C for one week: 0.3% citric acid at pH 2.5, sodium
hydroxide—buffered citric acid at pH 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7. After conditioning, the specimens were
subjected to hardness testing using a digital microhardness tester (load 500gf; dwell time 15
seconds). Data was analyzed using one-way ANOVA and Scheffe’s test at a significance level
of 0.05. The effects of pH on the microhardness of resin-based restoratives were material dependent.
The compomer and giomer materials were more affected by acids of low pH than the composite material
that was evaluated.
Editorial
The Impact of Study Clubs on Our Patients
Laboratory Research
Effectiveness of Composite Cure Associated with Different Light-curing Regimes
Clinical Relevance:
Soft-start and turbo cure regimens may be more effective than the standard continuous cure mode.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the use of various light-curing regimens with standardized light energy density
on the effectiveness of cure of a visible light activated resin composite (Z100, 3M-ESPE). A light-cure
unit (Variable Intensity Polymerizer (VIP), BISCO Inc) which permitted individual control over time and
intensity, was used. The five light-curing modes investigated include Pulse Delay (PD), Pulse Cure (PC),
Soft-start (SS), Turbo (T) and Control (C). Effectiveness of cure was established by measuring the top
and bottom Knoop hardness of 2-mm thick composite specimens using a digital microhardness tester (n=5,
load=500g; dwell time=15 seconds) immediately and at one-day post-polymerization. Data obtained was
analyzed using one-way ANOVA/Scheffe’s post hoc test and Independent Samples t-tests (p<0.05).
Top KHN observed immediately after polymerization with C was significantly lower than PD. At one day
post-polymerization, the top KHN obtained with C was significantly lower than PD, SS and T. No
significant difference in bottom KHN was observed among the different curing modes immediately after
curing. At one day post-polymerization, the bottom KHN obtained with C was significantly lower than
SS and T. Regardless of curing regimens, top and bottom values at one day were significantly higher
than those observed immediately after light polymerization. No significant difference in mean hardness
ratio was observed among the different curing regimens immediately and one day later. Effectiveness of
the cure at the bottom surfaces of composites may be increased by soft-start and turbo polymerization
regimens.
Salivary Contamination and Bond Strength of Glass-ionomers to Dentin
Clinical Relevance:
Salivary contamination did not affect the mean shear bond strength of highly viscous glass ionomers to
conditioned dentin; instead, it increased the probability of failure at low stresses.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the effect of salivary contamination on the shear bond strength of two highly
viscous glass ionomer cements (Fuji IX GP Fast and Ketac-Molar Maxicap) to conditioned dentin and
assessed the effect of cleaning the contaminated field prior to bonding.
The buccal surfaces of 90 human molars and premolars were ground to expose dentin and the teeth were then set in resin. The specimens were divided into two groups for each material, then further subdivided into three groups of 15 teeth each: Group 1–uncontaminated (control), Group 2–dentin contaminated with saliva, Group 3–dentin contaminated, washed and air dried. The specimens were made by bonding the test material to dentin using a 4-mm diameter gelatin capsule. All specimens were protected with varnish and placed in distilled water at 37°C for seven days prior to measuring bond strength in shear. Fractured surfaces were examined visually and by using SEM to assess mode of failure.
There were no significant differences in mean shear bond strength among the three test groups for either material (ANOVA). However, shear bond strength of Fuji IX to dentin was significantly greater than Ketac-Molar (p=0.019) for all groups. Weibull analysis showed that contaminated (Group 2) specimens had a greater probability of failure at low stresses. Modes of failure were mostly cohesive for Fuji IX and adhesive/cohesive for Ketac-Molar.
In conclusion, salivary contamination did not affect the mean shear bond strength of Fuji IX GP Fast and Ketac-Molar Maxicap to conditioned dentin; however, it increased the probability of failure at low stresses.
Effect of LED Curing Modes on Cusp Deflection and Hardness of Composite Restorations
Clinical Relevance:
Using pulse or stepped curing modes with LED to cure MOD resin composite restorations decreased the
polymerization-induced cusp deflection.
SUMMARY:
This in vitro study measured cusp deflection associated with MOD resin composite restorations in
maxillary premolars with different curing light modes. Soft-start polymerization may reduce cusp
deflection by reducing polymerization shrinkage stress. Forty maxillary premolars were mounted in
stone and slot MOD cavities were prepared. The teeth were randomized into four groups:
Group A–cavities were etched, bonded and restored with two increments of Z-100 composite.
Each increment was cured with an LED curing light (fast curing mode). Group B–similar to
Group A except that the LED curing light with pulse curing mode was used. Group C–similar to
Group A except that the LED curing light with stepped curing mode was used. Group D–a visible
curing light was used for curing the composite. The distance between the indexed cusp tips was
measured before the restorations were completed and five minutes after, 24 hours after and two weeks
after completion of the restorations. The mean contraction of the cusps in µm at five minutes,
24 hours and two weeks, respectively, for each group was A: 25.4, 16.2 and 8.2, B: 6.4, 3.4 and 2.2,
C: 11.6, 7.0 and 4.4, D: 33.0, 21.6 and 15.8. Group D resulted in the highest deflection, Group A was
intermediate and Groups B and C were the lowest. Ten samples of the composite for each group with
2-mm thickness were prepared for the Vickers hardness test. No difference among the samples was
found.
Fluoride Release/Recharge from Restorative Materials—Effect of Fluoride Gels and Time
Clinical Relevance:
A four-minute APF gel application led to a higher fluoride recharge by the tested materials; the
resin-modified glass ionomers were the most influenced by this procedure.
SUMMARY:
This study examined the differences in fluoride release and recharge among four restorative
materials following treatment with APF or neutral fluoride gel for one or four minutes.
Specimens were immersed in 2 mL of deionized water, while fluoride release was measured at
24-hour intervals for 15 days using an ion-selective electrode and analyzer. The materials
were then treated with the fluoride gels. The fluoride release was measured for 15 days.
ANOVA (p<0.05) showed higher fluoride release for Ketac-Fil before fluoride application and
for Vitremer and Fuji II LC after application of APF gel. APF gel yielded higher fluoride
release when compared to neutral gel, regardless of the material. Fluoride recharge and release
was greater after the four-minute APF gel application, with no difference between the times
of application for the neutral gel (p>0.05), except for Ketac-Fil. The pattern of release before
and after application of the gels was similar and was higher at day 16 compared to day one for
the APF gel for resin materials, with higher release at day 15 compared to the initial for Fuji
II LC and Vitremer. It was concluded that RM-GICs were the most effective materials with regards
to fluoride release after application of APF gel for four minutes.
Clinical Relevance:
Resin composites that polymerize under the warm temperature and high humidity conditions of
the oral cavity shrink more than those that polymerize under room temperature and humidity
conditions. Using a rubber dam lowers the temperature and humidity in treatment areas and,
therefore, may help reduce resin composite shrinkage.
SUMMARY:
This study measured the volumetric shrinkage of resin composites polymerized under temperature
and humidity conditions simulating the oral cavity and compared them to those occurring under
ambient room conditions. Small, semi-spherical specimens of a microhybrid (Z100), microfill
(Filtek A110) and flowable microhybrid (4 Seasons Flow) resin composite were manually formed and
light activated for 40 seconds using a halogen light-curing unit (Spectrum Curing Light). The
volumetric polymerization shrinkage of 10 specimens of each brand of resin composite was measured
using a drop shape analysis unit (Drop Shape Analysis System, model DSA10 Mk2) under each of two
temperature/relative humidity conditions: room conditions (22 ± 2°C and 60 ± 5%) and those
simulating intraoral conditions (35°C and 92 ± 5%). Mean volumetric shrinkage values were
calculated for each resin composite and the data were analyzed using two-way analysis of variance
and t-test (a=0.05) to determine if significant differences existed between the amount of
volumetric polymerization shrinkage that occurred under ambient room conditions and that which
occurred under simulated intraoral conditions. Mean volumetric shrinkage values measured for the
resin composites were: 2.26 ± 0.04% (ambient) and 2.61 ± 0.04% (intraoral) for Z100; 1.96 ± 0.04%
(ambient) and 2.28 ± 0.04% (intraoral) for Filtek A110 and 4.53 ± 0.06% (ambient) and 5.34 ±
0.05% (intraoral) for 4 Seasons Flow. For each resin composite, statistical analysis indicated
that the amount of volumetric shrinkage measured under simulated intraoral conditions was
significantly greater than what was measured under ambient room conditions (p<0.0001).
Clinical Relevance:
An experimentally developed adhesive resin system induced exposed pulp to produce reparative
dentin formation earlier than commercially available adhesive resin systems. More research is
required to determine the CO2 laser conditions that can be used successfully for direct pulp
capping.
SUMMARY:
This study examined the wound healing process of rat pulp directly capped with various
experimentally developed adhesive resin systems and treated with CO2 laser irradiation. The
experimental adhesive resins used in this study were made from Clearfil Mega Bond (MB). The
adhesive resin groups were capped with a combination of the following primers and bonding
agents: commercially available MB primer (MBP), experimental MB primer containing 2wt%
N-methacryloyl 5-aminosalicylic acid (5-NMSA: MP3) and 5wt% 12-methacryloyloxydodecylpyridinium
bromide (MDPB: ABP); and commercially available MB bonding agent (MBB), experimental MB bonding
agent containing 5wt% and 10wt% hydroxyl-calcium phosphate (hydroxyapatite: MB1, MB2) and 5wt%
dicalcium phosphate dihydrate (brushite: MB3) as a reparative dentin-promoter. The combination
of the three primers and four bonding agents yielded the 12 adhesive resin groups used in this
study. The CO2 laser group was irradiated with a laser and directly capped with MB. The CO2
laser used was an Opelaser 03S II SP, and irradiation conditions were as follows: a power output
of 0.5 W, superpulse mode 1, repeat pulse mode (a cycle of 10 msec irradiation and 10 msec
interval), defocused beam (approximately distance 20 mm from pulp exposure surface) and an
irradiation time of three seconds, with air cooling. The control group was capped with Dycal
(DY) and MB. After the direct pulp capping procedures were undertaken, all cavities were
restored with Clearfil AP-X resin composite. The rats were sacrificed on the 14th post-operative
day. The specimens were alternately stained with Mayer’s H & E, Hucker-Conn bacterial
stain and the ABC method on TGF-beta1. These stained sections were observed using light
microscopy and the following parameters were evaluated: pulp tissue disorganization,
inflammatory cell infiltration, reparative dentin formation and bacterial penetration. The
results of this study include the following: all experimentally developed bonding agent groups
showed reparative dentin formation; whereas, the MBB-capped groups showed very little reparative
dentin formation. The descending order regarding the amount of reparative dentin formation was
MB2 > MB3 > MB1 >>> MBB, which tended to be dependent on the concentration of the blended
reparative dentin-promoter. In terms of the quality of the formed dentin, it was observed that
MB1-capped teeth tended to form tubular dentin; whereas, MB2- and MB3-capped teeth formed
irregular and osteodentin types of dentin. Among the primers used, the descending order
regarding the amount of reparative dentin and tubular type dentin formation was MP3 > MBP > ABP.
The descending order of migration of macrophages and leukocytes was ABP > MBP > MP3. The CO2
laser group showed a very irreg-ular fibrous dentin matrix in the vicinity of the denatured and
carbonized tissue but definite reparative dentin formation was not observed. The control group
showed reparative dentin, which was very thick, compared with the other groups. In all the
groups, pulp tissue showed almost normal morphology. Positive staining of TGF-beta1 was only
observed slightly in some specimens of all groups. There was no difference in the staining of
each group. Based on the results of this study, it was concluded that the combination of MP3
(containing 2wt% 5-NMSA) and MB1 (containing 5wt% hydroxyapatite) was effective in initiating an
early repair process after direct pulp capping. CO2 laser irradiation is effective for field
control, but a longer observation time will be required to determine findings concerning dentin
bridge formation.
Radiographic Versus Clinical Extension of Class II Carious Lesions Using An F-speed Film
Clinical Relevance:
When using F-speed film (Insight–Kodak), the radiographic extent of Class II carious
lesions underestimated the true clinical extent for both “aggressive” and
“conservative” diagnoses.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the difference in the apparent radiographic and true clinical extension
of Class II carious lesions. Sixty-two lesions in both maxillary and mandibular premolars and
molars were radiographed using Insight bitewing film. Class II lesions were scored independently
by two masked examiners using an 8-point lesion severity scale. During the restoration process
the lesions were dissected in a stepwise fashion from the occlusal aspect. Intraoperative
photographs (2x) of the lesions were made, utilizing a novel measurement device in the field
as a point of reference. Subsequently, the lesions were all given clinical scores using the
same 8-point scale. Statistical analysis showed a significant difference between the true
clinical extension of the lesions compared to the radiographic score. “Aggressive”
and “Conservative” radiographic diagnoses underestimated the true clinical extent
by 0.66 mm and 0.91 mm, respectively. No statistical difference was found between premolars
and molars or maxillary and mandibular arches. The results of this study help to define the
parameters for making restorative treatment decisions involving Class II carious lesions.
Occlusal Loading Evaluation in the Cervical Integrity of Class II Cavities Filled with Composite
Clinical Relevance:
The periodical supervision of condensable composite proximal restorations is essential with
respect to the clinical success of such restorations, as the microleakage quality greatly
increases after axial mechanical load incidence.
SUMMARY:
There are many doubts about the clinical behavior of condensable composite restorations in
Class II cavities, particularly when they are submitted to axial mechanical loads. This study
evaluated cervical microleakage in Class II direct fillings in composite, whether or not they
were submitted to an occlusal load cycling. Twenty-three human molars with standardized cavities
(proximal vertical “slot”) were treated with enamel and cement endings. After
completion of the filling process with condensable composite (Surefil), they were separated into
two groups: control (without occlusal loading) and test, where 4,000 one-second cycles of 150
N occlusal loading were applied. Twenty teeth were submitted to a microleakage test and then
evaluated according to dye penetration. Significant statistical differences (Wilcoxon test,
p=0.005<0.05) of leakage degree in enamel and cement were found in the control group. Significant
statistical differences at <0.05 were also found in the test group, with p=0.045.
After paired comparison of the control and test groups, a significant statistical difference was found at the enamel level (Mann-Whitney test, p=0.03). However, no significant statistical differences were found at the cement level (p=0.28). Therefore, it could be concluded that there was greater microleakage in cement compared to enamel, and occlusal loading has a decisive influence, as it increases the rate of microleakage.
Microtensile Dentin Bond Strength of Self-Etching Resins: Effect of a Hydrophobic Layer
Clinical Relevance:
In resin composite restorations where maximum dentin adhesion is desirable, bonding of single
component self-etching adhesives would likely be improved through the addition of a layer of a more
hydrophobic adhesive.
SUMMARY:
In this study, the microtensile bond strength of resin composites to dentin was determined when
hydrophilic self-etching resins were used with and without an additional layer of a more
hydrophobic adhesive. Included were three single-step self-etching adhesives, Adper Prompt L-Pop
(3M ESPE), iBond GI (Heraeus Kulzer, Inc) and Xeno III (Caulk/Dentsply), and as a negative
control, UniFil Bond (GC America), a self-etching primer with a separate adhesive. Each product
was evaluated using a hybrid resin composite from its respective manufacturer, and each was used
as directed and then used with an added layer of a more hydrophobic resin from its respective
manufacturer. Testing was performed after 72 hours using a “non-trimming” microtensile
test at a crosshead speed of 0.6 mm/minute. When the products were used according to
manufacturers’ directions, iBond had a significantly higher bond strength to dentin than
the other three products (p<0.001), which were not significantly different from each other. For
the three self-etching adhesive systems, the addition of a layer of a more hydrophobic resin
produced significantly higher bond strengths to dentin (p<0.001), while no significant effect was
found for the self-etching primer (p=0.40). A significant interaction was found between the
variables product and adhesive treatment. The TEM evaluation of Prompt L-Pop and iBond demonstrated
reduced nanoleakage with the additional resin layer.
Clinical Relevance:
The “resin coating” technique did not provide an increase in tooth-restoration
interface width or wear after the toothbrushing abrasion test when compared to the conventional
cementation technique. The application of a restoration surface sealant improved interface wear
resistance for both cementation techniques.
SUMMARY:
This study compared (1) the tooth-restoration interface width of conventional and “resin
coating” cementation techniques, (2) the tooth- brushing wear resistance of the two
interfaces and (3) this study evaluated the influence of a restoration surface sealing on
toothbrush wear resistance on both cementation technique interfaces. Mid-coronal buccal surfaces
of 40 bovine teeth were ground to obtain a flat enamel surface. For each specimen, a 3 mm x 4
mm x 3 mm dimension rectangular cavity was prepared. The teeth were divided into four groups.
Two groups (RC) received a “resin coating” (ED Primer + Tetric Flow) prior to
cementation. The remaining two groups (NC) served as non-coated groups. All teeth were restored
with composite inlays (Z250) fabricated by the indirect method and were cemented with dual cure
resin cement (Panavia F). After finishing the margins, one group from each of the cementation
techniques (RC+S and NC+S) had the tooth-restoration interface protected with a restoration
surface sealant (Biscover). The specimens were subjected to 100,000 brushing abrasion cycles.
The tooth-restoration width was obtained using a Hommel Tester T 1000—basic profilometer
and Turbo Datawin NT 1.34 Software (µm). The interface wear (vertical loss/µm and area/µm2)
was calculated with Image Tool 3.0 Software. Data were analyzed with Student t-test, one-way
analysis of variance and Tukey test (a=0.05). Mean interface width for the NC group was 67 µm
and 72 µm for the RC group. The student t-test showed no significant differences between groups
(p=0.53). ANOVA showed significant differences (p<0.01) in vertical loss among groups (NC: 49.30
µm; NC+S: 7.90 µm; RC: 27.15 µm; RC+S: 4.74 µm). Also, ANOVA showed significant differences
(p<0.01) in worn areas among groups (NC: 2,008 µm2; NC+S: 128 µm2; RC: 1,580 µm2 and RC+S: 88 µm2).
No differences were found in tooth-restoration interface width and worn area between conventional
and “resin coating” techniques. “Resin coating” interface presented
reduced vertical loss. Restoration surface sealing provided reduced wear in tooth-restoration
interface for both techniques.
Clinical Relevance:
The film thickness of the Dentin Bonding Agent (DBA) used for the “immediate dentin
sealing” of onlay preparations prior to the final impression for indirect restorations
presents a vast range of values, depending on both the type of DBA and the topography of the
tooth preparation. Curing the DBA in the absence of oxygen (air blocking) is mandatory to maintain
a minimum DBA thickness. The filled DBA presented a more uniform thickness compared to the
unfilled one. Air abrasion and polishing used for cleaning the pre-cured DBA prior to final
cementation reduces the thickness of the DBA in a non-uniform manner.
SUMMARY:
This study evaluated the thickness of Dentin Bonding Agent (DBA) used for “immediate dentin
sealing” of onlay preparations prior to final impression making for indirect restorations.
In addition, the amount of DBA that is removed when the adhesive surface is cleaned with polishing
or air abrasion prior to final cementation was evaluated. For this purpose, a standardized onlay
preparation was prepared in 12 extracted molars, and either OptiBond FL (Kerr) or Syntac Classic
(Vivadent) was applied to half of the teeth and cured in the absence of oxygen (air blocking).
Each tooth was bisected in a bucco-lingual direction into two sections, and the thickness of the
DBA was measured under SEM on gold sputtered epoxy resin replicas at 11 positions. The DBA layer
of each half tooth was treated with either air abrasion or polishing. The thickness of the DBAs
was then re-measured on the replicas at the same positions. The results were statistically
analyzed with non-parametric statistics (Mann-Whitney U test and Kruskal-Wallis test) at a
confidence level of 95% (p=0.05).
The film thickness of the DBA was not uniform across the adhesive interface (121.13 ± 107.64 µm), and a great range of values was recorded (0 to 500 µm). Statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were noted, which were both material (OptiBond FL or Syntac Classic) and position (1 to 11) dependent. Syntac Classic presented a higher thickness of DBA (142.34 ± 125.10 µm) than OptiBond FL (87.99 ± 73.76 µm). The higher film thickness of both DBAs was at the deepest part of the isthmus (the most concave part of the preparation), while the lowest was at the line angles of the dentinal crest (the most convex part of the preparation). OptiBond FL presented a more uniform thickness around the dentinal crest of preparation; Syntac Classic pooled at the lower parts of the preparation.
The amount of DBA that was removed with air abrasion or polishing was not uniform (11.94 ± 16.46 µm), and a great range of values was recorded (0 to 145 µm). No statistically significant differences (p<0.05) were found either between different DBAs (OptiBond FL or Syntac Classic) or between different treatments (air abrasion or polishing). As far as the effect of different treatments at different positions, polishing removed more DBA from the top of the dentinal crest, but the difference was not statistically significant. Air abrasion removed less DBA from the corners of the dentinal crest (Positions 4 and 6) than the outer buccal part of the preparation (Positions 1 and 2). Neither air abrasion nor polishing removed the entire layer thickness of the DBA in the majority of the cases.
Curing Efficacy of a New Generation High-power LED Lamp
Clinical Relevance:
New generation high-power LED lamps may cure composites as effectively as conventional LED/halogen
in half the time.
SUMMARY:
This study investigated the curing efficacy of a new generation high-power LED lamp (Elipar
Freelight 2 [N] 3M-ESPE). The effectiveness of composite cure with this new lamp was compared
to conventional LED/halogen (Elipar Freelight [F], 3M-ESPE; Max [M], Dentsply-Caulk) and
high-power halogen (Elipar Trilight [T], 3M-ESPE; Astralis 10 [A], Ivoclar Vivadent) lamps.
Standard continuous (NS, FS, TS; MS), turbo (AT) and exponential (NE, FE, TE) curing modes of
the various lights were examined. Curing efficacy of the various lights and modes were
determined by measuring the top and bottom surface hardness of 2-mm thick composite specimens
(Z100, 3M-ESPE) using a digital microhardness tester (n=5; load=500 g; dwell time=15 seconds)
one hour after light polymerization. The hardness ratio was computed by dividing HK (Knoops
Hardness) of the bottom surface by HK of the top surface. The data was analyzed using one-way
ANOVA/Scheffe’s test and Independent Samples t-test at significance level 0.05. Results
of the statistical analysis were as follows: HK top—E, FE, NE > NS and NE > AT, TS, FS;
HK bottom—TE, NE > NS; Hardness ratio—NS > FE and FS, TS > NE. No significant
difference in HK bottom and hardness ratio was observed between the two modes of Freelight 2
and Max. Freelight 2 cured composites as effectively as conventional LED/halogen and high-power
halogen lamps, even with a 50% reduction in cure time. The exponential modes of Freelight 2,
Freelight and Trilight appear to be more effective than their respective standard modes.
Curing of Pit & Fissure Sealants Using Light Emitting Diode Curing Units
Clinical Relevance:
Adequate polymerization of opaque light-activated sealants should not be assumed and is dependent
upon the material and light-curing unit.
SUMMARY:
Light Emitting Diode (LED) curing units are attractive to clinicians, because most are cordless
and should create less heat within tooth structure. However, questions about polymerization
efficacy have surrounded this technology. This research evaluated the adequacy of the depth of
cure of pit & fissure sealants provided by LED curing units. Optilux (OP) and Elipar Highlight
(HL) high intensity halogen and Astralis 5 (A5) conventional halogen lights were used for
comparison. The Light Emitting Diode (LED) curing units were Allegro (AL), LE Demetron I (DM),
FreeLight (FL), UltraLume 2(UL), UltraLume 5 (UL5) and VersaLux (VX). Sealants used in the study
were UltraSeal XT plus Clear (Uclr), Opaque (Uopq) and Teethmate F-1 Natural (Kclr) and Opaque
(Kopq). Specimens were fabricated in a brass mold (2 mm thick x 6 mm diameter) and placed between
two glass slides (n=5). Each specimen was cured from the top surface only. One hour after curing,
four Knoop Hardness readings were made for each top and bottom surface at least 1 mm from the
edge. The bottom to top (B/T) KHN ratio was calculated. Groups were fabricated with 20 and
40-second exposure times. In addition, a group using a 1 mm-thick mold was fabricated using an
exposure time of 20 seconds. Differences between lights for each material at each testing condition
were determined using one-way ANOVA and Student-Newman-Keuls Post-hoc test (a=0.05). There was no
statistical difference between light curing units for Uclr cured in a 1-mm thickness for 20 seconds
or cured in a 2 mm-thickness for 40 seconds. All other materials and conditions showed differences
between light curing units. Both opaque materials showed significant variations in B/T KHN ratios
dependent upon the light-curing unit.
Awards
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Dr Barry O Evans
Scott B Barrett
American Academy of Gold Foil Operators
Dr Michael A Cochran
Melvin R Lund
Abstracts
After endodontic therapy, teeth are often restored with a post and core. In many cases after post cementation, there is a gap between the apical end of the post and the remaining gutta percha. This study evaluated in vivo the outcome of endodontic therapy in teeth with varying amounts of space between cemented post and gutta percha.
A total of 94 patients, who had previously undergone endodontic therapy followed by post and core restoration, were selected. The group consisted of 26 males and 68 females, 23 to 88 years of age.
The endodontically treated teeth fit the following criteria:
All teeth had been cleaned and shaped under rubber dam isolation and obturated within 1 mm of the radiographic apex, using laterally condensed gutta percha with AH-26 sealer. Cases with complicating factors (separated files, over or underextension of root canal filling, root fracture, residual root canal fill<3 mm) were excluded.
The selected cases were divided into three groups, based on measurements from post-treatment radiographs:
Follow-up radiographs, taken between one and five years post-treatment, were evaluated according to the following criteria:
Radiographs were “masked” coronally with cardboard to reduce bias. Clinical outcomes related only to the roots in which posts were placed. The results were as follows:
This study illustrates the need to exhibit care when cementing posts in endodontically treated teeth, seating the post properly to eliminate space between the post and residual gutta percha.
This study evaluated the clinical performance of Procera AllCeram crowns placed over a five-year period at three different private dental practices.
Two-hundred and five Procera AllCeram crowns placed in 106 patients were evaluated over a period ranging from a minimum of six months to a maximum of 60 months, with a mean of 23.52 months. The clinical procedures were performed by three dentists in their private practices. The crowns were fabricated by three dental technicians following manufacturers’ instructions. One hundred and fifty-one crowns were cemented with Panavia 21 TC (Kuraray), 40 with Fuji Plus (GC) and 14 with RelyX Luting (3M). Patients were reexamined by the authors one month after cementation and at three or six-month intervals for the following period. A restoration was considered a failure when it impaired esthetic quality or function, thus necessitating remake of the crown. Patients with severe parafunction, periodontitis, serious gingival inflammation, or poor oral hygiene or caries were excluded from the study.
The survival rate was determined with the use of the Kaplan-Meier method, which gave an overall survival rate of 96.7% (100% for the anterior crowns and 95.15% for the posterior crowns). Of the 50 anterior crowns, there were no failures. Of the 155 posterior crowns, there were four failures. All four failures were molars. Two involved fracture of the veneer and alumina coping. One involved fracture of the veneering porcelain only, and one involved de-lamination of the veneering porcelain. The results of this study match results reported in other similar studies on Procera Allceram crowns. Within the limits of this study, it was concluded that the Procera AllCeram system seems to have a good prognosis for the posterior teeth and an excellent prognosis for the anterior teeth.
This study compared the microhardness of resin composite cured in simulated root canals using light-transmitting plastic posts (LTPP), glass-fiber-reinforced composite posts (GFRCP) and conventional light curing methods (control group).
Thirty black plastic cylinders, measuring 15 mm in length and 4 mm in internal diameter, were divided into three groups of 10 specimens each. Tetric Ceram (Ivoclar Vivadent) composite was firmly packed into the simulated canals. The LTTP (No 4, Luminex, Dentatus) and GFRCP (No 1, Postec, Ivoclar Vivodent) with the same diameters (1.5 mm) were inserted into the simulated canals using a parallelometer. All samples were then light cured (Hilux Dental Curing Light, Model No 200, Benlioglu Dental, Inc) with a constant-type exposure at 460 mW/cm2 for 90 seconds. After 24 hours, the plastic cylinders were removed from the samples and a microhardness test was performed using a Micromet Microhardness Tester (MMT-3 Digital Microhardness Tester, Buehler Ltd) with a load of 100 g for 10 seconds. Three test indentations of each sample were made at randomly selected areas of the polymerized resin composite samples at depths of 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 and 14 mm from the light exposed surface. All microhardness measurements were recorded as a Knoop Hardness Number (KHN), and the results were evaluated statistically using a one-way analysis of variance and the Tukey post hoc test between groups. Paired t-tests and repeated measure analysis were used to compare KHN within groups.
There was a significant increase in microhardness of the resin composite for both LTPP and GFRCP compared with the control group (p<0.01). The microhardness test could not be performed on the control group due to the lack of polymerization below 4 mm. There were no significant differences in microhardness between LTPP and GFRCP until 10 mm (p>0.01). At 10 mm, the microhardness of resin composite was significantly higher with LTPP than GFRCP (p<0.01). After 10 mm, the microhardness of GFRCP could not be performed because of the lack of polymerization. With increasing distance from the curing tip, the measurement of resin composite microhardness was decreased in all groups.
Conclusions
The depth of cure of resin composite in a simulated root canal is significantly increased with LTPP and GFRCP. After 10 mm, the polymerization of resin composite could not be achieved by GFRCP.
This study compared the effect of adhesive and flowable composites on post-operative sensitivity over a two-week interval. The authors state that post-operative sensitivity in posterior teeth restored with resin composites has been a problem experienced by clinicians for more than 15 years. Several factors, such as polymerization shrinkage, bulk filling technique, incomplete coating to the dentin surface with dentin adhesives and traumatic occlusion have been the culprit of the postoperative sensitivity.
Providers inserted 100 posterior composite restorations in Class II cavity preparations in patients’ molars and premolars, either to replace an existing faulty restoration or to treat primary carious lesions. Patients’ ages ranged from 20 to 54 years. All preparations were of conventional design, and cavosurface angles were entirely in enamel without any intentional bevel. All operative procedures were performed under local anesthesia with rubber dam isolation. The enamel and dentin walls of the preparation were treated either with a self-etching dentin/enamel primer (SE Primer, Kuraray America) for 20 seconds or were etched with 34% phosphoric acid (Caulk Etchant, Dentsply Caulk) for 15 seconds. While the self-etching primer was not rinsed, the phosphoric acid was washed for 10 seconds and the dentin was left visibly moist or was remoistened to an acceptable level prior to application of Prime & Bond NT (Dentsply Caulk). The flowable composite Filtek Flow (3M ESPE) was inserted as the first increment in the cervical area of each box for half of the restorations receiving each adhesive. The composite restorative SureFil (Dentsply Caulk) was then inserted in one increment (when the flowable material was used as the cervical increment) or two increments (when no flowable material was used). Each increment was polymerized for 40 seconds with a light source as recommended by manufacturer. Finishing and polishing were performed on each restoration.
The authors evaluated the restorations clinically for the following characteristics: a) marginal discoloration; b) post-operative sensitivity to air and cold and c) postoperative sensitivity to masticatory forces. The results were that all restorations had no discoloration at the post-operative period; change from baseline to two weeks in sensitivity for cold or air stimulus was not significant; there were no cases of post-operative sensitivity due to masticatory forces.
The authors found that there were no differences in post-operative sensitivity between a self-etch adhesive and a total-etch adhesive at two weeks. A flowable composite did not decrease post-operative sensitivity.
The investigators designed a project to determine if one type of x-ray film (D, E or F-speed category) or digital sensor provided a significant advantage over the others in detecting approximal caries. Forty molars and premolars were imaged using the same settings on the x-ray machine; 70kVp, 8mA and 16-inch focal spot-film distance. They varied the time of exposure to comply with manufacturers’ recommendations. The images were randomized and viewed under subdued lighting without the use of magnification or post-processing manipulation. Three clinicians graded the lesions using a five-point rating system. The teeth were then sectioned mesiodistally for microscopic evaluation to determine the true extent of caries.
There was no significant difference among the four diagnostic modalities in the ability to detect interproximal caries lesions. The dental professional has an obligation to produce radiographs of the highest diagnostic quality using the least amount of radiation. Insight film and RVG produced diagnostic images comparable to Ultraspeed and Ektaspeed Plus film utilizing reduced radiation exposure times.
(C) Operative Dentistry, 2006